Hissène Habré’s rape acquittal must not be quietly airbrushed from history | Kim Thuy Seelinger

Though ruled out on procedural grounds, Khadidja Zidane’s testimony against the former Chad president highlights some uncomfortable truths about attitudes towards survivors of sexual violence

Almost a year ago, I sat in the extraordinary African chambers of the courts of Senegal and watched as Hissène Habré, the former president of Chad, was convicted of multiple war crimes, crimes against humanity and acts of torture.

The judgment was hailed as a victory for international criminal justice. It was the first time a national court had used principles of universal jurisdiction to prosecute a former head of state for crimes of this nature.

After hearing detailed, horrific accounts of rape and sexual slavery, the judges added sexual violence to Habré’s charge sheet. One shocking testimony came from Khadidja Zidane, who explained how, almost 30 years earlier, Habré had summoned her from prison to the presidential palace and raped her.

Hissène Habré reacts as he is escorted in to stand trial by police at the Palais de Justice in Dakar, Senegal.
Hissène Habré reacts as he is escorted in to stand trial by police at the Palais de Justice in Dakar, Senegal. Photograph: EPA

Habré was convicted of half a dozen crimes under international law, including rape and sexual slavery as a crime against humanity. The conviction reflected not only the mass rape and sexual slavery his security forces committed in prisons and military camps, but what Habré had done to Zidane in the presidential palace. This was an extraordinary conviction. Normally, high-level defendants in war crimes cases are charged with responsibility for the acts of their subordinates, not their own.Last month, Judge Ougadeye Wafi upheld all convictions against Habré except one. All the sentences for the mass sexual violence committed by his security forces were maintained, but Habré was acquitted of raping Zidane. The appeals court took pains to emphasise that the acquittal was a procedural matter and did not reflect on Zidane’s credibility. It said the new facts Zidane offered in her trial testimony came too late to be included within the new charges of sexual violence, so they could not serve as the basis for a conviction.

The appeals decision was seen as a victory. However, Habré’s rape acquittal should not be allowed to pass unnoticed. It not only sheds light on Senegalese criminal procedure, it also reveals some persistent and paradoxical truths about sexual crimes: not least that it is often difficult for survivors to come forward in a clear and timely way, and that these cases require sensitive investigation from the start.

Survivors of sexual violence face several challenges when considering whether to disclose their experiences. These are intimate crimes, often imbued with a sense of shame. Many survivors fear stigmatisation, harassment, blame or retaliation. Many need psychosocial support, medical care, safe shelter. Many risk losing their spouses. For all these reasons, disclosure of sexual violence can require time and supportive conditions.

Our legal processes are not built that way. Despite having decades of jurisprudence establishing forms of sexual violence as war crimes, crimes against humanity and acts of genocide, we still often fail to support disclosure from the beginning of these investigations. In this case, it is easy to imagine why the Chadian police or the Senegalese investigating judges did not question Habré’s victims about intimate violations more thoroughly. They are largely untrained about gender-based violence, and broaching the subject of rape is still seen as taboo.

This mistake has been made in other courts, too. Sexual violence charges have been added retrospectively in cases before the international criminal tribunal for Rwanda and at the international criminal court. Slowly, though, we are learning. In 2014, the prosecutor of the international criminal court released guidance on considering sexual and gender-based crimes at every stage of investigation and prosecution. But these guidelines are not easily accessed or applied by national courts, particularly where evidentiary rules and processes may differ.

At the extraordinary African chambers in Dakar, the judge was gentle and encouraging when questioning Zidane at trial, but it was too late.

Perhaps we can take Habré’s rape acquittal at face value. The appeal court held that the relevant facts had not been raised when the investigating judges were determining the factual bounds of the case, and under Senegalese procedural law they could not therefore be used.

Malian judge Ougadeye Wafi, centre, upholds Hissène Habré’s life sentence.
Malian judge Ougadeye Wafi, centre, upholds Hissène Habré’s life sentence. Photograph: Seyllou/AFP/Getty Images

Equally, perhaps this is not just a procedural issue. Perhaps it is about how gender inequality and stigma make it tremendously difficult for some survivors of sexual violence to speak out, much less have confidence that criminal justice institutions will support them. Either investigations practice must be improved to explore these crimes sensitively from the moment evidence collection begins, or trial procedures must allow for the possibility that victims may not disclose neatly or “on time”. Or both.

Either way, Zidane’s testimony was not in vain. After decades of silence, she confronted her former president in court. She told the trial judges what he did to her, and the whole world heard.

• Kim Thuy Seelinger directs the sexual violence programme at the Human Rights Center, University of California, Berkeley


Kim Thuy Seelinger

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
'I told my story face to face with Habré': courageous rape survivors make history | Ruth Maclean
Women raped under Chad dictator Hissène Habré, who has received a life sentence for mass atrocities, tell their stories for the first time

Ruth Maclean in N'Djamena

18, Sep, 2016 @8:00 AM

Article image
UN condemns 'grotesque rape chants' of Burundi youth militia
UN human rights chief says video of the youth wing of Burundi’s ruling party urging rape and murder of opposition members represents ‘tip of the iceberg’

Hannah Summers

19, Apr, 2017 @1:42 PM

Article image
Ugandan soldiers accused of rape and assault to face court martial
Military pledges zero tolerance after allegations of abuses by Human Rights Watch, but some fear court will not bring troops to justice

Samuel Okiror

06, Jun, 2017 @6:00 AM

Article image
Congolese rape survivor finds justice elusive: ‘I'm afraid my father will find me’ | Ruth Maclean
Eve was repeatedly raped by her father. Her long, lonely battle for redress exposes deep flaws in the Democratic Republic of the Congo’s legal framework

Ruth Maclean in Goma

09, Dec, 2016 @7:00 AM

Article image
Lawyers press for Chad's Hissène​​ Habré to face sexual slavery and rape charges
Group of international lawyers calls for charges against former Chad president to be revised in light of testimony by women at his trial for war crimes and torture

Celeste Hicks

22, Dec, 2015 @12:02 PM

Article image
Hissène Habré ordered to pay millions for crimes against humanity in Chad
Campaigners fear former Chad dictator’s assets may prove insufficient to meet court compensation demand for victims of rape, torture and bereavement

Ruth Maclean in Dakar

29, Jul, 2016 @4:38 PM

Article image
Jail fear prevents women in Mauritania from filing rape complaints, study finds
Campaigners demand change to law that means survivors of sexual violence can be imprisoned for adultery

Ruth Maclean, west Africa correspondent

06, Sep, 2018 @10:44 AM

Article image
No sleep for Congolese mothers trying to save their girls from rape
Officially, sexual violence has declined in the Democratic Republic of the Congo, dubbed the ‘rape capital of the world’. But frontline workers tell a different story

Ruth Maclean in Goma

07, Dec, 2016 @7:00 AM

Article image
'A great milestone': Somaliland adopts legislation outlawing rape
Activists welcome initial approval of law designed to curb rising sexual violence, but warn scope and implementation could prove problematic

Verity Bowman

11, Jan, 2018 @2:02 PM

Article image
'The nanny realised something was wrong': South Africa’s rape crisis
Dedicated nurses play a key role in helping rape survivors in South Africa, yet their future is threatened by a funding crisis that has lurched from bad to worse

Hannah Summers and Simisola Jolaoso

06, Dec, 2017 @1:59 PM