Scottish misogyny law must protect all women, says Helena Kennedy

QC discusses the task ahead as she begins her scrutiny into whether Scotland needs a separate offence of misogynist abuse

There should be no limits of the types of women protected from hate crime says Baroness Helena Kennedy QC, as she begins her consideration of whether Scotland requires a standalone offence to tackle misogynist abuse.

“It’s the perception of the perpetrator that matters here,” says the human rights QC, who is well aware that her appointment to lead an independent working group on the question coincides with a toxic row about the Scottish government’s hate crime bill more broadly, and its protections for both women and transgender individuals.

There is an attempt to bridge this deepening schism on Monday, when the Scottish government’s new draft free-speech amendment will be discussed at a public roundtable.

But Kennedy is immediately clear on how she would define the scope of specific protection she is charged with: “This is about hatred. Trans women, gay women, journalists, parliamentarians, all women get a whole lot of horrible stuff slung at them – disproportionately – and I’m not narrowing down those who receive it.”

In her first interview since the appointment earlier this month, Kennedy also sets out plans to call social media chiefs to explain why they are failing to tackle “vile abuse” of women online, and reveals that she was recently advised to carry an attack alarm after receiving a threat at the House of Lords.

Describing it as an ambitious project to protect women, Kennedy and her six-person panel – “hand-picked by me” – have a year to resolve whether the creation of a standalone offence or adding sex to the list of other protected characteristics, such as race and religion, would better tackle misogynist abuse.

While a working definition of misogyny is for the panel to deliberate, Kennedy suggests it should target conduct like street harassment, sexual bullying in the workplace and online abuse of women in public life. She particularly mentions a survey published last week by Holyrood magazine, which found almost a third of female MSPs who responded had received a threat of sexual violence.

She is clear about the significant and long-lasting impact of such hatred: “It ends up eating away at your self-confidence, your sense of safety, it creates fear and anxiety … We’re talking about the whole backdrop of inequality and how women are treated in society.”

Calls to treat misogynist abuse – and in particular street harassment – separately in law have been spearheaded by community organiser Citizens UK and the Labour MP Stella Creasy, with growing public support, and last autumn the Law Commission recommended that misogyny should be made a hate crime in England and Wales.

The Scottish government’s own hate crime bill has attracted a huge amount of controversy and, while it was always the intention to examine this standalone option, the timing is far from ideal. As it stands, the bill that is passing through Holyrood criminalises, among other things, the stirring up of hatred against cross-dressing people, thereby protecting men who dress as women, but not the stirring up of hatred against women, while the decision on protections for women won’t be made until Kennedy’s working group reports back in 12 months’ time.

Kennedy refuses to be drawn on the timing – “I’m not even going there” – but, asked what her reassurance would be for women concerned that the new bill does not protect them, she says: “I’m sure that’s precisely why I was asked to look at whether women should just be added on [to the list of protected characteristics] or there should be a much more ambitious project to protect women. Going into the difficult areas is not something that I mind doing.”

Although the concept was initially trivialised by the media as “arrests for wolf-whistling”, many police forces in England now record street harassment of women, for example, as a hate crime, following a groundbreaking pilot in Nottingham in 2016.

“There is also no doubt that law can be hugely symbolic and it can concentrate the mind,” adding she is certain that the Law Commission will be “looking over our shoulder”. She will be seeking evidence from the Nottingham force, as well as other common law jurisdictions such as Australia and Canada that have introduced similar legislation.

“What you don’t want is for it to be used in a way that brings it into disrepute, where someone makes a kissy noise and finds the heavy hand of the law on their shoulder. What we’re really talking about here is the sort of abuse that ends up putting people in fear, that denigrates and reduces women.”

Kennedy herself recently received a threatening letter from a man who had served a long sentence for attempted murder of a woman, which she brought to the attention of the parliamentary authorities. She was given a personal alarm by the police. “Women in the public domain carry those risks,” she says. “It affects your life.”

• This article was amended on 22 February 2021 to clarify that the reference to the criminalisation of the stirring up of hatred against men who dress as women is specifically in relation to the protection the bill offers to people who cross-dress.


Libby Brooks

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
EU citizens should collect proof of living in UK, says Helena Kennedy
Lords Brexit reports: QC advises making file of documents as Lords committee she chairs calls on PM to safeguard rights of EU nationals in Britain

Anushka Asthana Political editor

14, Dec, 2016 @12:01 AM

Article image
Review brings misogyny as a hate crime a step closer
Campaigners hail ‘amazing’ victory as government move to protect women from street sex harassment is announced

Libby Brooks

05, Sep, 2018 @11:24 PM

Article image
Helena Kennedy | Top 100 women
Human rights lawyer who originally worked on sex-discrimination cases before setting up Doughty Street chambers

Homa Khaleeli

08, Mar, 2011 @12:05 AM

Article image
Helena Kennedy: ‘Brexit is a disaster for women’
The barrister’s fights for equality and justice made her a household name. But, she says, leaving the EU could set everything back decades

Zoe Williams

09, Oct, 2018 @9:00 AM

Article image
Misogyny 'should become a hate crime in England and Wales'
Law Commission, which recommends legal changes, calls for sex or gender to be protected trait

Jamie Grierson Home affairs correspondent

22, Sep, 2020 @11:01 PM

Article image
London bus attack victims join campaign to make misogyny a hate crime
Increase in violence against women during lockdown makes new law imperative, says MP Stella Creasy

Alexandra Topping

10, Sep, 2020 @5:00 AM

Labour peer Helena Kennedy denies organising against party

Helena Kennedy leads campaign for referendum on parliamentary reform, believing system 'close to collapse'

Allegra Stratton, political correspondent

25, May, 2009 @8:58 PM

Article image
Helena Kennedy: ‘We’re making a society that’s hard, where only money matters’
The principal of Mansfield College, Oxford, never went to university, but she is determined people from all backgrounds should have the opportunity to learn

Peter Wilby

07, Mar, 2017 @7:30 AM

Article image
Nottingham women welcome 'victory' in bid to treat misogyny as hate crime
Local pilot scheme led to a change in government policy on police data to help tackle abuse

Libby Brooks

21, Mar, 2021 @3:01 PM

Article image
Sexting between children not automatically a crime, says CPS
New guidelines published to help prosecutors decide when to act on reports of online harassment and abuse

Owen Bowcott Legal affairs correspondent

09, Oct, 2016 @11:01 PM