Federal court bars Australian company from releasing unsanctioned Pokémon-branded NFTs

Parramatta-based developer Kotiota also made false representations about its relationship with The Pokémon Company International, court hears

The owners of the Pokémon brand hired private investigators to track down the Australian developers behind a crypto-based online game that uses its characters without the Japanese company’s permission.

The Pokémon Company International (TPCI) won orders in the federal court on Wednesday preventing Parramatta-based developers Kotiota from using the popular video game, film and television characters in their software, releasing Pokémon-branded non-fungible tokens, or representing that the company has a relationship with The Pokémon Company International.

TPCI was alerted that Kotiota was presenting itself as a developer of Pokémon games in August this year, when news outlets said they had received legal letters from Kotiota claiming that articles about games should name Kotiota as a Pokémon developer despite having no agreement with TPCI, the court heard.

Kotiota has represented on its website that it was working on a number of Pokémon games, including the game’s latest releases, Pokémon Violet and Pokémon Scarlet, which TPCI has said Kotiota did not work on.

TPCI became aware in November of a website called PokeWorld that was registered by Xiaoyan Liu, who heads up Kotiota. The site announced plans to launch a crypto-based game and NFTs in January next year.

TPCI was particularly concerned about the launch of NFTs because according to documents filed, Nintendo and TPCI had made a “deliberate decision” not to enter the world of NFTs.

I enjoy how judgments just have to lay out these things sometimes pic.twitter.com/LN1aFVrmze

— Josh Taylor (@joshgnosis) December 22, 2022

As part of the affidavit provided to the court, TPCI’s representative, Katherine Fang, had to explain the history of Pokémon and its characters, including Pikachu, Bulbasaur, Charmander and Squirtle. The judgment identifies Pikachu as the “most recognisable” of the characters, and includes an illustration and rules around how Pikachu should be presented.

“Ms Fang deposed that TPCI was particularly concerned to ensure that Pikachu was not represented in any way that impinged on Pikachu’s visible facial features, or in any way impeded the ability to see its facial expressions,” the judgment states.

I should say the next paragraph is also excellent. pic.twitter.com/eQyIO637PH

— Josh Taylor (@joshgnosis) December 22, 2022

The court heard that in the company’s investigation, they discovered that another agency had been provided with what was purported to be a licence agreement between TPCI and Kotiota but which in fact had a falsified seal of an officer of TPCI.

In initial attempts to put a stop to Kotiota’s use of Pokémon, TPCI hired a cybersecurity firm to find Kotiota’s offices in Parramatta but could not find anyone in the building.

The court accepted that TCPI had attempted to meaningfully serve the documents, and ordered Kotiota cease using the Pokémon brand and stop presenting itself as a developer of the games.

As the respondents in the case did not attend the hearing, costs were reserved.

Guardian Australia has sought comment from Kotiota.


Josh Taylor

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Journalists angered by new Australian federal court restrictions on reporting of cases
Changes limiting access to key documents were made without consultation and only publicly revealed last week

Christopher Knaus

17, Jan, 2023 @1:45 AM

Article image
‘Utterly disgraceful’: new federal court rules limiting access to documents criticised by media union
While the court says rules are designed to protect respondents from early reporting of allegations, MEAA president says decision ‘goes against the concept of open court’

Paul Karp

13, Jan, 2023 @7:25 AM

Article image
Australian government to restore powers to strip citizenship from terrorism suspects
New laws to strip citizenship from dual citizens suspected of terrorism are likely to pass parliament after Coalition indicated support

Paul Karp

24, Oct, 2022 @1:17 AM

Article image
NSW says federal Labor’s ‘brazen intervention’ in rail dispute could constitute ‘improper influence’
Federal Coalition also takes aim at Tony Burke, who last week said he wanted to change law that has become central to Sydney train strike dispute

Michael McGowan and Paul Karp

04, Sep, 2022 @6:09 AM

Article image
Government and security company reach multimillion-dollar settlements with Manus Island guards
Multiple former employees of G4S who suffered physical or mental harm after 2014 riots have been compensated days into a predicted weeks-long trial

Nino Bucci

10, Sep, 2022 @8:00 PM

Article image
Optus cyber-attack: company opposed changes to privacy laws to give customers more rights over their data
In its submission to Privacy Act review telco said giving people right to erase personal data would involve ‘significant’ hurdles and costs

Josh Taylor

23, Sep, 2022 @8:00 PM

Article image
From Pokéstops to Pikachu: everything you need to know about Pokémon Go
The game has been flooding the news and neighbourhoods but for many it seems as silly as it is impenetrable. Pokémon Go devotee Clem Bastow breaks it down

Clem Bastow

11, Jul, 2016 @8:38 AM

Article image
Australian hospitality giant accused of going to shocking lengths to avoid paying casuals penalty rates
Pub chain Mantle Group under pressure to ‘negotiate a fair dinkum EBA’ after union says ‘zombie’ deal replaced by substandard agreement

Luke Henriques-Gomes Social affairs and inequality editor

26, Jan, 2023 @10:01 AM

Article image
Alleged clergy abuse survivor wins right to appeal case to high court of Australia
NSW court of appeal had ruled case could not be heard because priest accused of abusing applicant when she was 14 had since died

Christopher Knaus

18, Nov, 2022 @5:43 AM

Article image
‘Watershed moment’: Australian child abuse survivors finally have real access to justice
In the past, victims sought legal help only to be met with the further humiliation of unjust settlements. But the tide has begun to turn

Christopher Knaus

17, Sep, 2022 @8:00 PM