Brazil hospital chain accused of hiding Covid deaths and giving unproven drugs

Group of whistleblowing doctors gave 10,000-page dossier to investigators last month with allegations against Prevent Senior

One of Brazil’s biggest healthcare providers has been accused of covering up coronavirus deaths, pressuring doctors to prescribe ineffective treatments, and testing unproven drugs on elderly patients as part of ideologically charged efforts to help the Brazilian government resist a Covid lockdown.

Prevent Senior, a health maintenance organization with a chain of hospitals and more than half a million members, is in the crosshairs of a congressional inquiry into Brazil’s coronavirus crisis and the highly controversial response of President Jair Bolsonaro.

Last month a group of whistleblowing doctors handed a 10,000-page dossier to investigators containing a series of incendiary allegations against the São Paulo-based firm that caters to senior citizens.

The dossier contained claims that elderly patients had been used as “human guinea pigs” for the testing of unproven Covid “remedies” without giving their full consent.

On Tuesday, the lawyer representing those whistleblowers, Bruna Morato, appeared before the Covid investigation in Brasília and made further allegations.

They included claims that:

  • Prevent Senior doctors were pressured into giving patients a cocktail of ineffective drugs, including the antimalarial hydroxychloroquine and the anti-parasitic ivermectin, in what was referred to as the “Covid kit”.

  • The decision to promote hydroxychloroquine as a supposedly effective Covid treatment was partly designed to help government ideologues who allegedly wanted to use such information to convince Brazilians there was no need to stay at home during the pandemic. “The economy couldn’t stop so they [the government] needed to find a way of giving hope to people who were leaving their homes. This hope had a name: hydroxychloroquine,” Morato alleged.

  • The use of such unproven medicines was also part of “a cost-reduction strategy” on the part of Prevent Senior. “It is much cheaper for a health provider to make certain medication available rather than actually admitting those patients,” Morato claimed.

  • Coronavirus deaths had been concealed in order not to compromise the results of Prevent Senior tests allegedly designed to show “Covid kit” drugs were effective against the disease. “This is fraud,” said the inquiry’s vice-president, Randolfe Rodrigues.

  • Prevent Senior doctors had supposedly received instructions to reduce the oxygen supply to seriously ill Covid patients who had been in intensive care for more than 10 or 14 days. “The expression I heard repeated on numerous occasions was: ‘Deaths free up beds too,’” Morto said.

In a statement Prevent Senior said it repudiated the “untruthful accusations” and had always operated within legal and ethical guidelines. The company denied it had ever hidden or under-reported deaths.

“Prevent Senior has always respected the autonomy of its doctors and has never fired its employees because of their technical convictions,” the company said.

The claims sparked a major outcry in Brazil, where nearly 600,000 people have died because of Covid – second only to the US.

Daniel Dourado, a public health expert and lawyer from the University of São Paulo, said: “This is an unprecedented scandal in Brazil.”

Dourado said much about the allegations against Prevent Senior still needed to be elucidated. A police investigation was needed. But there were disturbing signs that Prevent Senior may have formed an “alliance” with some government officials and informal advisers “to create a narrative that was used to trick the Brazilian population into becoming infected” with Covid. “These accusations are extremely serious,” Dourado said.

Chrystina Barros, a member of the Covid-19 taskforce at Rio de Janeiro’s Federal University, agreed that the accusations, if confirmed, were grave.

“If it happened as is claimed, it is like telling patients … that they were not being treated by the doctors in front of them. [That actually] those doctors were following a script laid out by an administrative office that was motivated either by cost reduction … or political purposes,” Barros said.

“It will be up to investigators to define the extent of this [but] it is very serious.”


Tom Phillips and Flávia Milhorance in Rio de Janeiro

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Brazil could have stopped 400,000 Covid deaths with better government response, expert says
Epidemiologist behind study on scale of disaster says Jair Bolsonaro’s government is ‘entirely’ responsible

Flávia Milhorance in Rio de Janeiro

29, Jun, 2021 @9:00 AM

Article image
Brazil: viral rapper becomes unexpected champion of Covid vaccine drive
MC Fioti’s ‘vaccine anthem’ remix celebrates coronavirus inoculation with music video shot at biomedical research centre

Caio Barretto Briso in Rio de Janeiro

30, Jan, 2021 @2:59 PM

Article image
'The heart of darkness': neighbors shun Brazil over Covid response
Latin American countries scramble to protect themselves from a country where nearly 60,000 people are expected to die in March alone

Tom Phillips in Rio de Janeiro Uki Goñi in Buenos Aires and Joe Parkin Daniels in Bogotá

30, Mar, 2021 @1:08 PM

Article image
‘Calamity of maternal deaths’: Covid concern grows for Brazil’s pregnant
Following 803 pregnant and postpartum deaths, authorities have warned women to delay pregnancy as alarm rises

Flávia Milhorance in Rio de Janeiro

03, May, 2021 @8:00 AM

Article image
'We failed': one scientist's despair as Brazil Covid-19 deaths hit 100,000
Natalia Pasternak has tried ceaselessly through media appearances to counter President Jair Bolsonaro’s chaotic anti-science response to the pandemic

Tom Phillips Latin America correspondent

09, Aug, 2020 @9:30 AM

Article image
Brazil tops 251,000 Covid deaths as daily fatalities also set record
1,582 Brazilians die in a day amid slow vaccine rollout as President Jair Bolsonaro again discourages mask use

Flávia Milhorance in Rio de Janeiro

26, Feb, 2021 @9:04 PM

Article image
A silent decimation: South America’s losing battle against Covid
Strained and underfunded health systems, economics and misinformation have all led to a surge in deaths

William Costa in Asunción, Uki Goñi in Buenos Aires, Flávia Milhorance in Rio de Janeiro, Dan Collyns and Sam Jones

18, Jun, 2021 @9:00 AM

Article image
Lula: Bolsonaro leading Brazil 'to slaughterhouse' over Covid-19
Former president brands current leader a ‘troglodyte’ who should be removed from office

Tom Phillips in Rio de Janeiro

17, Apr, 2020 @9:00 AM

Article image
Brazil overtakes Italy as country with third-highest coronavirus deaths
Brazil registers a record 1,473 deaths in day, with Mexico also registering over 1,000, as Latin American countries seek to reopen

Tom Phillips in Rio de Janeiro

04, Jun, 2020 @11:57 PM

Article image
Judge orders Bolsonaro to resume publishing Brazil Covid-19 data
Move comes amid accusations government was trying to suppress the scale of the crisis

Tom Phillips and Caio Barretto Briso in Rio de Janeiro

09, Jun, 2020 @2:25 PM