Pushing Buttons: Breaking Bad meets GTA – and other shows I’d like to play

Game adaptations don’t have to be terrible. But as Better Call Saul creator Vince Gilligan admits, bringing action from screen to console isn’t as easy as it sounds

Welcome back to Pushing Buttons! This issue is going out on my birthday. Presents would be nice, but what I actually want is a week off to finally play Elden Ring. Only slightly more importantly, today is also when the finale of Better Call Saul airs in the UK, closing out a story that began with Breaking Bad’s first TV episodes in 2008. I will really miss this series – there is nothing in television quite like creator Vince Gilligan’s sumptuous shots and tight dark-comedic writing. I’ve often wondered why there’s been no Breaking Bad video game – especially because Netflix has shown a great deal of interest in the games, from buying studios to bankrolling endless TV adaptations. (Side note: did you know that Netflix subscribers get access to 24 mostly excellent games for free, including the sci-fi masterpiece Into the Breach? I didn’t, until last week.)

I would have expected some drug-empire management game, maybe spliced with scenes from the show, or with scene-setting and dialogue from its writers. Or perhaps an interactive-movie tie-in along the lines of Charlie Brooker’s Black Mirror: Bandersnatch, where your reactions send the story spinning off in different directions. It would be expensive, sure, but Netflix has never minded spending money.

It turns out, as Gilligan said in this podcast interview, that there have been attempts at Breaking Bad video games – but none have come to fruition. Gilligan is not a gamer himself, but he talks about his vision for a Grand Theft Auto-style adaptation of the show that was pitched but never happened. Immense energy, effort and talent went into writing storylines for potential game projects, he says; at one point something was on the cards for PlayStation VR, but that never materialised, either.

Gilligan has run into a problem that video game creatives know well: making games is absurdly difficult, expensive and time-consuming. I am reminded of a quote from Frank Lantz of the NYU Game Center, which opened a superb video game exhibition at the V&A in 2018: “Making a game combines everything that’s hard about building a bridge with everything that’s hard about composing an opera. Games are basically operas made out of bridges.” Creating something that met the extremely high production standards of Breaking Bad would take years and cost millions. No wonder Gilligan and co couldn’t get anything off the ground.

This is why, historically, games based on movies and TV shows have been as terrible as movies based on games: they have to be made on constrained timescales and budgets, so that they can be released while the TV show or movie in question is still on air. I knew a few people who worked at EA Bright Light, the UK studio tasked with adapting the Harry Potter films into games for the Wii, Xbox 360 and PS3 in the 00s. Although those games sucked, it’s a miracle any of them were finished at all, given the insane pressure and compressed schedule developers had. Getting something remotely playable out the door in 11 months or less was a minor miracle.

Time and money are difficult problems to solve, no matter how much creative talent at your disposal. The most successful game adaptations tend to be the ones that aren’t time-sensitive: ones based on Tolkien, or the Marvel/DC universes, or the 2020 interpretation of Animal Farm. But perhaps TV creators (and fans) are patient. After a few cheap tie-ins in the early 00s, South Park’s creators Trey Parker and Matt Stone refused to license out any more until they could help make a game themselves, and do it properly. It resulted in the well-received South Park: The Stick of Truth in 2014, after 5 years of development.

Vince Gilligan tells us not to hold our breath for a Breaking Bad video game adaptation, but now that TV, books, film and games are getting friendlier with each other, I wonder whether it might happen in another 5 years. We can wait. They’re only finally releasing games based on the Redwall novels this year, for instance, and it’s been 25 years since I read those. (Relatedly: I have a very detailed hand-illustrated design document for an open-world Redwall adventure-RPG that I wrote when I was 11. If any developers fancy starting a bidding war for it, you know where to find me.)

What to play

Game of Thrones the game.
Monarchic conundrums …Reigns: Game of Thrones. Photograph: Steam

If you want an example of how to make a game based on a TV series without a casual £10 million and half a decade to spare, look at Reigns: Game of Thrones. Taking on the role of one of the TV show’s leaders – Jon Snow, Cersei, Sansa, so on – you are presented with monarchic conundrums and make snap decisions on them by swiping left or right, like a significantly more consequential version of Tinder. It’s halfway between sequel and fan fiction, feeding your imagination with hundreds of potential futures for Westeros and the characters we know so well. Its makers clearly love Game of Thrones, but are not afraid to take its fiction in their own direction.
Available on: PC, smartphones, Nintendo Switch
Approximate playtime: 2-10 hours

What to read

  • Microsoft stopped disclosing sales figures for Xbox consoles long ago, but early in the PlayStation 4/Xbox One era it was fairly clear that the PS4 was streets ahead. It comes as no surprise, then, to learn that the PS4 outsold the Xbox One by more than two to one, as revealed by court documents. Is it any wonder that Microsoft prefers to frame the console wars on its own terms and talk about Game Pass subscribers and engagement instead?

  • The Pokémon world championships are in London this week for the first time. The tournaments will be live-streamed, but Pokémon fans can also pay £10 to go and spectate. I went to this tournament in Washington in 2014 and it’s one of the most wholesome video game events I’ve ever been to – I especially loved all the millennial parents proudly watching their little kids compete.

  • Lastly, enjoy this footage of a game in which you are a squirrel with a gun, which quite deservedly blew up on Twitter over the weekend.

What to click

Metal: Hellsinger – where video games and heavy-metal music collide

The final Fifa: after 30 years, the football sim plans to go out with a bang

Arcade Paradise review – enjoy some 90s retro vibes in this tribute to classic games

Question block

Shape of the World.
Shape of the World. Photograph: Steam

Reader Lewis sent in this week’s question: I replayed the wonderful Florence, which was the perfect way to decompress during a hectic week. What other one- or two-hour games would you recommend?

I love all short-form media, from singles to short stories and poems to micro-games, and not just because I’m extremely time-poor: when you only have an hour or two to get your point across, you have to be creative and concise. Florence is a great example of this, an entire young-adult relationship compressed into a sequence of emotionally affecting mini-games. Journey is only a couple of hours long and it’s one of my favourite games of all time. The Stanley Parable is a short, replayable work of comic genius. Queer coming-of-age story If Found… also made an impression on me. I liked Shape of the World, an aesthetically pleasing and calm wander through surreal landscapes. I’ve recommended A Short Hike a few times, because it is just that. Ooh, and Minit – a strange, monochrome Zelda-like adventure where you only have 60 seconds to achieve something on each attempt – had me riveted for the entire 90 minutes it took to complete.


Keza MacDonald

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Pushing Buttons: There’s a place for narrative in games, but I’m done worshipping the story gods
The players not the plot do most of the work in Elden Ring and other innovative titles – it could be the future of video games

Keith Stuart

30, Nov, 2022 @11:39 AM

Article image
Pushing Buttons: Sony’s PS5 price hike shows play does have limits
Prices of PlayStation 5 consoles are rising despite the tough financial situations many are in – even as PS sales are at $20bn

Keza MacDonald

30, Aug, 2022 @10:15 AM

Article image
Pushing Buttons: Will The Last of Us open the door for more good video-game adaptations?
The HBO version of the post-apocalyptic has had rave reviews. From Silent Hill to Broken Sword, here are others that could really shine on the small screen

Keith Stuart

18, Jan, 2023 @11:40 AM

Article image
Better Call Saul's Vince Gilligan: 'We want to reward the fans'
Breaking Bad creator spoke during a panel in LA and revealed how fans of the show are at the heart of his creative decisions

Lauren Gambino

27, Mar, 2015 @7:41 PM

Article image
Pushing Buttons: The one game my kid will play with me
In this week’s newsletter: Give kids time, and they’ll find a game that captures their imagination – and yours too, if you’re lucky

Keza MacDonald

07, Dec, 2022 @11:48 AM

Article image
Pushing Buttons: Autumn’s gaming gems
From a creeping horror to a funny alien shooter, here are unexpected finds to play before the onslaught of big-name titles

Keza MacDonald

13, Sep, 2022 @11:18 AM

Article image
Better Call Saul: the audacious prequel series keeps getting better
In the new season of the Breaking Bad prequel, creator Vince Gilligan once again showcases his ability to rewrite the rules with flair

Charles Bramesco

06, Aug, 2018 @3:03 PM

Article image
Vince Gilligan and Peter Gould on Better Call Saul: 'It could have been a huge flop'
As the second season of the Breaking Bad spinoff starts, its creators reveal what happens next, the pitfalls of time travel – and why their female characters have suffered until now

Sam Wollaston

16, Feb, 2016 @10:58 AM

Article image
Vince Gilligan on Better Call Saul: 'We dread the future as much as the fans do'
The Breaking Bad showrunner explains how a throwaway joke created some of the world’s most compelling TV

Andrew P Street

14, Jul, 2017 @1:38 AM

Article image
Has Better Call Saul lived up to expectations?
Halfway through the first series, we have time to take stock – is this a great show in its own right, or do you have to be a fully signed-up Breaking Bad fan to appreciate it?

Richard Vine

12, Mar, 2015 @2:59 PM