Sheffield United 0-8 Newcastle: Premier League – as it happened

Last modified: 05: 56 PM GMT+0

There were eight different goalscorers at Bramall Lane, where a rampant Newcastle inflicted a record home defeat on Sheffield United

Eddie Howe speaks to Sky Sports

I thought we were really good, and once the goals came the confidence returned. We’ve had a difficult start to the season – the Liverpool game really hurt us – but what a response from the players in the past week: two wins, three clean sheets.

It’s great to get eight different goalscorers, and there were some really important ones for individuals: Alex Isak, Sean Longstaff, Sven Botman. And to get three clean sheets in a row is a really welcome boost for us.

🗣 "The Liverpool game really hurt us... What a response from the players in the last week."

Eddie Howe reflects on Newcastle's biggest-ever league away win 🔥8️⃣

— Sky Sports Premier League (@SkySportsPL) September 24, 2023


Full time: Sheffield United 0-8 Newcastle United

Peep peep! That was utterly extraordinary. It’s the biggest home defeat in Sheffield United’s history and Newcastle’s biggest away win. There were eight different goalscorers: Sean Longstaff, Dan Burn, Sven Botman, Callum Wilson, the outstanding Anthony Gordon, Miguel Almiron, Bruno Guimaraes and Alexander Isak. Newcastle were cold and ruthless; Sheffield United, who were actually the better team at 0-0, collapsed horribly.


90+3 min “Thanks for the reminder of the number of scorers in that Liverpool-Palace 9-0,” says Steve Crisp. “To be fair, Palace were totally robbed. The first three goals were offside. Suckling was impeded for the fourth and seventh. It was never a penalty for the sixth. I don’t even have to say why the fifth and eighth should behave been disallowed and the ninth was a plain handball. So if Geoff Thomas had scored the penalty, we’d have rightly won that night (34 years ago! I’m over it).”

Surely you got over it at about 2.15pm on Sunday 8 April 1990?

90+1 min Six minutes of added time.

90 min The record Premier League win, as you probably know, is 9-0.

89 min “I’m nearly certain (from fantasy football memory) that Ashley Young got four assists in the 8-2 over Arsenal,” says Brian Foley. “The internet tells me three, but I’m nearly positive I was giddy getting two goals and four assists for him that day.”

I think there’s a difference between official assists and Fantasy assists, so it’s possible that both you and the internet are right. That said, he was playing in midfield that day so he doesn’t get to join the Kieran Trippier Hat-Trick Club.

A poor backheader from Davies was collected by Isak, who sat Robinson down and slipped the ball nonchalantly past Foderingham.

GOAL! Sheff Utd 0-8 Newcastle (Isak 87)

Eight goals, eight different goalscorers. This is astonishing.

Alexander Isak of Newcastle United scores the team's eigth goal.
Alexander Isak of Newcastle United scores the team's eigth goal. Photograph: Anna Gowthorpe/Shutterstock


84 min Davies plays a one-two with Basham and shoots over from a tight angle.

83 min Newcastle have had 14 shots on target to Sheffield United’s one. Fourteen.

82 min This is also the biggest home defeat in Sheffield United’s history.


81 min: Newcastle substitution A Newcastle debut for Lewis Hall, who comes on to replace Bruno Guimaraes.

80 min Tonali’s corner, Anderson’s header, Foderingham’s save. He’s made a few decent saves today, the poor bloke.

80 min Sheff Utd are now bottom of the league on goal difference. They actually started this game well.

Pos Team P GD Pts
16 Wolverhampton 6 -6 4
17 AFC Bournemouth 6 -6 3
18 Luton 5 -8 1
19 Burnley 5 -9 1
20 Sheff Utd 6 -11 1

77 min “What is the highest number of different scorers in one game?” asks Richard Hirst.

Liverpool had eight when they beat Crystal Palace 9-0 in 1989, and I think there were nine different goalscorers when Arsenal beat Spurs 5-4 in that hockey match in 2004-05. Not sure if that’s a record though.

76 min Vinicius Souza is booked for flattening Anderson. This scoreline equals Newcastle’s biggest victory away from home, which was against Morecambe in the League Cup in 2020-21. They’ve never won by seven goals in a league game away from home.

75 min: Sheff Utd substitution Chris Basham replaces James McAtee, whose swaggering start to the game feels a lifetime ago.

GOAL! Sheff Utd 0-7 Newcastle (Guimaraes 73)

This is getting a bit weird. Longstaff’s shot deflects across the area to Guimaraes, who calmly places the ball into the corner. Newcastle are 7-0 up!

Bruno Guimaraes of Newcastle United scores the team's seventh goal past Wes Foderingham of Sheffield United.
Bruno Guimaraes of Newcastle United scores the team's seventh goal past Wes Foderingham of Sheffield United. Photograph: Michael Regan/Getty Images


73 min Richard Hirst suggests Trent Alexander-Arnold as somebody who may have managed a hat-trick of assists. And he’s right. I think Kyle Walker-Peters managed it as well when Spurs beat Bournemouth 5-0 in 2018-19.

71 min Ahmedhodzic misses a good chance for a non-consolation goal, lifting over the bar from a tight angle after a nice give-and-go with Traore.

70 min: Triple subsitution for Newcastle Sandro Tonali, Tino Livramento and Alexander Isak replace Miguel Almiron, Callum Wilson and Kieran Trippier.


Bruno Guimaraes has all the time in the world to play a simple pass through to Almiron, who finishes expertly with his left foot.

GOAL! Sheff Utd 0-6 Newcastle (Almiron 68)

Sheffield United have fallen apart.

66 min: Sheff Utd substitution Anis Ben Slimane replaces Gustavo Hamer.

65 min I can’t think of many defenders with a hat-trick of assists in the English top flight. Any suggestions?

64 min “Three assists today for Trippier,” says Chris Paraskevas. “His form this season has been exceptional, even during the team’s rough patch. He is right up there with Shearer as one of the most important signings in the club’s history.”

63 min: Sheff Utd substitution Tom Davies replaces Oliver Norwood.

Gordon, who started the match on the bench, has been the best player on the pitch and fully deserves this goal. He cut inside from the left, on the edge of the area, and shaped a precise curling shot into the far corner. Foderingham dived to his left but couldn’t quite get there. Newcastle have been terrific but this has been a wretched performance from Sheffield United.

GOAL! Sheff Utd 0-5 Newcastle (Gordon 61)

Anthony Gordon roars with delight after scoring a superb goal!

Newcastle United's Anthony Gordon celebrates scoring his side's fifth goal.
Newcastle United's Anthony Gordon celebrates scoring his side's fifth goal. Photograph: Andrew Kearns/CameraSport/Getty Images


61 min: Almiron has a goal disallowed! Anderson puts Gordon through on goal. His shot is well saved by Foderingham, and Almiron is offside when he puts the loose ball away. This could get extremely ugly for Sheffield United.

60 min Life doesn’t get much easier for Sheffield United, whose next four league games are West Ham (A), Fulham (A), Man Utd (H) and Arsenal (A)

Schar walked forward like Matthias Sammer and played an angled pass to Trippier on the right edge of the area. He teased a gorgeous first-time cross over Egan and onto the head of Wilson, who stooped to head past Foderingham from close-range.

Easy as you like... 🤷‍♂️⚽

Newcastle pick up where they left off as Wilson adds to the scoring early in the second-half ✅

— Sky Sports Premier League (@SkySportsPL) September 24, 2023


GOAL! Sheff Utd 0-4 Newcastle (Wilson 56)

A lovely team goal, and a hat-trick of assists for Kieran Trippier!

Callum Wilson of Newcastle United scores his team's fourth goal.
Callum Wilson of Newcastle United scores his team's fourth goal. Photograph: Michael Regan/Getty Images


55 min Botman hurts his back after landing awkwardly. He’s wincing but is going to try to run it off.

53 min Nothing much to report. McAtee is getting on the ball a bit more, with Sheffield United now playing a diamond midfield, but Nick Pope hasn’t yet had anything to do in the second half.

49 min Souza seems to foul Longstaff just outside the area, but the referee isn’t interested.

48 min This win will move Newcastle up to eighth, five points off the top four. They have a good run of Premier League fixtures coming up.

46 min Peep peep! Sheffield United have brought on Benie Traore for Jayden Bogle, which means a switch to a back four.


On the first goal, apparently Anthony Gordon’s handball needs to be deliberate – which it wasn’t – for the goal to be disallowed. There was a handball shout before the second goal as well; Almiron’s shot hit the arm of Schar before being saved by Foderingham. That led to the corner from which Dan Burn scored. It’s good that VAR made everything simpler.


Half time: Sheff Utd 0-3 Newcastle

Newcastle are cruising to their first away win of the season. They didn’t start particularly well but relaxed after Sean Longstaff put them ahead with a dubious goal in the 21st minute. Dan Burn and Sven Botman headed them further ahead, both from set-pieces by Kieran Trippier, and it would have been more but for Wes Foderingham. Once they hit their stride Newcastle were just too fast, too powerful, too good.


45+6 min Gordon beats Bogle to a loose ball, cuts inside and hits a deflected shot that is tipped over acrobatically by Foderingham. That’s a decent save.

45+5 min Guimaraes drags the ball through the legs of McAtee, reminding him who’s the boss in midfield today.

45+2 min “Sheffield United vs Newcastle is also on the telly here in Cambodia, in case anyone is interested,” writes Joe Buckley.

45 min Six minutes of added time. To say the atmosphere is flat would be an understatement.

44 min The resulting corner is headed away to Gordon, who larrups it into the crowd from 20 yards.

43 min: Chance for Wilson! This is crazily one-sided. Gordon, who has been superb since coming on, eases a through pass to Wilson, whose left-footed shot is well blocked by the outrushing Foderingham.

Callum Wilson
Callum Wilson has another chance for Newcastle. The gulf between to the sides is very much on show. Photograph: Darren Staples/AFP/Getty Images


41 min Apparently Elliot Anderson was hit on the leg by a bottle while Newcastle were celebrating their third goal. He didn’t make anything of it, but I’m sure we’ll hear more about it after the game.

39 min Wilson’s 20-yarder curler is saved to his left by Foderingham. Sheffield United have fallen apart since going behind.

38 min Bogle seems to foul Gordon in the area, but Stuart Attwell doesn’t give it and VAR decides not to get involved. I haven’t a clue any more.

36 min Thanks to all of you who have written in with details of US coverage. Talking of which…

“In answer to the question about listening to Sheffield vs Newcastle in the U.S - it’s on the telly, on the USA cable channel,” writes Richard Whitmore.

Newcastle started the game slowly but they’re running riot now. It came from the free-kick that was awarded for that foul by Robinson. Trippier swung it to the near post and Sven Botman flicked a good header into the far corner. Foderingham was a bit slow to react though I don’t think he’d have got there anyway.


Newcastle are RUNNING RIOT at Bramall lane ⚽⚽⚽

— Sky Sports Premier League (@SkySportsPL) September 24, 2023


GOAL! Sheff Utd 0-3 Newcastle (Botman 35)

And it’s goodnight from Sheffield United.

Sven Botman scores
Botman Forever! Photograph: Darren Staples/AFP/Getty Images


35 min Robinson is booked for a very aggressive man and ball challenge on Longstaff. Newcastle were fuming and thought he should have been sent off. Just before that, Foderingham made an important save from Wilson, who probably should have scored.

33 min Ahmedhodzic was trying to undress Burn as the corner came in, but Burn was still strong enough to get away from him.

No training-ground routine this time, just an exemplary, old-fashioned corner. Trippier curled a brilliant ball to the far post, where Burn got away from Ahmedhodzic and stooped to head home from three yards.


— Sky Sports Premier League (@SkySportsPL) September 24, 2023


GOAL! Sheff Utd 0-2 Newcastle (Burn 31)


Dan Burn scores
Dan Burn nods home the second goal for Newcastle. Photograph: Chris Radburn/Reuters


30 min A lovely corner routine from Newcastle. Trippier plays a one-two and then slides a square pass towards Almiron, running round the ball on the edge of the area. His off-target shot hits his teammate Schar and bounces towards goal, forcing Foderingham to push it over the bar.


30 min Here’s Newcastle’s opening goal, another one for poor old Howard Webb to explain away.


Sean Longstaff scores his first in 11 months and Newcastle lead ✅

— Sky Sports Premier League (@SkySportsPL) September 24, 2023


29 min “For your enquiring correspondent,” says Richard Tibbles, “you can listen to the Blades vs Bonesaws match on the World Service on BBC Sounds.”

28 min Ahmedhodzic is booked for taking a shortcut through Anthony Gordon.

27 min “If Dietrich Ewing has Sirius XM,” says Joe Pearson, “the match is being carried on channel 157.”

26 min Thomas wins a corner for Sheffield United on the left. Pope flaps it away to Hamer, who splashes a half-volley over the bar from a tight angle.

25 min Pope misses his punch at a free-kick but gets away with it. I’d like to see that goal again as I think VAR may have missed a handball.

The goal stands! It looked like it stayed in play, though it’s impossible to be 100 per cent sure. The ball also seemed to hit Gordon’s hand, or maybe I’m seeing things. Either way, Newcastle are ahead.


Sheffield United thought the ball had gone out of play on the left so there will be a VAR check. Gordon collected a throw-in right on the byline, wriggled away from a defender and slid a low cross to Longstaff at the near post. He finished crisply with his left foot.

GOAL! Sheff Utd 0-1 Newcastle (Longstaff 21)

Newcastle may have been flat, but they’re now in front.

Sean Longstaff scores for Newcastle
Sean Longstaff puts the away side ahead. Photograph: Jason Cairnduff/Action Images/Reuters


20 min Newcastle look a bit flat, as they did in their last away league game at Brighton.

18 min Vinicius Souza’s long-range shot is comfortably saved by Pope. Just before that, McAtee – who is so bright – got away from Longstaff and found Hamer, whose shot was blocked.

16 min Longstaff’s excellent pass releases Wilson on the right. He moves into the area and tries to go outside Norwood, who reads it well and strolls away with the ball.

14 min McAtee, who has started brightly, plays a one-two with Bogle on the right and waves a nonchalant cross with the outside of the left foot. It clears Trippier at the farp ost and reaches Thomas, who slices a volley well wide. That was a pretty good chance, though he might have seen the ball late.

12 min: Newcastle substitution A dejected Harvey Barnes is replaced by Anthony Gordon.


10 min Harvey Barnes is down with what looks like a muscle injury. I don’t think he’ll be able to continue.

Harvey Barnes
Harvey Barnes is down with an injury. His afternoon is over. Photograph: Darren Staples/AFP/Getty Images


9 min “Hey there!” writes Dietrich Ewing. “Is there any way to listen to the game in the U.S.?”

I have no idea I’m afraid. Can anyone help?

7 min Guimaraes slides a nice pass through the inside-right channel to Wilson, who drills a low shot from a tight angle. Foderingham gets down to his right to save at the second attempt.

5 min It’s been a good start from Sheffield United, who are pressing aggressively. Newcastle are yet to get going.

3 min Sheffield United’s wing-backs combine for the first chance. Bogle fizzes a terrific first-time cross towards Thomas at the far post. He controls it on the chest and wallops a volley that is really well blocked by Trippier.

3 min “G’Day Rob, brutal 1.30am kick-off here,” writes Chris Paraskevas. “I’ve got work in a few hours but got some sleep in before this one. Any time I see Sheffield United play I can’t help but think of Danny Webber’s winner against us back in the 2006-07 season.

“It remains one of the quintessential Newcastle results of my lifetime: gifting Neil Warnock’s side their first away win of the campaign. Hoping for a less anaemic performance tonight... The Newcastle line-up that day (with Glenn Roeder as manager): Harper, Carr, Moore, Bramble, Babayaro, Milner, Parker, Butt, N’Zogbia, Rossi, Duff.

That’s a decent team as well, at least on paper.

2 min It looks like a 3-4-2-1 for Sheffield United, who are without the suspended Oli McBurnie. Gustavo Hamer and James McAtee are supporting Carmeron Archer.

1 min Peep peep! Sheffield United kick off from right to left as we watch.

Before the game there will be a minute’s silence in memory of Maddy Cusack, who died tragically this week.

Team news

Paul Heckingbottom makes two changes from the team that lost so agonisingly at Spurs. John Egan replaces Chris Basham in defence, and Oliver Norwood is in for the suspended Oli McBurnie. That might mean Gustavo Hamer playing further forward.

Eddie Howe continues his rotation policy, making four changes from the draw in Milan. Elliot Anderson, Miguel Almiron, Callum Wilson and Harvey Barnes come into the side in place of Sandro Tonali, Anthony Gordon, Alexander Isak and Jacob Murphy.

Sheff Utd (possible 3-4-2-1) Foderingham; Ahmedhodzic, Egan, Robinson; Bogle, Vinicius Souza, Norwood, Thomas; McAtee, Hamer; Archer.
Substitutes: Davies, Trusty, Basham, Larouci, Seriki, Davies, Ben Slimane, Brooks, Traore.

Newcastle (possible 4-3-3) Pope; Trippier, Schar, Botman, Burn; Longstaff, Guimaraes, Anderson; Almiron, Wilson, Barnes.
Substitutes: Dubravka, Lascelles, Targett, Hall, Livramento, Tonali, Murphy, Gordon, Isak.

Referee Stuart Attwell.



Hello and welcome to live coverage of Sheffield United v Newcastle United at Bramall Lane. Despite some decent performances, both teams have had iffy starts to the season. Sheffield United almost drew with Manchester City and almost won at Spurs; Newcastle almost beat Liverpool. But they didn’t, and they have one and six points respectively. This, dearest reader, would be a good game to win.

Kick off 4.30pm.


Rob Smyth

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Sheffield United 1-2 Manchester United: Premier League – as it happened
Diego Dalot scored the winner for Manchester United at Bramall Lane on the day that legendary figure Bobby Charlton died

Tim de Lisle

21, Oct, 2023 @9:32 PM

Article image
Sheffield United 2-2 Everton: Premier League – as it happened
Oli McBurnie hit the bar and post in the last seconds of a pulsating game that included impressive debuts from Cameron Archer and Beto

Rob Smyth

02, Sep, 2023 @2:02 PM

Article image
Newcastle United 3-0 Sheffield United: Premier League – as it happened
Allan Saint-Maximin, Matt Ritchie and Joelinton all scored as Newcastle put 10-man Sheffield United to the sword in the second half

Rob Smyth

21, Jun, 2020 @2:54 PM

Article image
Sheffield United 1-0 Newcastle: Premier League – as it happened
Minute-by-minute report: Billy Sharp scored the winner from the spot as Sheffield United won their first top flight game of the season at the 18th time of asking

Barry Glendenning

12, Jan, 2021 @8:19 PM

Article image
Wolves 2-2 Newcastle United: Premier League – as it happened
Hwang Hee-chan made amends for giving away a penalty by scoring Wolves’ equaliser against Newcastle

Tim de Lisle

28, Oct, 2023 @7:00 PM

Article image
Newcastle 1-0 Manchester United: Premier League – as it happened!
Newcastle outran and outclassed Erik ten Hag’s feeble side to leapfrog them in the table and move up to fifth

Tim de Lisle

02, Dec, 2023 @11:28 PM

Article image
Brighton 3-1 Newcastle United: Premier League – as it happened
The 18-year-old striker Evan Ferguson scored a charming hat-trick as Brighton outclassed Newcastle at the Amex Stadium

Rob Smyth

02, Sep, 2023 @7:01 PM

Article image
Sheffield United 1-2 Manchester City: Premier League – as it happened
City went top of the table after Rodri blasted a late winner in an increasingly dramatic game at Bramall Lane

Rob Smyth

27, Aug, 2023 @3:34 PM

Article image
Newcastle United 1-0 Brentford: Premier League – as it happened
Callum Wilson scored the only goal of the match from the penalty spot to end Newcastle’s three-match losing streak

Barry Glendenning

16, Sep, 2023 @6:58 PM

Article image
Newcastle 1-2 Liverpool: Premier League – as it happened
Two finishes from substitute Darwin Nuñez hauled Liverpool – who had Virgil van Dijk sent off – from behind to snatch a win

Daniel Harris

27, Aug, 2023 @5:56 PM