‘We went to the dark side’: horror film shows reality of Mexico’s migrant trail

Mystical realism conveys real-life stories of brutal cartel violence in Fernanda Valadez’s chilling directorial debut

Two teenage boys wave goodbye to their mothers across a field in rural Mexico, leaving home in search of the American dream. The opening moments of the Mexican film-maker Fernanda Valadez’s Identifying Features, available to stream from this week, reflects scenes played out every day across Mexico and Central America, as men, women and children journey north in search of safety and job opportunities.

Valadez, 39, starts her directorial debut film in her home state of Guanajuato – a picturesque, once tranquil state in the centre of the country. In recent years Guanajuato has fallen victim to the evolving geography and relentless nature of Mexico’s humanitarian crisis; it is now one of the most dangerous places in the country for those who live there and for people travelling through on the migrant trail.

The inspiration for the film’s central story is based on a real-life account published in the Blog del Narco – an anonymous blog detailing crimes of kidnappings or gun battles that local newspapers were warned off reporting.

The film starts by accompanying two teenage boys as they travel towards the border. The bus they are on is intercepted by armed men who kill most of the passengers. One of the boys, Jesús, is spared after agreeing to work for the cartel. First he must kill his friend and burn the bus.

Throughout the film Valadez combines mystical realism with unflinching reality. The red fire that engulfs the bus and its passengers evokes hellfire, a fantastical force of evil.

Valadez says she wanted to do something different with Identifying Features, creating “not just another Latin American film about concepts and social interest”. Instead of adopting the narrative documentary style chosen by many other film-makers to depict the perils of the migrant journey through Mexico, she has crafted a horror film.

“By using more metaphoric figures like the devil to express the violence we felt able to take the audience very close emotionally,” says Valadez, in an interview.

Yet, the scenarios that Valadez shows us are real. Scores of buses carrying migrants are believed to have been ambushed in this way in recent years, arriving at their final destination with no passengers, only their luggage. In 2010, 72 migrants from Central and South America who had been abducted from several buses were massacred in the northern state of Tamaulipas by members of the Los Zetas cartel after refusing to pay a ransom or take jobs as hitmen. Only three people survived.

Another character, Jesús’s mother, Magdalena, embarks on a journey of her own, following in the footsteps of her son from their village in Guanajuato to find out what happened to him. Magdalena’s grief and steely determination are counterpoints to the cartel violence that lurks behind every corner.

“The key word is empathy,” says Valadez. “Empathy is the bridge from which art in general begins, it’s so important to storytelling in films. It’s what has taken this film to audiences we never expected. Empathy is the key to igniting conversations.”

Fernanda Valadez and Astrid Rondero
Director Fernanda Valadez (r) and co-producer Astrid Rondero. ‘Empathy is the key to igniting conversations,’ says Valadez. Photograph: Courtesy of Leonardo Manzo for Quién Magazine

People on the migrant trail are not the only ones at risk of disappearing in Mexico. The film includes the story of a surgeon whose son had disappeared four years earlier while driving to see friends in Monterrey in Nuevo León, a state where forced disappearances were once so widespread that billboards instructed residents to call the armed forces in case of an emergency as the police were in cahoots with the criminal gangs.

“At first kidnappings were something you read about happening to migrants, but within a couple of years [of the launch of the war against drugs] it started happening closer to home, closer to cities and to the middle classes,” says Astrid Rondero, who co-wrote and produced Identifying Features.

“When we were teenagers [in Mexico City] you could no longer take a trip on the highway to the beach in case the bus was kidnapped. Anyone could be in the wrong place at the wrong time,” she says.

At least 73,000 people have gone missing since the start of the militarised war on drugs in 2006, while at least 39,000 unidentified bodies are unclaimed in morgues. This war without an end has so far cost the lives of at least 300,000 Mexicans.

Identifying Features offers up no hope of resolution or an end to the desperate search of families for their loved ones.

“[With this film] we went to the dark side because we are still in this crisis, there is no closure. There was hope of change with the new government of [Andrés Manuel] López Obrador but now it’s out of control, the stories may be even more gruesome,” says Rondero. “The ending is dark because we’re still in that place, it feels like a complete betrayal.”

The current administration agreed to Donald Trump’s demands to place thousands of asylum seekers on the Mexican side of the border, where they have been subjected to violence, extortion, kidnap and inhumane living conditions, according to Human Rights Watch. Now, at the behest of the Biden government, more troops are being deployed to Mexico’s southern border to stop migrants and refugees crossing.

Amid daily reports of atrocities which only seem to get worse, the film-makers believe that art plays a crucial role in evoking empathy and political consciousness among those numbed by the pain.

“When we show the film here in Mexico, the emotional information helps people to finally start understanding what we’ve been living since 2000,” says Rondero. “We cannot allow this to happen, and we have to do something to change it because it’s not normal for so many people to be travelling on dirt roads looking for their loved ones.”

• Identifying Features is available to stream on BFI Player.


Nina Lakhani in New York

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Passage through Mexico: the global migration to the US
While waiting for travel documents in Tapachula, African and Asian migrants recount the treacherous journeys they took to get one step closer to a new home

Nina Lakhani in Tapachula, Mexico

06, Sep, 2016 @3:53 PM

Article image
How the American dream died on the world's busiest border
Driven by hope of a better life, people from Central America and beyond flock to the US-Mexico border. Yet it has become a focal point for human suffering

Ed Vulliamy in Matamoros

21, Feb, 2020 @6:00 AM

Article image
Global refugees take long detours through Latin America to reach the US
Recent events involving Syrian refugees arriving at North American borders have brought to light the increased global traffic along the continent’s migrant routes

Sibylla Brodzinsky in Bogotá and Nina Lakhani in Mexico City

24, Nov, 2015 @3:07 PM

Article image
Back to the border of misery: Amexica revisited 10 years on
A decade after publishing his vivid account of the places and people most affected by the US-Mexican ‘war on drugs’, Ed Vulliamy returns to the frontline

Ed Vulliamy

08, Dec, 2019 @8:00 AM

Article image
Mexico’s vow to tighten border fails to deter US-bound migrants
As the Biden administration enlists its neighbours in attempts to slow the flow of people, families seeking a future free from hunger and violence journey on

David Agren in Frontera Corozal

14, Apr, 2021 @10:00 AM

Article image
‘A moment in history’: making a perilous sea-crossing with refugees – photo essay
Ahead of a UK exhibition of her photo series Journey in the Death Boat, Güliz Vural describes travelling with Syrians being smuggled to Greece from Turkey

Amie Ferris-Rotman and Isabel Choat

07, Nov, 2021 @3:00 PM

Article image
‘I’d never seen a boat come in with so many bodies’: mortal cost of Atlantic migrant route
Every year thousands of refugees from conflict, climate and instability in Africa board vessels in search of a new life in Europe but hundreds never arrive

Sam Jones in Gran Canaria

08, Aug, 2021 @7:00 AM

Article image
Greek police arrest Dutch journalist for helping Afghan asylum seeker
Ingeborg Beugel was detained for ‘facilitating the illegal stay of a foreigner’ and faces up to a year in jail

Katy Fallon

24, Jun, 2021 @2:31 PM

Article image
‘They lost almost everything’: photographing the terror and joy of refugees in DRC
Alexis Huguet’s image of this twin girl, born as her mother fled into Congo, captures the fragility of life in the Central African Republic

Sarah Johnson

31, Dec, 2021 @3:00 PM

Article image
Central America's rampant violence fuels an invisible refugee crisis
The numbers are staggering, and governments are doing little to protect people from warring gangs and corrupt security forces. Yet entire families who are now seeking asylum are being sent back and told to simply live elsewhere

Nina Lakhani in Tapachula, Mexico

13, Oct, 2016 @10:00 AM