Wiping out the daughters: Burkina Faso's controversial mosquito experiment

A radical experiment to genetically modify a strain of mosquito in order to stop them breeding malaria-carrying daughters is one of the latest efforts to tackle the deadly scourge of malaria

At 6.30am five-year-old Osman Balama and his mother reach the state hospital of Bobo-Dioulasso, the second-largest city in Burkina Faso. He hasn’t been feeling well for a few days and his mother is worried that he has contracted malaria. The waiting room is already full of mothers and grandmothers with young children on their laps, all with the same tired look as Osman.

“The rainy season has started,” says Sami Palm, head of the clinic. “That means more mosquitos. I’m certain that almost everyone here has malaria.”

Two red lines on the detection strip confirm malaria. “He doesn’t need to stay in the hospital, because he isn’t vomiting and isn’t extremely sick,” Palm says. Osman is sent home with medication – the Burkinese government covers treatments for children aged five and under.

Each year around 400,000 people worldwide die from malaria, half of them in seven countries in Africa, including Burkina Faso. Despite progress in reducing deaths since 2000, cases have been gradually increasing. “We’re having more and more problems with resistance – from the parasite, which knows how to counteract the medicines, and from the mosquitoes, which are getting less sensitive to the insect poisons applied to the mosquito nets,” says Palm. “On top of this, there are many remote areas we can’t reach.”

A radical trial using “gene drive” technology is currently taking place in Burkina Faso, that will see the release of genetically modified mosquitoes in an attempt to wipe out the carriers of the disease.

“We’re developing mosquitoes here that can only have sons. Those sons will also only be able to produce sons, causing the population of females, the only gender that bites, to dwindle until the mosquito is extinct,” says Moussa Namountougou, head of the insect farm of the Institut de Recherche et Sciences de la Santé (IRSS), just a few kilometres from the hospital.

“To do this we have added a bit of genetic information from a slime mould to the mosquito DNA. That extra bit contains the instructions to break down any sperm cells that could produce a daughter mosquito.”

In the insectarium of Target Malaria, Moussa Namountougou inspects a tray with mosquito larvae
In the insectarium of Target Malaria, Moussa Namountougou inspects a tray with mosquito larvae Photograph: Joost Bastmeijer

Namountougou and his team have at their disposal a gene drive, which they want to use to stop the genetic instruction diluting as modified mosquitoes mate with those that don’t have the new genetic information. This uses a sort of genetic copier so breed offspring with the new trait – with the intention of wiping out female malaria-carrying mosquitoes. “This way the trait spreads rapidly through the entire population, over just a few years,” says Namountougou. “Such a gene drive has never been released into the wild.”

The village of Bana, near Bobo-Dioulasso, is where GM mosquitoes using this technology will eventually be released. The government gave the go-ahead in June.

Bana is like many others: mud huts around a central square, no sewage system or electricity, the ground strewn with drying shea nuts, whose harvest has just begun.

Village elder Tchessira Sanou with some of the residents of Bana
Village elder Tchessira Sanou with some of the residents of Bana Photograph: Joost Bastmeijer

“We have two major problems here: water pollution and malaria,” says village elder Tchessira Sanou. “I used to go into the forest to gather sticks and leaves from specific trees and shrubs to treat the symptoms. Now we receive mosquito nets from the government and we have medicine, but the disease persists.” Even if no one dies, the disease has a huge impact. “If you or your child get sick, then you can’t work in the fields for several days. That can cost you your entire harvest, leaving you with too little to eat.”

For seven years, Target Malaria, the organisation behind the project – has been sending teams of theatre performers to Bana to explain what scientists are doing in their village.

“It’s very important to us that everyone in the village understands what’s going on here,” says Lea Pare, of Target Malaria.

“Not everyone in the village can read or write, so this helps everyone understand. We need that, or they won’t support the project.”

Lea Pare, head of information at Target Malaria, dances with children as they wait for the theatre group which is helping to explain the scientists’ work to residents
Lea Pare, head of information at Target Malaria, dances with children as they wait for the theatre group which is helping to explain the scientists’ work to residents Photograph: Joost Bastmeijer

More than 100 local people have toured the insect farm in Bobo-Dioulasso, where scientists explained mosquitoes’ life cycle, and answered questions.

Genetic modification is controversial, and gene drive technology takes it a step further. Introducing “ordinary” GM produce to agriculture has led to widespread resistance. Several countries have also outlawed the technology.

And there are substantial objections in Burkina Faso. “It makes us puppets of the west,” says Ali Tapsoba, director of Terre à Vie, a community organisation in the capital Ouagadougou. “We believe genetic modification is never a solution. There is always a risk that the mosquitoes will mutate and we will lose track of them. People in our country must learn to live more hygienically, then the malaria mosquito will disappear in a safer way.”

There are doubts too in the academic world. Recently, entomologist Willem Takken from Wagening asked in the Volkskrant newspaper whether another type of mosquito wouldn’t simply take the place of the exterminated insect.

Ali Tapsoba works on his laptop
Ali Tapsoba works on his laptop Photograph: Joost Bastmeijer

Namantougou already knows the work he’s doing is not nearly enough. “In Burkina Faso there are four mosquitoes that can carry malaria, and we need to tackle each.”

The genetic instruction taken from slime moulds only works in this one type of malaria mosquito, and not in others. “Those will continue to have daughters,” he says.

Bart Knols, mosquito expert at the Radbouduniversiteit in Nijmegen, says bed nets are far more cost effective. “The development of gene-drive mosquitoes is expensive, while a mosquito net costs next to nothing. I think that it’s more effective to invest more money in distributing those.”

Last year, a group of around 160 social and environmental organisations called for a for a moratorium on the experimental use of the gene drive at a UN meeting. It failed by a narrow margin, and many African countries voted against it.

“Opponents of the gene drive should be required to come live here in Burkina Faso for a while and see what malaria brings,” Pare says. “Then they can see for themselves how much we need a solution here.”

A group of young men walking around Bana to catch mosquitoes
A group of young men walking around Bana to catch mosquitoes Photograph: Joost Bastmeijer

As evening falls in Bana, men with mosquito nets arrive and begin swishing them through the air. “These are test mosquitoes, without the gene drive,” says Namountougou. “They have a modification that makes them sterile: no eggs are formed after mating.”

These mosquitoes serve a primarily scientific purpose. “We want to know, for example, how far the mosquitoes travel. We also train people to catch and analyse the mosquitoes.”

One of the catchers shines a flashlight on his net, and at least 10 mosquitoes fly about. The men carefully place their filled nets in a freezer. The following day the mosquitoes will be removed one by one and transported to the lab, where Namountougou will inspect whether they are modified or not. He has great optimism for future possibilities: “The malaria mosquito isn’t the only mosquito causing misery. With a gene drive we can also make dengue, Zika, and chikungunya disappear.”

A longer version of this story appeared in De Volkskrant

Hidde Boersma and Joost Bastmeijer

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Mosquito-killing spider juice offers malaria hope
Scientists have genetically modified a fungus to make it produce the same lethal toxin as is found in the funnel web spider

Rebecca Ratcliffe

31, May, 2019 @12:22 PM

Article image
Scientists hail malaria breakthrough as bed nets prove deadly to mosquitoes
Clinical malaria cases in Burkina Faso drop by 12% after trial of nets treated with new chemical combination

Kate Hodal

11, Aug, 2018 @8:00 AM

Article image
Malaria trial shows ‘striking’ 70% reduction in severe illness in children
A study in Burkina Faso and Mali suggests combining anti-malarial drugs and vaccination could reduce deaths and hospitalisations

Saeed Kamali Dehghan

26, Aug, 2021 @4:05 PM

Article image
Invest in mosquito surveillance to combat malaria, says Bill Gates
Gates stresses need to track geographical spikes in disease as Commonwealth nations pledge £2.7bn to halt deadly resurgence

Hannah Summers

18, Apr, 2018 @8:00 AM

Article image
Child malaria deaths dramatically cut by suppository drug, shows Zambia study
Internally administered medicine allows crucial window of time for children in remote areas to reach healthcare facilities

Rebecca Ratcliffe

25, Oct, 2018 @6:00 AM

Article image
Malaria campaigns fight off Covid disruptions to deliver programmes
Almost all programmes against the disease have continued, delivering nets, drugs and the world’s first malaria vaccine

Samuel Okiror in Kampala

02, Oct, 2020 @12:26 PM

Article image
Malawi starts landmark pilot of first ever child malaria vaccine
Immunisation gives partial protection against the killer disease, and lessens the severity of other cases

Karen McVeigh

23, Apr, 2019 @12:58 PM

Article image
Scientists sound warning note over malaria drug resistance in Africa
Rwanda study raises fears erosion of efficacy may have begun, with children at greatest risk

Sarah Boseley, health correspondent

15, Apr, 2021 @9:19 AM

Article image
Ghana's unlikely marriage of mining and malaria control draws envious glances
A global mining firm joined forces with the people of Obuasi and the national government to tackle malaria. Now others want to emulate their success

Lucy Lamble in Obuasi

04, Jun, 2018 @6:00 AM

Article image
Healers cure mistrust in Guinea's health system after horrors of Ebola
Practitioners of traditional medicine – the first port of call for 80% of Guineans – could be invaluable in helping fight other killer diseases, such as malaria

Ruth Maclean in Kissidougou, Guinea

28, Sep, 2016 @6:00 AM