Phil Foden can exploit USA gaps but England’s bench offers a vital edge | Karen Carney

Gareth Southgate’s team selection worked perfectly against Iran but also showcased the importance of England’s finishers

In the 71st minute of England’s victory over Iran, Gareth Southgate brought on Phil Foden, Marcus Rashford and Jack Grealish. They are not traditional substitutes, they are the manager’s finishers – the players brought on to lift the tempo and see the match out. They made a difference and could do once more against the USA on Friday.

Gregg Berhalter’s side struggled to hold Wales in the second half because their stamina levels were depleted and a tired challenge from Walker Zimmerman on Gareth Bale resulted in a late penalty. If the USA run out of steam in the same manner, they could face an even tougher final quarter against the freshness of England’s bench.

The starters are there to deliver the gameplan and the replacements come on to increase the tempo by 15-20% and get the job done – and Southgate has plenty of options. The role of finishers is critical in the modern game, maximising everything available to a head coach. They bring intensity and in England’s case plenty of goals. Not many countries can call upon someone of Foden’s level off the bench and it is a great strength for England.

It was a World Cup like no other. For the last 12 years the Guardian has been reporting on the issues surrounding Qatar 2022, from corruption and human rights abuses to the treatment of migrant workers and discriminatory laws. The best of our journalism is gathered on our dedicated Qatar: Beyond the Football home page for those who want to go deeper into the issues beyond the pitch.

Guardian reporting goes far beyond what happens on the pitch. Support our investigative journalism today.

If Southgate had been offered a 6-2 win over Iran he would have accepted it. I know I would have. There were plenty of positives but he was concerned by conceding two goals because tournament football is about clean sheets and he will be telling his players not to switch off in the same way on Friday. They were the two blemishes on an impressive performance that laid down a marker in dominant fashion.

Southgate selected an experienced side and that shone through. It is unlikely he will make too many changes, fitness permitting. I would have picked Foden over Bukayo Saka but Southgate justified his selection. The team counterpressed well, winning the ball back quickly. That said, I could see a case for Foden starting against USA. He is a technician who can take a number of touches in tight spaces and against the intensity of the USA press that could be useful to find the gaps they may leave in behind.


It was great to witness Jude Bellingham liberated in the centre of the pitch. He was allowed to express himself, get forward and be who he wanted to be. As England progress, Bellingham’s role may become more defensive but he certainly made the most of being allowed to be proactive against Iran and it could do the same to the USA.

Everyone knew how Carlos Queiroz’s side would play against England: they set out to be compact and hard to beat. England needed to earn the right to break them down and it took until the 35th minute for Bellingham to head the opener.

You could see the plan: Bellingham would punch a pass through the lines to put England on the front foot; Raheem Sterling, Saka and Mason Mount all got into good pockets of spaces; and Kieran Trippier and Luke Shaw offered width.

At this level it is not enough to dominate possession in the final third. It is necessary to work teams by moving them from left to right and create spaces. Then, as the game goes on, it is possible to stretch them the other way.

When the game is stretched, England have plenty of options to utilise space in behind. The USA lack pace at centre‑back, something Wales tried to target, albeit unsuccessfully. I understand why Rob Page went with Bale and Daniel James up front because Tim Ream and Zimmerman are not the quickest but the ball rarely made it to them in the first half because of the USA’s press. There is certainly no lack of pace in the England squad and they will be aiming to use that to threaten.

The USA looked susceptible on set pieces against Wales; Kieffer Moore should have scored from a corner and Matt Turner was troubled from corners. Against Iran, set pieces were a strength of England’s. Harry Maguire should have been awarded a penalty early after being wrestled to the ground and softer spot-kicks have been awarded since. This is one of the reasons I selected him in my team for the opener. A lot of people questioned the decision to pick him but my reasoning is that 30% of goals come from set pieces – it is a massive weapon.

When Manchester United signed Maguire it was because his aerial duels were really good. He’s always been a threat in attack and he is incredibly important in defending set pieces. England look a threat and a physical team in the penalty area, so it is something they should capitalise on.

People should not underestimate how difficult the first game of a major tournament is. One of the favourites, Argentina, lost to Saudi Arabia. There was pressure on them because of the high expectations back home but they could not get the job done against inferior opposition. England deserve plenty of credit for what they did on Monday against a side who wanted to make things incredibly difficult. Now they need to back it up because momentum is key.


Karen Carney

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Unhappy World Cup memories for England keepers against USA
Rob Green and Bert Williams have unfortunate roles in the history of two teams who meet again in Qatar

Ed Aarons

24, Nov, 2022 @12:03 PM

Article image
Stodgy England toil in cold footballing custard but the message is don’t panic | Barney Ronay
Gareth Southgate’s England delivered a performance protest in their stodgy draw with USA but perhaps this should be expected at World Cup of bad energy

Barney Ronay at Al Bayt Stadium

25, Nov, 2022 @11:35 PM

Article image
‘We’re on track’: Southgate shields England players after tame USA draw
Gareth Southgate admitted he would have to shield his England players from criticism after their sterile World Cup draw with the USA

Jacob Steinberg at Al Bayt Stadium

25, Nov, 2022 @11:03 PM

Article image
Phil Foden gives seminal display to show England he really is sensational | Jonathan Liew
Manchester City’s young attacker delivers his best work yet on the biggest stage for his country in his preferred role

Jonathan Liew at Al Bayt Stadium

05, Dec, 2022 @7:30 AM

Article image
Blandest of displays proves England still far from top of the food chain | Jonathan Liew
On a night of stalemate with the USA Gareth Southgate’s limp team seemed content simply to stay out of trouble

Jonathan Liew at Al Bayt Stadium

26, Nov, 2022 @7:30 AM

Article image
Edgy England on verge of World Cup last 16 after fortunate draw with USA
Another World Cup stalemate left Group B qualification open to all but England were fortunate to escape with a 0-0 after Christian Pulisic struck the bar

David Hytner at Al Bayt Stadium

25, Nov, 2022 @9:10 PM

Article image
England 0-0 USA: player ratings from the World Cup Group B game
Harry Maguire was one of England’s better performers on a night when the USA’s three midfielders caught the eye

Jacob Steinberg at Al Bayt Stadium

25, Nov, 2022 @9:21 PM

Article image
Phil Foden should start against Wales or England risk another wasted talent | Jacob Steinberg
Glenn Hoddle’s frustrating England career is a warning that Gareth Southgate must get more from his most gifted player

Jacob Steinberg in Doha

27, Nov, 2022 @11:30 AM

Article image
England transformed soccer in America. Now its players stand in USA’s way
When the US meet England on Friday night, they will effectively be facing one of the reasons for the sport’s rising profile back home

Bryan Armen Graham in Doha

24, Nov, 2022 @9:02 PM

Article image
Knowing England’s luck we’ll win this depressing incarnation of the World Cup | Max Rushden
Tainted Qatar 2022 is unlikely to be won by Gareth Southgate’s side, but lose in the wrong manner and it could cost him his job

Max Rushden

29, Sep, 2022 @11:00 AM