The Stansted 15 activists should be supported, not punished | Letters

Supporters including Diane Abbott, Phillip Pullman, Emma Thompson and Caroline Lucas write in defence of the 15 human rights activists who acted to stop a ‘brutal, secretive and barely legal deportation flight’ last year

We the undersigned express our deep concern and disagreement with the recent prosecutions at Chelmsford crown court against the 15 human rights activists who acted to stop a brutal, secretive and barely legal deportation flight last year (Report, 11 December). The “Stansted 15” have been convicted of “endangering an aerodrome” under the Aviation and Maritime Security Act 1990 – a terrorism-related law. The use of this draconian legislation is grossly disproportionate and a clear abuse of power.

Helen, Joe, Lyndsay, Ben, Mel, Nathan, Laura, Jo, Nick, Ali, Eddie, Emma, May, Ruth and Melanie chained themselves around a deportation charter flight bound for Nigeria and Ghana in March 2017 with the sincere belief that they were preventing the 60 people on board from coming to harm. As a result of their 10-hour blockade, 11 people – including victims of trafficking recognised under the Modern Slavery Act – are still here in the UK with their loved ones.

This group of ordinary people took extraordinary and peaceful action in the knowledge that they were saving lives. But now they face prison sentences. It is the UK government’s brutal and unjust “hostile environment” that should be found guilty of endangering human lives, and not the peaceful efforts of 15 people to keep them safer. The UK is the only country in Europe to lock up people with uncertain immigration status indefinitely; 3,000 people are incarcerated in immigration prisons in the UK at any one time.

The UK is also one of the few to fill chartered planes with deportees when legal cases are still unresolved. Nearly half (47%) of all appeals to deportation decisions last year were successful and 75% of Home Office appeals on immigration decisions are rejected. The Windrush scandal has shown us that the UK immigration system violates human rights. The Home Office constantly racially profiles, uses unfair targets, and victimises and expels people who have the right to live here.

We call on the UK government to end its inhumane hostile environment policies and to end its shameful deportation charter flights. We also call for the Stansted 15 to be spared prison. They did not aim to inconvenience people, and this arduous trial has had such a profound impact on their lives that they are unlikely to take such action again. The Stansted 15 are a credit to human rights. They and their intentions should be supported, not punished.

Diane Abbott MP Shadow home secretary, Shami Chakrabarti Shadow attorney general, Caroline Lucas MP, Naomi Klein Writer, Alice Walker Writer, Akala Hip-hop artist and author, Emma Thompson Actor, Prof Angela Davis Writer and activist, Phillip Pullman Author, Brian Eno Musician, Manual Cortes General secretary, TSSA, Peter Gabriel Musician and more than 300 others (see

• My heart goes out to the men and women found guilty of terror-related charges for attempting to stop the deportation of people who are victims of the government’s hostile environment policy. Some of those people on the stopped plane are still in England and have a legal right to remain. Hence the actions taken by the Stansted 15 prevented immoral illegal deportations and are for, not against, the national interest.

If the government was not operating in such a rogue fashion such counter-measures would not be necessary. This is a bleak period in our history and these brave men and women shine a light on the opaque, harmful actions of a government that have led to deaths and the breakdown of families and communities across the UK. They should be commended, not incarcerated.
Holly Hope-Smith

• On 2 July 2018 the National Democracy Week Awards were announced, timed to mark the 90th anniversary of the 1928 Equal Franchise Act. The Collaboration of the Year award is given to individuals or organisations that have come together to reach a shared goal. This year it was awarded to the People’s History museum. But who will win next year? There’s still time to nominate the Stansted 15 who have come together for a peaceful protest to protect human rights in the UK. The outcome of their protest has been outstanding, with 11 people who would have been deported still here and appealing their deportation. One deportee wrote in the Guardian: “They are heroes … they helped me see justice - and the birth of my daughter”.

Just like the suffragettes, the Stansted 15 now face draconian convictions for peaceful defence of human rights in the UK. All the more reason to nominate this group for the 2019 Collaboration of the Year award.
Dr John Bremner

• Join the debate – email

• Read more Guardian letters – click here to visit

• Do you have a photo you’d like to share with Guardian readers? Click here to upload it and we’ll publish the best submissions in the letters spread of our print edition


The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
The Guardian view on the Stansted 15: a sledgehammer prosecution | Editorial
Editorial: The activists who blocked a deportation flight from departing were charged under legislation introduced to counter terrorist threats. Their case sets a chilling precedent


11, Dec, 2018 @6:27 PM

Article image
Grief and pride of the Stansted 15’s parents | Letters
Letters: Parents of the protesters convicted this week say that the group has upheld the values of social justice and human rights on behalf of us all


13, Dec, 2018 @4:43 PM

Article image
Standing with the Stansted 15 activists | Letter
Letter: Emma Jones praises the heroism of the activists who could face lengthy jail sentences after trying to prevent deportations


30, Sep, 2018 @5:41 PM

Article image
The Stansted 15 stood up for justice. And now I stand up for them | Letter from Catherine West MP
Letter: Activists who peacefully seek to defend people’s right of access to justice should not be facing the prospect of life imprisonment under legislation designed to tackle terrorism, writes the Labour MP Catherine West


11, Jan, 2019 @4:49 PM

Article image
Secret deportation flights must stop | Letters
Letters: David Ramsbotham, Caroline Lucas, Naomi Klein and Philip Pullman are among those calling for charges against the Stansted 15 activists to be dropped and for the Home Office to cease chartering flights for deportation


16, Mar, 2018 @3:06 PM

Article image
We in the Stansted 15 have been treated like terrorists | Emma Hughes
My sentence of community service is nothing compared with the suffering of deportees, says the activist Emma Hughes

Emma Hughes

06, Feb, 2019 @5:17 PM

Article image
The Stansted protesters saved me from wrongful deportation. They are heroes | Anonymous
The ‘Stansted 15’ face jail for stopping my flight from taking off. But without them, I’d have missed my daughter’s birth


10, Dec, 2018 @1:55 PM

Article image
Children hit by UK’s hostile environment | Letters
Letters from Bruce Ross-Smith and Dr Paquita de Zulueta


24, Sep, 2018 @5:37 PM

Article image
How the Gatwick drone saga broke my family’s hearts | Letters
Letters: The cancelling of flights at Gatwick ruined Christmas for 16-year-old Tivka Dillner’s family; Judith Martin on why Liz Truss is the woman to consult on drones; plus letters from Christine Bainbridge, Jol Miskin, Terry Hunt, Mike Evans, Brian Robinson, Alec Mitchell and Ruth Coppard


21, Dec, 2018 @4:48 PM

Article image
Stansted 15: no jail for activists convicted of terror-related offences
Judge says group ‘didn’t have a grievous intent as some may who commit this type of crime’

Damien Gayle

06, Feb, 2019 @3:48 PM