Chaotic Manchester United remain in thrall to strolling Cristiano Ronaldo | Jonathan Liew

Ole Gunnar Solskjær’s star player rescued him again but his team looked confused and overrun in a 2-2 draw with Atalanta

The genius of the modern Manchester United is that for all the attention lavished upon them, for all the granular analysis they attract, they remain a largely unknown quantity. When they take the field, you genuinely have no idea what to expect from them. And not just in terms of results, either: tactics, personnel, effort and mood are all equally unforeseeable. They are the hyperactive toddlers of English football, equally capable of moments of startling insight and unfettered joy as they are of throwing valuable household ornaments into the toilet.

Naturally, this is a quality greatly prized by Ed Woodward and the Glazer family, whose entire strategy has seemed to revolve around reimagining this working-class football club as a brandable entertainment product.

Even the fans still seem to be on board for the time being, recognising – correctly – that the virtues of a watertight five-year plan and a coherent backroom infrastructure must occasionally take a back seat to the haptic thrill of watching your clump of highly paid frauds pull off yet another sensational comeback.

And lo, on a chilly Lombardian night United again went behind, again came back, again changed formations before half-time, again went behind, again came back, again kept the United content machine well and truly in business. For Ole Gunnar Solskjær, who has been in the last chance saloon so many times he knows the bar staff by name and has long since memorised all the questions on the quiz machine, it was another night that felt like it might settle everything and yet seemed to settle nothing.

His teamsheet offered us a handy window into the confusion. Four of the back five that had served United so well against Tottenham on Saturday were in operation again. So was Paul Pogba, but in a porous midfield three alongside the wandering Bruno Fernandes and the overloaded Scott McTominay. Up front Marcus Rashford played off Cristiano Ronaldo, an appropriate role for someone so used to feeding children. And so it was a system set up for defensive cover. But also dominating possession. But also playing the ball through midfield. But also the counterattack.

An injury to Raphaël Varane forced Solskjær to switch to a 4-3-3 shortly before the break and, true to form, by the closing minutes United had reverted to their default of simply flinging four forwards on to the pitch and letting them get on with it. It worked. It will work most weeks; individually United are that good. Yet there is a basic irony in the fact that a squad assembled for domination is so poor without the ball that they condemn themselves to long periods of being dominated.

Manchester United’s Raphaël Varane went off injured in the first half
Manchester United’s Raphaël Varane went off injured in the first half. Photograph: Luca Bruno/AP

Both Atalanta goals were good examples of this. At first glance Josip Ilicic’s goal was crafted by the fumbling limbs of David de Gea, who let the ball squirm through him like a tired fielder at deep square leg. But really the situation was created when Remo Freuler was allowed to advance from midfield and play a simple unpressured pass into the channel for Duván Zapata to cross.

Zapata’s goal came from an elementary long ball over the top from José Luis Palomino. And against a team as quick and fluid as Atalanta, United’s approach did occasionally smack of: go on, you do something and as soon as we work out what it is, we’ll try and defend it.

The problem here wasn’t effort: United’s three midfielders ran more than anyone else on the pitch in the first half. Much has been written and said in recent weeks about United’s reluctance to press from the front, but the real issue here isn’t so much that United don’t press, it’s that some of them do, and some of them don’t, and almost never all of them at the same time. Fernandes is an enthusiastic presser, although – arrestingly – often the only one. Rashford wants to press but isn’t really very good at it.

The Fiver: sign up and get our daily football email.

Ronaldo, meanwhile, presses with all the enthusiasm of the guy who fumbles for his wallet when the bill arrives, but has no intention of actually getting it out. And when you have scored as many goals as he has, decided as many games, it’s probably a little late in the day to start quibbling about his defensive output. He’s here now, he’s going to play, and very often he’s going to rescue a game with two goals out of absolutely nothing and keep your Champions League campaign on track single-handedly.

This is the Faustian pact you willingly enter when you turn your team into a Ronaldo-pleasure machine. The studio pundit sees a defence in chaos and a midfield overrun and a star striker simply strolling around waiting for someone to give him the ball. But the chaos isn’t the flaw in the system; it is the system. It’s baked in, priced in, hardwired. Ronaldo will solve the problems that Ronaldo creates. Ronaldo will restore the supremacy that Ronaldo has helped to surrender. And if that sounds like a recipe for a team powered by chance, vibes and pure, blind circumstance: well, that’s just the genius in action.


Jonathan Liew at the Gewiss Stadium

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Cristiano Ronaldo saves Manchester United from dismal defeat at Atalanta
Cristiano Ronaldo equalised twice, in added time at the end of each half, to snatch a 2-2 draw for Manchester United at Atalanta

Jamie Jackson at the Gewiss Stadium

02, Nov, 2021 @10:10 PM

Article image
Cristiano Ronaldo the inevitable headline star of a cinematic thriller | Barney Ronay
Manchester United’s win over Atalanta was made up of magnificent moments but this was a gruelling watch for home fans

Barney Ronay

20, Oct, 2021 @10:13 PM

Article image
Ronaldo completes Manchester United’s rousing comeback win against Atalanta
Manchester United stormed back from 2-0 down to beat Atalanta 3-2 in the Champions League courtesy of Cristiano Ronaldo’s winner

Jamie Jackson at Old Trafford

20, Oct, 2021 @9:05 PM

Article image
‘We played well’: Solskjær shrugs off jeers of Manchester United fans
Ole Gunnar Solskjær said he was unconcerned about his Manchester United players being booed off at half-time before their thrilling comeback to beat Atalanta

Jamie Jackson at Old Trafford

20, Oct, 2021 @10:27 PM

Article image
Cristiano Ronaldo rescues Manchester United late on to see off Villarreal
A goal in added time by Cristiano Ronaldo followed Alex Telles’s equaliser as Manchester United struggled before beating Villarreal 2-1 in the Champions League

Jamie Jackson at Old Traffford

29, Sep, 2021 @9:08 PM

Article image
Raphaël Varane could miss Manchester City game with hamstring injury
The Manchester United defender Raphaël Varane came off early against Atalanta but Ole Gunnar Solskjær praised Cristiano Ronaldo for his two goals

Jamie Jackson at the Gewiss Stadium

02, Nov, 2021 @11:39 PM

Article image
‘Outraged’ Cristiano Ronaldo puts Manchester United on red alert
Manchester United are watching Cristiano Ronaldo developments after the Real Madrid striker said he is ‘outraged’ at what he feels is unfair treatment by Spanish tax authorities

Mark Dobson

16, Jun, 2017 @6:38 PM

Article image
Manchester United defence proves no match for Messi’s footballing third eye | Barney Ronay
Even on what was a relatively poor night for Lionel Messi, the greatest club footballer of all time was impossible to tame

Barney Ronay at Old Trafford

10, Apr, 2019 @9:43 PM

Article image
Champions League 2020-21: group stage analysis and predictions
Manchester City and holders Bayern Munich should secure straightforward passage but Manchester United must find a way past two of last season’s semi-finalists

Jonathan Wilson

01, Oct, 2020 @7:59 PM

Article image
‘Truth comes first’ – Cristiano Ronaldo defiant on Old Trafford return
Cristiano Ronaldo, in Manchester with Juventus, said he was a ‘happy man’ and claimed ‘the truth comes first’ as he answered questions about the allegation of rape against him

Jamie Jackson

22, Oct, 2018 @7:56 PM