European Club Association is orchestrating a silent football coup | Javier Tebas

Through its actions the ECA is intensifying the influence of Europe’s biggest clubs while disregarding the aspirational ones

The Guardian recently published an article by Charlie Marshall, the CEO of the European Club Association (ECA), headlined: “European Club Association is being cast as an evil elite killing football. What nonsense.” While I appreciate the opportunity to engage in a discussion about the future of European football, I must express my strong disagreement with Marshall’s assertions. It is imperative to set the record straight and shed light on the true nature of ECA’s actions and the distortions it has caused within the football landscape.

Marshall accuses me of promoting a false narrative regarding the ECA’s influence on Uefa. However, the truth is that the ECA has been gradually orchestrating a silent coup within the European football governance structure. This slow-moving coup is designed to empower the continent’s largest clubs, enabling them to exert greater control over the sport. Marshall conveniently highlights various clubs in his article, without recognising that they are, in fact, the dominant forces within their respective countries. The financial windfall from European competitions has led to significant distortions within their domestic leagues.

We also should not forget that Marshall was at the ECA in 2019 when it presented an early version of the super league project together with Uefa. Fortunately Uefa realised that it would destroy football after a revolt among clubs and in the media, but Marshall has little credibility when it comes to the future of European football.

Furthermore, it is essential to call out the democratic deficit within the ECA, a crucial point that Marshall conveniently glosses over. Of the 330 clubs holding a right to vote, only 140 possess full voting rights, while the remaining 190 have their voting power significantly limited. This disparity in voting rights showcases the undemocratic nature of the ECA, where a minority of clubs holds a disproportionate amount of influence and decision-making power. Such an imbalance undermines the principles of fairness, transparency, and inclusivity that should be the bedrock of any representative organisation.

By downplaying the significance of this democratic deficit, Marshall fails to address the concerns raised by many stakeholders within European football. The concentration of power in the hands of a select few clubs not only perpetuates existing inequalities but also stifles the voices and aspirations of other clubs. It is imperative that we acknowledge and rectify this issue to ensure a more equitable and democratic future for European football, which is why I support the nascent Union of European Clubs.

The ECA is intensifying the influence of Europe’s biggest clubs while disregarding the interests of aspirational clubs. The lack of a genuine democratic framework within the ECA further exacerbates this issue. To strengthen European football, we must prioritise the domestic leagues as the foundation of the European football pyramid and ensure that Uefa funds flow more equitably to support aspirational clubs. Only through a fair, inclusive and democratic approach can we restore balance and safeguard the future of the beautiful game.

Javier Tebas is the president of La Liga

Javier Tebas

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
All six English ESL breakaway sides rejoin European Club Association
Arsenal, Chelsea, Liverpool, Spurs and the two Manchester clubs are among the former Super League members back in the European Club Association fold

Paul MacInnes

16, Aug, 2021 @5:26 PM

Article image
A lesson from history: the European Super League battle is not over | Jonathan Wilson
The last, short-lived rebel-league experiment 70 years ago in Colombia tells us much about why breakaways happen

Jonathan Wilson

22, Apr, 2021 @2:00 PM

Article image
La Liga files complaint to Uefa, alleging Manchester City and PSG breach FFP
The Spanish league has claimed Manchester City and Paris Saint-Germain are in ‘continuous breach’ of financial fair play rules

Paul MacInnes

15, Jun, 2022 @3:07 PM

Article image
Re-elected Ceferin stresses Uefa opposition to European Super League
Aleksander Ceferin has emphasised his firm opposition to a breakaway league at the congress that confirmed his unopposed election as the Uefa president for another four years

David Conn

07, Feb, 2019 @5:00 PM

Article image
Rebels in Spain have the best hands for football’s biggest game of poker | Sid Lowe
There has been criticism, but don’t expect fans to mobilise in huge numbers against their own clubs, not like in England

Sid Lowe

19, Apr, 2021 @3:24 PM

Article image
England and Germany ‘will block European Super League’
Opposition from the Premier League and Bundesliga will block the plans developed by the ECA for a ‘super league’ in 2024, the German Football League president has said

David Conn in Paris

04, Jun, 2019 @4:30 PM

Article image
European Club Association is bad for domestic leagues, says La Liga president
At the launch of a new clubs’ union that has attracted interest from clubs such as Crystal Palace and Brighton, Javier Tebas said the ECA represented only the elite

Ed Aarons

24, Apr, 2023 @5:23 PM

Article image
European Super League: how did the clubs get to this point?
Analysis: 12 clubs have announced they are joining the new European Super League after a weekend of frantic talks. Why?

Sean Ingle

18, Apr, 2021 @11:53 PM

Article image
Would an ‘Atlantic league’ be good for European club football?
With clubs in Scotland, Denmark, the Netherlands, Belgium, Norway and Sweden reportedly negotiating a new competition, we’d like to hear your thoughts about clubs potentially breaking away from their domestic leagues

Tom Stevens

13, Oct, 2016 @2:52 PM

Article image
European Super League plans in tatters as English clubs, Milan pair and Atlético withdraw – as it happened
Rolling report: Look back at all the developments and reaction after all six Premier League clubs withdrew from the ESL plans

Gregg Bakowski, Michael Butler and Jonathan Howcroft

21, Apr, 2021 @4:30 PM