Yazidi women kept as slaves by IS appeal to UN to intervene in their fight for compensation

Lawyers demand support from Australia for five victims of Khaled Sharrouf in test case for international law on torture survivors

Five Yazidi women held as slaves by an Islamic State fighter are appealing to the UN to intervene in their case for compensation in a move lawyers hope will help fix a “lawless” global system that is failing torture survivors.

The women, captured in Iraq in 2014, were taken to Syria as slaves by IS fighters, including the Australian citizen Khaled Sharrouf, who was pictured standing next to his young son holding a severed human head.

The women, in a case due to be filed next week, want the UN’s Committee Against Torture to remind Australia of its obligation to provide survivors of violence with redress under the UN’s torture convention, which the country has ratified. The Australian authorities have so far denied all requests for compensation.

Lawyers had argued that the women were entitled to compensation under New South Wales law because Sharrouf was born in Sydney and NSW was his last known place of residence. The NSW Victims Rights and Supports Act entitles survivors to $10,000 and other means of support. However, the Australian courts, including the high court, ruled against the women.

Philippe Sands KC, one of the lawyers leading the case, said the purpose of taking the complaint to the UN committee is to end the impunity of western governments who have pledged to support Yazidis in their quest for justice.

“You’ve got a situation of utter lawlessness in which western governments who have committed to rooting it out seem unwilling to take responsibility to provide the institutional and financial mechanisms to deliver on that commitment. If there’s a gap, and unless that gap is filled, you have impunity and more lawlessness,” said Sands.

“The legal framework as it stands seems incapable of delivering, so this application is intended to fill that gap and seek to recognise the responsibility of a state like Australia to ensure that justice is done for the victims.”

In their complaint to the UN, the women argue that Sharrouf’s crimes were of universal jurisdiction, and Australia’s obligation to act under the torture convention is not limited by territory. They also state that Australia had failed to prevent Sharrouf from leaving the country, despite previous arrests for terror offences.

Yasmin Waljee, the international pro bono partner at the law firm Hogan Lovells, which is representing the women, said the women cannot be compensated by IS or the perpetrator, as Sharrouf is presumed to have been killed in a 2017 US airstrike. Waljee said the case highlighted how difficult it is for survivors to access compensation, even when their abuse had been widely condemned.

“We’ve got women who experienced sexual violence and violence generally as part of this horrific movement which the world condemned, and yet they’ve left the victims on their own without any remedy,” said Waljee. “It’s shocking – you’re dealing with post-traumatic stress, suicides, all sorts of horrendous long-term impacts.”

Waljee said survivors have short and long-term needs – like healthcare, mental health support and accommodation – that require money. While a positive ruling from the UN committee cannot compel Australia to provide compensation, she said, a finding that the government had breached the convention against torture would be “a move forward” in international law.

“It is important that the experience of these courageous women is widely recognised, documented and remembered. If we don’t draw these issues into the light, there’s no hope that improvements will ever be made,” said Waljee. “The world condemned this movement [IS] and continues to condemn it, but then doesn’t try to support the victims in any way.”

Lawyers believe the outcome of this case can have implications for survivors of violence in other conflicts, especially those by non-state militias.

Erin Rosenberg, senior legal adviser to the DRC-based Mukwege Foundation, said: “Right now in the Democratic Republic of the Congo, for example, one of the most vicious and brutal is a non-state actor, M23. It’s crucial that victims could be provided with redress even when the perpetrator is a terrorist or militia.”

Rosenberg, who previously worked at the international criminal court, said that international justice is too focused on prosecuting individuals for crimes against humanity and does not offer enough support for victims. The need for compensation is recognised by most countries but, in reality, few are willing to pay.

“We see a lot of rhetoric from a lot of states about the idea of a victim-centred approach, ensuring victims are provided with redress and able to rebuild their lives, but these talking points are often deprioritised when it comes down to the nuts and bolts of paying,” she said.


Kaamil Ahmed

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
UK government faces calls to shelter Yazidi refugees persecuted by Isis
MPs urge home secretary to extend resettlement scheme to members of Iraq’s Yazidi community, many of whom have suffered rape, torture and sexual slavery

Karen McVeigh

26, Nov, 2016 @9:00 AM

Article image
'Tonight I'm going to die': the Iraqi women targeted by rapists
Amnesty reports that women suspected of Isis links face sexual violence in IDP camps, amid claims they are being denied aid

Peter Beaumont

17, Apr, 2018 @5:00 AM

Article image
Nadia Murad says UK could save lives of Yazidi women by admitting refugees
Isis survivor who escaped sexual enslavement urges UK to follow Germany in offering refuge to Yazidi women and girls persecuted in Iraq

Liz Ford

09, Dec, 2016 @9:00 AM

Article image
Germany opens its doors to Yazidi women and children enslaved by Isis | Lara Whyte
Secret shelters in Baden-Württemberg support some of the 2,500 deeply traumatised women and children who have escaped Isis in northern Iraq

Lara Whyte in Stuttgart

02, Mar, 2016 @7:00 AM

Article image
Charity helping Yazidi survivors of Isis sexual slavery shut down
Kurdish authorities’ closure of Yazda leaves more than 1,200 women and children without any support, say activists

Emma Graham-Harrison

12, Jan, 2017 @6:00 AM

Article image
‘Still going through hell’: the search for Yazidi women seven years on
As two women are rescued in Syria after being kidnapped by Isis years earlier, Yazidis renew calls for international help to find the thousands still unaccounted for

Kate Denereaz

03, Aug, 2021 @9:01 AM

Article image
‘I watched my family die’: Shatila refugees' suffering laid bare
Cartoonist Ella Baron travelled to Shatila refugee camp in Beirut, Lebanon, to hear the stories of women at Médecins Sans Frontières’ women’s health clinic

Ella Baron

04, Oct, 2018 @6:00 AM

Article image
Makeshift justice the only recourse for ill-protected women at South Sudan camp | Ben Quinn
For women who routinely run the gauntlet of harassment and sexual violence, Malakal protection of civilians camp has roundly failed to live up to its name

Ben Quinn in Malakal

16, Jan, 2017 @7:00 AM

Article image
Women saved from Boko Haram claim soldiers made them trade sex for food
Amnesty investigation alleges ‘horrendous abuse’ by Nigerian military in camps where thousands reportedly died of hunger

Kate Hodal

24, May, 2018 @10:51 AM

Article image
Conflict drives global rise in sexual violence against women
Study identifies DRC, India and South Sudan among countries where women are at highest risk of attack

Rod Austin

28, Jun, 2019 @8:00 AM