Pakistan sends back hundreds of Afghan refugees to face Taliban repression

About 250,000 Afghan asylum seekers have arrived in Pakistan since August 2021, but a migrant crackdown has left many of them in fear of being jailed or deported

More than 600 Afghans have been deported from Pakistan in the past three days, and hundreds more face expulsion in a renewed crackdown on migrants.

On Saturday, 302 people were sent back to Afghanistan from Sindh province and 303 on Monday, including 63 women and 71 children. A further 800 people are expected to be deported in the coming days.

About 250,000 Afghans have arrived in Pakistan since the Taliban seized power in August 2021.

Last summer, authorities began deporting Afghans for illegally entering the country, but arrests and detentions have increased since October. Nearly 1,400 Afghans, including 129 women and 178 children, have been detained in Karachi and Hyderabad alone, the largest number of arrests made to date in Pakistan, say lawyers.

Pakistan has not adopted the UN Refugee Convention 1951, which confers a legal duty on countries to protect people fleeing serious harm.

Moniza Kakar, a Karachi-based human rights lawyer, said nearly 400 of the arrested Afghans had valid visas on their passports or proof-of-residence cards, which they said were confiscated by police before they were jailed.

Afghan women and children sitting on the floor in a prison in Karachi.
In December last year, photos of Afghan women and children imprisoned in Karachi went viral. Photograph: Handout

Umer Ijaz Gilani, an Islamabad-based lawyer, said deporting Afghan asylum seekers was a “clear violation of the non-refoulement principle” (forcibly returning refugees or asylum seekers where they may be persecuted). He urged the Pakistan government’s National Commission for Human Rights (NCHR) to direct state authorities to stop the deportations.

“The NCHR has the jurisdiction … if it fails to exercise it, we might go to the high court,” said Gilani, who is supporting 100 Afghan human rights defenders seeking asylum in Islamabad. He said his clients were extremely disturbed about the arrests in Sindh.

Farah Zia, the director of the independent Human Rights Commission of Pakistan, condemned the treatment of Afghans, particularly the arrests of women and children “because their vulnerability is compounded by their gender and age and lack of connections with local networks”.

In December, leaked photos of imprisoned women and children in Karachi went viral.

Last year, the commission wrote to the government, urging it to develop a more humane policy towards Afghan refugees.

The Sindh authorities have defended their actions. “The government is only taking action against illegal immigrants; those living without a valid travel document,” said their spokesperson Murtaza Wahab.

Nida Amiri*, a registered asylum seeker in Karachi, told of “sleepless nights” since the crackdown. Her husband, a prominent government official, is in hiding in Afghanistan. “I have headaches, and my blood pressure refuses to come down,” said Amiri, 47, who left Kabul in December 2021 and is now working as a cook.

She added: “I would rather die in prison than return to Kabul, where we cannot even breathe freely.”

She has a registration card from the Society for Human Rights and Prisoners’ Aid (Sharp), which partners with the UN high commissioner for refugees (UNHCR) to initially assess asylum cases. But a Sharp employee said the card “cannot save her from being hauled in”.

Nida Amiri and her daugther Afshaneh Noor
Nida Amiri and her daugther Afshaneh Noor. Photograph: Zofeen Ebrahim

Amiri’s 21-year old daughter, Afshaneh Noor, said that living in Pakistan may not be easy, but if she was sent back she would be “a prisoner in my home”. “It’s the worst place on Earth to be in for a woman, right now,” she said.

Her 14-year-old sister and nine-year-old brother are no longer allowed to go to school, she said, because their mother is so worried they’ll be detained. “She has told us to always carry the Sharp card and to avoid leaving the home unless absolutely necessary,” said Noor. “We tell people we are from Chitral [a region in northern Pakistan bordering Afghanistan].”

Nadera Najeeb*, 43, a widow and mother of six, belongs to the Hazara community, a predominantly Shia Muslim minority group persecuted by the Taliban. She entered Pakistan illegally with five of her children – two sons and three daughters – two months ago. “I was forced to run away, otherwise my daughters would be raped by the Taliban,” she said. Before leaving, she married her eldest daughter to a cousin’s son, leaving her in Kabul.

Nadera Najeeb and five of her six children.
Nadera Najeeb: ‘I took this difficult journey to keep my kids safe.’ Photograph: Zofeen Ebrahim

Najeeb, who works at a fishery in Karachi, has begun to wear a black abaya – a long, loose coat that covers her head and face so that only her eyes show. “This way no one can tell I’m an Afghan or belong to the Hazara community,” she said. “I took this difficult journey to keep my kids safe; if we’re put behind bars and then sent back, all this will be for nothing.”

Qaiser Khan Afridi, a UNHCR spokesperson, said the organisation is working to identify the most vulnerable asylum cases for resettlement, including women-headed households and families with children at risk. The UNHCR was striving to find “durable solutions” for refugees, but it was up to governments to grant asylum.

“Resettlement, unfortunately, cannot be available for the entire refugee population as the opportunities are limited,” he said.

*Names have been changed to protect identities


Zofeen T Ebrahim in Karachi

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
UN accused of failing Afghan refugees 'forced' to return home from Pakistan
UNHCR cites behind-scenes advocacy after rights group claims it has left Afghan refugees at risk of persecution by failing to condemn ‘campaign of abuse’

Sune Engel Rasmussen in Kabul

13, Feb, 2017 @11:35 AM

Article image
Afghan exodus from Pakistan could be 'catastrophic' without urgent aid
With political tension forcing half a million people to return to Afghanistan, the World Food Programme warns the freezing winter could prove deadly

Matthew Green in Kabul

04, Oct, 2016 @6:00 AM

Article image
Selfies with the Taliban: Afghan women buoyed by ceasefire snaps | Ruchi Kumar
When Taliban fighters entered the cities of Afghanistan after hostilities were put on hold for Eid, some women took photos that quickly went viral

Ruchi Kumar in Kabul

06, Jul, 2018 @11:18 AM

Article image
US warns Afghan women of increased risk of extremist attack
Message from the US embassy comes during long-postponed direct talks between the government and the Taliban

Stefanie Glinski in Kabul

18, Sep, 2020 @2:26 PM

Article image
Pakistan crackdown on Afghan refugees leaves ‘four dead’ and thousands in cells
Asylum seekers in Karachi tell of terror of being sent back to the Taliban and despair at being shackled and held in Pakistani jails

Shah Meer Baloch in Pakistan

02, Mar, 2023 @12:00 PM

Article image
'Now is not the time': violence forces refugees to flee Afghanistan again
Political rhetoric about country’s safety dismissed after study shows 72% of returnees forced into renewed flight

Karen McVeigh

25, Jan, 2018 @9:00 AM

Article image
Exiled from Pakistan, destitute Afghans return to a country at war
Hundreds of thousands of Afghans, banished from Pakistan, find destruction, violence and hardship in their homeland

Sune Engel Rasmussen in Nangarhar

06, Oct, 2016 @6:00 AM

Article image
'Shot at by both sides': Families flee as Taliban battles for territory in Kandahar

Villages in southern Afghanistan have become frontline of conflict as peace talks stall and uncertainty surrounds US withdrawal

Charlie Faulkner in Kandahar

24, Feb, 2021 @7:15 AM

Article image
‘I am not afraid to fight’: the female Afghan colonel who survived the Taliban's assassins
Saba Sahar, who returned fire while protecting her daughter, survived one of a wave of recent assassination attempts that have killed six policewomen

Ruchi Kumar

24, Dec, 2020 @7:30 AM

Article image
Afghan clerics in talks with Isis to break polio vaccine myths
Islamic clerics consult with Taliban and Islamic State to ensure immunisation campaign goes ahead despite scepticism and distrust

Haroon Janjua in Islamabad

27, Mar, 2018 @11:36 AM