EU support for Libya contributes to 'extreme abuse' of refugees, says study

Human Rights Watch accuses EU institutions of sustaining network of ‘inhuman and degrading’ migrant detention centres

The EU’s support for Libya’s anti-migrant policies is contributing to a cycle of “extreme abuse”, including arbitrary detention, torture, sexual violence, extortion and forced labour.

According to a report by Human Rights Watch, who interviewed 66 migrants and asylum seekers in Libya last year, EU institutions and member states are continuing to sustain a network of detention centres characterised by “inhuman and degrading” conditions where the risk of abuse is rife.

Detailing a pattern of treatment in Libyan detention centres which it said “violates international law”, the group accused senior EU officials of being aware of the abuses but repeatedly failing to act.

The report highlights EU assistance to the Libyan coastguard to enable it to intercept migrants and asylum seekers at sea, at which point they are taken to Libya. Italy, in particular, is accused of “abdicat[ing] virtually all responsibility for coordination of rescue operations at sea in a bid to limit the number of people arriving on its shores”.

“Since 2016, the EU has intensified efforts to prevent boat departures from Libya. EU policymakers and leaders justify this focus as a political and practical necessity to assert control over Europe’s external borders and ‘break the business model of smugglers’, as well as a humanitarian imperative to prevent dangerous boat migration,” said the report, published on Monday.

The study follows the publication of new data from the International Organisation for Migration showing that – despite the EU’s Libya policy – migrant numbers arriving by sea in Europe in the first 16 days of 2019 were nearly double that of the same period last year, totalling 4,216 arrivals.

An estimated 170 migrants are feared to have died since last week in the Mediterranean in two incidents involving dinghies that left from Libya and Morocco, migrants organisations have said.

One dinghy was spotted sinking in rough waters on Friday by an Italian military plane on patrol. A naval helicopter was dispatched and rescued three people who said they had left Libya on Thursday night as part of a group of 120 people.

“After 10 to 11 hours at sea … (the boat) started sinking and people started drowning,” Flavio Di Giacomo, spokesman for the International Organisation for Migration (IOM) said.

In another incident, 53 migrants who left Morocco on a dinghy were missing after what one survivor said was a collision in the Alboran Sea, in the western Mediterranean.

Among accusations levelled by those interviewed by HRW are that members of the Libyan coastguard, which includes untrained former militia members who fought against former president Muammar Gaddafi, “threatened to shoot” intercepted migrants who refused to board their boat.

According to Joanna, a 34-year-old mother of three from Cameroon, who was on a boat intercepted by the coastguard in international waters: “Men on the large Libyan boat threw us a rope and at first we refused to tie it to ours. The Libyans shot into the air and threatened us: ‘If you don’t tie it on to the boat then we will shoot at you.’ So we tied it to our boat and they started to move people to their boat.”

The US-led group adds that increased legal and bureaucratic obstacles imposed in Europe to block most non-governmental maritime rescue operations in the central Mediterranean has contributed to a rising death toll even as the numbers attempting to reach Europe from Libya have dropped.

“While Mediterranean departures have decreased since mid-2017, the chances of dying in waters off the coast of Libya significantly increased, from one in 42 in 2017 to one in 18 in 2018,” the group added, citing figures collected by the UN’s refugee agency.

The report adds that while the IOM had assisted more than 30,000 people to return from Libya to their home countries through its “voluntary humanitarian program”, increased interceptions by the EU-supported Libyan coastguard have led to a rise in the number of migrants and asylum seekers detained in Libya to between 8,000 to 10,000 people, up from 5,200 in April 2018.

Describing unsanitary conditions and a lack of proper healthcare in the centres visited, researchers also documented repeated claims of serious abuse by the authorities against detainees.

Researchers visited detention centres in Tripoli, Misrata and Zuwara where they documented inhumane conditions that included severe overcrowding, unsanitary accommodation, poor-quality food and water that has led to malnutrition, lack of adequate healthcare, and disturbing accounts of violence by guards, including beatings, whippings and use of electric shocks.

Judith Sunderland, lead author of the report, told the Guardian: “There has been a wilful attempt to ignore what is going on.

“There have been some efforts to mitigate the situation and to try to improve conditions in the detention centres, and to improve the capacity and professionalism of the Libyan coastguard. But… it is past time to accept the fact that these efforts are not bearing fruit.

“It is important to keep in mind that the overarching ambition of this policy is to limit arrivals of migrants to EU shores. The logic is clear and they appear willing to accept a Faustian bargain. But what is needed is a reset to a failed strategy.”


Peter Beaumont

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Fear and despair engulf refugees in Libya's 'market of human beings'
Long the target of reported abuses, refugees in Libya now claim they are being recruited by militias – a potential war crime

Sally Hayden

15, Apr, 2019 @10:43 AM

Article image
German report details Libya abuses amid pressure to stem migrant flows
Embassy in Niger verifies reports of rights abuses including executions in camps as Italy demands action to halt crossings

Patrick Wintour Diplomatic editor

30, Jan, 2017 @9:05 AM

Article image
Violence towards refugees at Libyan detention centres forces MSF to pull out
Medical charity says abuse and attacks have escalated as more migrants are intercepted at sea and camps become increasingly overcrowded

Kaamil Ahmed

24, Jun, 2021 @6:00 AM

Article image
Shipwreck claims the lives of at least 43 migrants off the coast of Libya
The UN calls for the resumption of state-led operations in the Mediterranean, as rescue groups’ vessels are detained in port

Kaamil Ahmed

21, Jan, 2021 @6:30 AM

Article image
EU to launch Mediterranean naval mission to tackle migrant crisis
Ministers want to seize smugglers and destroy their boats off Libyan coast to combat rising number of migrants fleeing war and poverty in north Africa

Arthur Neslen in Brussels

18, May, 2015 @5:05 PM

Article image
‘Life-saving’: hundreds of refugees to be evacuated from Libya to Rwanda
First group expected to leave dire detention centres in days, as UN denies reports that plan is part of EU strategy to keep refugees from Europe

Karen McVeigh

10, Sep, 2019 @3:04 PM

Article image
Crosses on our heads to 'cure' Covid-19: refugees report abuse by Croatian police
Group of asylum seekers including minors say they were beaten and spray-painted near the border with Bosnia, as calls grow for EU to investigate

Lorenzo Tondo

28, May, 2020 @10:03 AM

Article image
More than 100 lone children rescued trying to cross Mediterranean
Unicef warns many child refugees and migrants picked up off the coast of Libya will be sent to ‘appalling’ detention centres

Hannah Summers and Emmanuelle Chaze

30, Apr, 2021 @3:12 PM

Article image
Migrant crisis: EU plan to strike Libya networks could include ground forces
Exclusive: Strategy paper for the mission focuses on air and naval campaign, but adds that ‘presence ashore’ might be needed to destroy smugglers’ assets

Ian Traynor in Brussels

13, May, 2015 @5:04 PM

Article image
Why attack on Libya detention centre was grimly predictable
The EU has long been aware of the terrible plight of migrants detained or trapped in Libya

Peter Beaumont

03, Jul, 2019 @5:30 PM