‘Shocking blow to Indigenous land rights’ as court dismisses Maasai herder claim

Herders lodge appeal against ruling in their case against the Tanzanian government, which they say is violently evicting them from ancestral land

Lawyers for Maasai herders who say the Tanzanian government is trying to violently evict them from their ancestral land to make way for a luxury game reserve have lodged an appeal against a court ruling that dismissed their case.

Donald Deya, lead counsel for the herders and chief executive officer of the Pan-African Lawyers Union (Palu), said his team had, on Wednesday, appealed against the verdict of the east African court of justice, which campaigners branded “a shocking blow” to Indigenous land rights.

In a statement issued by Palu earlier this week, the Maasai communities were said to be “dissatisfied and disappointed” by the ruling, which they felt “disregarded the compelling multitude” of evidence they presented in court.

The legal battle dates back to 2017, when residents of four Maasai villages in northern Tanzania went to court to try to stop the authorities evicting them from 580 sq miles (1,500 sq km) of land in Loliondo, bordering the Serengeti national park. If carried out, more than 70,000 Maasai would be affected by the move.

The government says the land is within the park and should, therefore, be given over solely to conservation purposes rather than being disrupted by human activity. But the herders say the land has been rightfully theirs for generations and accuse the authorities of wanting to use it to create a luxury game reserve run by a UAE-owned company.

They are seeking recourse for the allegedly violent evictions of 2017, which they claim included the burning of their homes and the confiscation of their livestock. The government denies this.

Although the court issued an interim order in 2018 that stopped evictions, tensions reached boiling point in June of this year, when violent clashes re-erupted between police and Maasai demonstrators after authorities began to demarcate land boundaries.

In its ruling on Friday, the court found that the Maasai had failed to prove they had been evicted from their village land and not from the Serengeti itself. The court also found that witnesses who alleged violent evictions had failed to give evidence proving injury or loss.

The judgment was condemned by campaigners.

“The failure of the east African court of justice to hold the Tanzanian government accountable for blatantly abusing human rights of the Maasai in Loliondo is a travesty for all Indigenous communities on the continent,” said Anuradha Mittal, executive director of the Oakland Institute.

Fiore Longo, from Survival International, an indigenous rights advocacy group, told Reuters: “The court has given a strong signal to the international community that evictions and human rights abuses against Indigenous peoples should be tolerated if they are done in the name of protecting nature.”

There was no immediate comment from Tanzania’s government.

Associated Press and Reuters contributed to this report


Lizzy Davies and agencies

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Tanzania charges 20 Maasai with murder after police officer dies during protests
Lawyers say government is attempting to intimidate pastoralists as thousands flee to Kenya amid escalating row over evictions

Caroline Kimeu in Nairobi

23, Jun, 2022 @8:00 AM

Article image
'Land means life': Tanzania's Maasai fear their existence is under threat
Reports that homes belonging to Maasai people were torched have upped the stakes in their long-running land dispute with the Tanzanian government

Karen McVeigh

16, Oct, 2017 @6:00 AM

Article image
Tanzania drops murder charges against 24 Maasai leaders
The pastoralists had been detained over the death of a police officer during protests against government plans to evict them from ancestral land

Caroline Kimeu in Nairobi

25, Nov, 2022 @12:27 PM

Article image
Tanzania’s Maasai appeal to west to stop eviction for conservation plans
Thousands of Indigenous people sign letter to UK, US and EU protesting at appropriation of land for tourist safaris and hunting

Katie McQue

22, Apr, 2022 @6:30 AM

Article image
Brazilian supreme court upholds land rights of indigenous people
Land rights activists applaud rejection of case brought by Brazilian state that claimed it was due compensation for award of territory to native inhabitants

Jo Griffin

17, Aug, 2017 @2:47 PM

Article image
Tanzanian land rights victory earns Masaai leader Goldman prize
Edward Loure wins leading environmental award after helping communities in Tanzanian Rift Valley secure legal title to ancestral land

John Vidal

18, Apr, 2016 @3:01 AM

Article image
Mexican tourism boom: Tulum’s locals fight evictions as developers move in
Indigenous people in the tourist hotspot on the Riviera Maya face losing their homes as land is sold for luxury housing

Mattha Busby

29, Sep, 2022 @5:30 AM

Article image
Maasai herders driven off land to make way for luxury safaris, report says
Tanzanian government accused of putting indigenous people at risk in order to grant foreign tourists access to Serengeti wildlife

Jonathan Watts Global environment correspondent

10, May, 2018 @10:00 AM

Article image
Indigenous peoples to get $1.7bn in recognition of role in protecting forests
Cop26 pledge cautiously welcomed as ‘first step’ in making indigenous rights central to climate crisis talks

Phoebe Weston

01, Nov, 2021 @10:30 PM

Article image
Illegal logging threatens Cambodia’s indigenous people, says Amnesty
Country’s ‘corrupt’ approach to conservation leaves protected forests facing ‘oblivion’, human rights watchdog warns

Sarah Johnson

28, Jan, 2022 @9:54 AM