Illegal donkey-skin trade thriving on social networks, report reveals

About 4.8 million animals are killed each year largely driven by Chinese demand for traditional medicine, says charity

The illegal sale of donkey skins is thriving in online marketplaces, with traders openly flouting local laws, and social media multinationals such as Facebook doing little to prevent the illegal trade, according to a new investigation.

Traders on Facebook are offering large quantities of donkey skins on the site, the report said, including one in Kenya, where the sale is effectively banned, who listed 2,000 for immediate sale. The report found large numbers of sellers in countries that have bans on the donkey skin trade, including Kenya, Nigeria, Burkina Faso, Senegal and Ghana.

In its report, the Donkey Sanctuary charity said traders promoted the sale of donkey skins on Facebook, YouTube, Twitter and Instagram. It said the algorithms used by social media companies made it easy for buyers to find sellers.

An estimated 4.8 million donkeys are killed for the trade every year, according to the report, a demand partly sustained by raids on farmers who depend on the animals for their livelihoods.

The trafficking feeds a rising demand for ejiao, a traditional Chinese remedy that uses donkey skins to produce a form of gelatine. Despite only 20 countries having deals to legally trade donkey skins with China, skins arrive there from more than 50 countries, says the charity.

The report, published on Sunday, is the first to reveal the scale of the trade, which is entangled with organised crime syndicates, international drug trafficking and the illegal trade in endangered animals and animal parts.

Ejiao, a traditional Chinese remedy produced from donkey skins.
Ejiao, a traditional Chinese remedy produced from donkey skins. Photograph: The Donkey Sanctuary

Investigators for the charity found 382 traders who sold donkey skins and other trafficked wildlife on e-commerce sites, some of whom also sold drugs, human hair and fake passports.

The report said some traders also operated on the dark web, and many used established drug-trafficking networks to transport the hides. In cases where exporting donkey skins was legal, the report found the goods were bundled with other illegal wildlife items, or illegal drugs.

It also said websites were failing to clamp down on the illegal trade, despite it being clear from listings that sellers were aware of the laws, with many promising to package the hides carefully to avoid detection. Marianne Steele, the charity’s acting CEO, said: “By cracking down on the sale of donkey skins on their platforms, e-commerce and social media [firms] will not only prevent considerable cruelty, but also help eliminate the other criminal activity that is taking place alongside it.”

In an accompanying study on the link between the donkey trade and global wildlife trafficking, the University of Oxford’s Saïd Business School and Wildlife Conservation Research Unit found 15,000 items for sale on seven websites, alongside postings offering 13 endangered species.

Donkey skins are laid out in the sun to dry at a slaughterhouse in Kenya.
Donkey skins are laid out in the sun to dry at a slaughterhouse in Kenya. Photograph: Courtesy of The Donkey Sanctuary

“Our work brings together concerns about wildlife conservation, animal welfare and the wellbeing of some of the world’s poorest communities, all around the unexpected focal point of donkeys,” said Dr Ewan Macdonald, postdoctoral research fellow at Saïd Business School.

Macdonald said 20% of traders also sold other trafficked wildlife products, including pangolin scales and elephant ivory.

Last month, campaign group Avaaz said it had documented a thriving marketplace for wildlife trafficking on Facebook, finding tiger cubs, leopards, ocelots, African grey parrots and the pygmy marmoset, the world’s smallest monkey.

In response to the Avaaz report, Facebook’s parent company, Meta, questioned the validity of the study’s methodology and sample size, and said the results did not reflect the work they had done to combat wildlife trafficking, including removing content and launching strategies to discourage people from participating in the trade. “This is an adversarial space though, and the people behind this awful activity are persistent and constantly evolving their tactics to try and evade these efforts,” said a spokesperson.

Meta did not respond to the claims made in the Donkey Sanctuary report about the use of its platform for the sale of donkey skins in countries where it is illegal.


Kaamil Ahmed

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Illegal trade in rhino horn thriving in China, NGO investigation reveals
Elephant Action League’s sting operation shows how horns are trafficked from Africa and enter into China via Vietnam, alleging official complicity

Andrea Crosta

18, Jul, 2017 @4:46 PM

Article image
Illegal wildlife trading in internet's deepest, darkest corners

Organised wildlife criminals are using online tools more commonly associated with serious financial crime, drug trafficking and child pornography

Nic Fleming

04, Sep, 2012 @7:00 AM

Article image
Chinese medicine fuelling rise in donkey slaughter for global skin trade
Demand for hide, used to make traditional ejiao, has raised the price and rate of slaughter of donkeys, endangering the livelihoods of those who rely on them

Katherine Purvis

29, Jan, 2017 @12:07 PM

Article image
Illegal wildlife trade 'threatening national security', says WWF

Group says organised crime syndicates are 'outgunning' governments, leading to sharp rise in elephant and rhino deaths

Suzanne Goldenberg US environment correspondent

12, Dec, 2012 @7:00 AM

Article image
$213bn illegal wildlife and charcoal trade 'funding global terror groups'
Somalia's Al-Qaeda linked terror group al-Shabaab relies on charcoal as its primary source of finance, UN and Interpol report says

Hannah McNeish in Nairobi

24, Jun, 2014 @4:08 PM

Article image
WildLeaks attracts major wildlife crime leads in first three months
WikiLeaks-style website yields 24 tip-offs including elephant poaching, tiger killing, illegal fishery and forest destruction

Damian Carrington

12, Jun, 2014 @12:27 PM

Article image
Inside the complicated world of online wildlife trafficking
You’ve heard of Cecil’s dentist killer, but for many other lions, elephants, rhinos and tens of thousands of other exotic animals, internet marketplaces like eBay and Craigslist are the biggest threa

Mary Catherine O'Connor

03, Aug, 2015 @4:21 AM

Article image
Global accord on combatting illegal wildlife trade agreed by 46 nations

William Hague hails London event as 'turning point' in fight against yearly slaughter of thousands of rhinos and elephants

Adam Vaughan

13, Feb, 2014 @8:52 PM

Article image
Global pact against illegal wildlife trade should also look beyond poaching

Bradnee Chambers: Controlling poaching is only part of the battle – internationally agreed conservation policies are also needed

Bradnee Chambers

14, Feb, 2014 @4:15 PM

Article image
'It's against nature': illegal wildlife trade casts shadow over traditional Chinese medicine
Practitioners warn exploitation of endangered animals is tarnishing their name as bear bile is touted as a Covid-19 cure

Michael Standaert

26, May, 2020 @6:30 AM