VAR and human error combine in agonising fashion for Liverpool | Barney Ronay

Jürgen Klopp’s side were on the end of bad refereeing decisions and Joël Matip’s own goal to give Spurs victory was final straw

Defeats in football are often described as agonising. But agony, to be really convincing, must be extended, unrelieved and built towards a decisive peak. Ideally, agony should look a bit like this.

There was a rare kind of pain here for Liverpool and for Jürgen Klopp, who, as Jota was sent off, was standing on the touchline ready to send on Darwin Núñez, but ended up just clutching hold of his arm, pummelling it vaguely, then shoving him back towards the bench. Define a bad day on the road. Let’s see. Start with two red cards, one of them a little harsh and interventionist, an example of yet more unnecessary Big Refereeing Energy.

Chuck in a goal incorrectly disallowed for a micro-offside just when you thought you’d taken the lead against the head. Add one draining, doomed defensive rearguard. Plus, of course, a goal conceded to lose the game 2-1 in the sixth minute of added time. Actually, make that an own goal. Oh. And there’s a train strike.

This was still a wonderful football match. It was a significant victory for Tottenham, who probed and nibbled at Liverpool’s 10, then nine men for the whole second half, who seemed destined for a pyrrhic point, but found enough edge, and blood and luck, to press their case right at the death. Happy teams tend to win this kind of game.

For Liverpool the game will continue to revolve around two refereeing decisions. First, Luis Díaz’s offside goal, which was simply a bodge and a fudge, VAR failing to re-award the goal when it turned out that Díaz was very clearly onside. The PGMOL ended the evening issuing an apology to Liverpool for what was a really dreadful, game-altering mistake.

It still seems strange that so much of the exhausting debate around VAR seems to boil down to basic issues of competence. These are professionally trained officials unable to manipulate their own technology, and to make a correct, very obvious call on one of the few things that always happens in every game. It doesn’t have to be like this. Imagine if these people were in charge of air traffic control.

Jürgen Klopp cuts a frustrated figure on the touchline during Liverpool’s 2-1 defeat at Tottenham.
Jürgen Klopp cuts a frustrated figure on the touchline during Liverpool’s 2-1 defeat at Tottenham. Photograph: Henry Nicholls/AFP/Getty Images

But in a way the mistake for Díaz’s goal was easier to understand because it was simply an error. The sending-off of Curtis Jones in the 26th minute was more puzzling, and indeed more representative of the issues with subjectivity around VAR, the illusion of precision or objective truth.

This was a very modern kind of red card: a red card that wasn’t obviously unfair or incorrect; but which also wasn’t obviously correct or fair. It was a red card that happened because the tools exist to call it into being. And because refereeing a football match has now become an active pursuit, the refereeing cadre mob-handed and tooled-up, poised with its finger on the button.

As Klopp pointed out afterwards, it was a slow-motion red card. Initially Simon Hooper awarded a foul and a yellow card as Jones tackled Yves Bissouma at close quarters. Hooper was duly summoned to the VAR screen and shown initially a freeze frame of the contact, followed by repeated slow motion replays of Bissouma’s ankle turning over.

This seems misleading in itself, unrepresentative of how sport happens in real time. Jones’s foot was off the ground, but it also slid over the top of the ball at high speed in a tiny space, end point of micro-calculations made, brain and limbs and moving ball triangulated. It was mistimed and overeager. But his foot was also touching the ball when he made contact with Bissouma’s ankle. And we know how this works. Freeze frame any incident, slow it down, it will instantly ooze guilt. Looking up from Bissouma’s ankle you half expected to see a mystery man with a trilby behind the fence by the railroad tracks, a puff of dust on the grassy knoll.

But then, this is just how the system is designed to work, an example of the new active refereeing, of approaching your role with Main Character Syndrome. Would anyone have cared, or gone back to that moment, if a yellow card had been deemed enough?

There was something equally grim in the stadium feed showing the challenge on the massive screen as Jones left the pitch, ensuring howls and pantomime horror. Here we had television interfering with the real-time experience, directing the reactions of the crowd.

  • Download the Guardian app from the iOS App Store on iPhone or the Google Play store on Android by searching for 'The Guardian'.
  • If you already have the Guardian app, make sure you’re on the most recent version.
  • In the Guardian app, tap the Menu button at the bottom right, then go to Settings (the gear icon), then Notifications.
  • Turn on sport notifications.

It was, in between all of this, an excellent game of football. Spurs took the lead with a goal from Son Heung-min made by a wonderful pass from James Maddison, perfectly calibrated with speed and fade, like a shot rolled up the green towards the hole, almost stopping by the time Richarlison sprinted on to it.

Cody Gakpo equalised before half-time. With 69 minutes gone Diogo Jota picked up a second yellow card, leaving Liverpool to play out the game a 5-3-0 formation. It felt like it might be enough, right up until Tottenham’s final attack, the ball deflected into his own net by Joël Matip, who crumpled on the spot like a gut-shot cowboy, the night of agonies complete.

• This article was amended on 6 October 2023. Darwin Núñez was being readied to come on when Jota was sent off, not when Spurs scored their winning goal as an earlier version said.


Barney Ronay at Tottenham Hotspur Stadium

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Joël Matip own goal gives Tottenham dramatic win over nine-man Liverpool
Liverpool had Jones and Jota sent off but battled back and looked set to earn a point before the late Joël Matip own goal in a 2-1 defeat

David Hytner at Tottenham Hotspur Stadium

30, Sep, 2023 @6:50 PM

Article image
‘A bit strange’: Liverpool’s Klopp baffled by Díaz’s disallowed goal against Spurs
The PGMOL acknowledged that ‘significant human error’ had resulted in Luis Díaz’s strike against Spurs being wrongly ruled out for offside

David Hytner at Tottenham Hotspur Stadium

30, Sep, 2023 @9:06 PM

Article image
Liverpool ask Premier League to review VAR decisions in draw at Everton
Liverpool have asked the Premier League to review the use of VAR in their controversial 2-2 draw at Everton in the Merseyside derby

Andy Hunter at Goodison Park

17, Oct, 2020 @5:10 PM

Article image
Jürgen Klopp calls for Spurs-Liverpool replay after VAR error
Jürgen Klopp has called for Liverpool’s defeat at Tottenham to be replayed owing to the unprecedented errors behind Luis Díaz’s disallowed goal

Andy Hunter

04, Oct, 2023 @12:39 PM

Article image
‘I am absolutely sick’: Roy Hodgson rails at state of laws and refereeing
Roy Hodgson said games such as the 2-1 defeat by Liverpool made him realise ‘I won’t be missing anything’ about football when he retires

Jonathan Liew at Selhurst Park

09, Dec, 2023 @5:45 PM

Article image
Furious Liverpool call VAR errors ‘unacceptable’ and ponder action
Liverpool have released a statement criticising the PGMOL following VAR errors during their 2-1 defeat at Tottenham

Ben Fisher and agencies

01, Oct, 2023 @10:23 PM

Article image
Liverpool in state of flux but Salah still Klopp’s priceless gamechanger | Paul Hayward
Rebuild at Anfield is made much easier by relentless Egyptian, who was decisive again in 2-0 defeat of Everton

Paul Hayward at Anfield

21, Oct, 2023 @3:42 PM

Article image
Finely tuned Liverpool are really getting into Jürgen Klopp’s groove
This may not have been a whirl of red pain for Tottenham, but every part of Jürgen Klopp’s Liverpool machine looks calm and settled

Barney Ronay at Wembley

15, Sep, 2018 @4:53 PM

Article image
Careless Liverpool do not deserve top-four finish, Jürgen Klopp admits
Jürgen Klopp said wasteful finishing is likely to cost his Liverpool side Champions League qualification, while Steve Bruce lambasted as ‘crazy’ a VAR ruling out a Callum Wilson goal

Andy Hunter at Anfield

24, Apr, 2021 @3:51 PM

Article image
‘Absolute disgrace’: Mikel Arteta slams VAR after Gordon winner for Newcastle
‘I don’t want to be in the hands of these people,’ said an irate Mikel Arteta as he called the officials ‘embarrassing’ after Anthony Gordon’s goal stood

Louise Taylor at St James' Park

04, Nov, 2023 @9:48 PM