Eric Cantona saga epitomises the Manchester United-Leeds rivalry | Paul Wilson

The number of big names to play for both sides is remarkable – but none made a bigger impact than the only player to have won titles with them

Manchester United versus Leeds will always be one of the most evocative fixtures in top-flight English football, even if Sunday’s game at Old Trafford will be the first league meeting for more than 16 years. Their rivalry is surprisingly intense given that Leeds won their first title in the Don Revie era in the 1960s and have spent much of their time outside the Premier League since becoming the last winners of the old First Division in 1992.

Ignore anyone who tells you this has anything to do with the Wars of the Roses, though historians pointing out there were decades of bitter trans-Pennine competition between the wool trade in Yorkshire and the ultimately more dominant King Cotton in Lancashire are probably close to the mark.

Certainly in terms of the urban, industrial areas of the two counties there has never been much love lost between inhabitants of Lancashire and Yorkshire and football in the past half-century or so has simply provided a convenient platform for mutual distrust.

Yet much as supporters of the two sides love to dislike each other, the clubs have far more in common than might be imagined. Unlike a traditional rivalry between clubs in the same city, players have been able to move freely and easily in both directions along the M62 in recent years. The number of big names to have played for both sides is quite remarkable.

There are players such as Johnny Giles and Gordon Strachan, who enjoyed limited success at Old Trafford before going on to win titles with Leeds, and there are players who did the opposite, such as Rio Ferdinand and Alan Smith. Joe Jordan and Gordon McQueen travelled west across the Pennines when Leeds began to fade post-Revie. But best known of all, and poignant to remember in the week following Gérard Houllier’s passing, is the only player to have won titles at Manchester United and Leeds.

Roy Keane scores for Manchester United against Leeds in 1996
Roy Keane scores for Manchester United against Leeds in 1996. Photograph: Ted Blackbrow/ANL/Shutterstock

As Manchester United supporters have been somewhat mischievously reminding everyone in the past few days, Eric Cantona might never have ended up at Old Trafford but for Houllier, then manager of France, complaining to Alex Ferguson that his top striker was mouldering in the reserves at Elland Road.

Cantona had been the catalyst for Leeds’s 1992 success – even the last title won by an English manager owed a lot to a Frenchman – though by November in the following season Howard Wilkinson had lost trust in the player and begun to look for alternatives in the forward line.

This was not entirely a new experience for Cantona. He had arrived in England in the first place because Michel Platini, Houllier’s predecessor as national coach, felt he had burned too many bridges in France. Platini knew Graeme Souness and tried to fix up a move to Liverpool first, but the-then Liverpool manager declined the invitation on the grounds that Cantona would almost certainly disrupt the dressing room harmony at Anfield.

So when Ferguson talks of Cantona arriving at Old Trafford with his collar turned up, his chest out and a sense of excitement at finally arriving on a grand enough stage, he is selling himself a little bit short. The £1.2m transfer fee United paid Leeds may be viewed as the bargain of the century given what subsequently happened, but managers in this country were not falling over themselves in the race to sign a troublesome Frenchman, even at an affordable price.

Joe Jordan celebrates a goal for Manchester United with Gordon McQueen
Joe Jordan celebrates scoring for Manchester United with Gordon McQueen, who also travelled west across the Pennines when Leeds faded post-Don Revie. Photograph: Colorsport/Shutterstock

Ferguson decided a player of Cantona’s talent could and should be accommodated and the slew of titles and doubles that immediately followed were reward for his boldness. The managerial reputations of Wilkinson, in particular, and Souness never really recovered.

Nevertheless, Wilkinson was still in charge of Leeds in April 1996 when they turned up at Old Trafford in a poor run of form, to play a Ferguson side that had just overtaken Newcastle to move top of the league. Even though they lost their goalkeeper, Mark Beeney, to a red card early in the first half, 10-man Leeds put in a redoubtable performance, with Lucas Radebe, the emergency goalkeeper, making several impressive saves and only being beaten by Roy Keane’s 72nd-minute winner.

The Leeds support who had barracked their players a few days earlier after a lacklustre performance against Chelsea applauded them from the pitch in Manchester.

What happened next is part of Premier League lore. Ferguson, partly out of loyalty to his pal Wilkinson and partly because it was true, said if Leeds played like that every week their manager would not be living in fear of the sack. He added that while teams generally like to raise their game when visiting old Trafford, it was not much use to under-pressure managers if they could not try as hard in all their games.

The Manchester United manager may, just may, have been attempting to gee up the Leeds players for their match against Newcastle in 12 days’ time, though it is extremely doubtful he was attempting to wind up Kevin Keegan, much less set in train the sequence of events that led to the Newcastle manager’s celebrated “I’d love it” outburst a few days later.

Manchester United’s Eric Cantona challenges Leeds’s Carlton Palmer for the ball in April 1996.
Manchester United’s Eric Cantona challenges Leeds’s Carlton Palmer for the ball in April 1996. Photograph: Action Images / Reuters

No one now remembers it that way or even wants to remember it that way. The idea of Ferguson playing deliberate mind games and Keegan biting like a perch on live television is far too treasurable to abandon.

Keegan never played for either United, though he did memorably fly off the handle in Liverpool’s 1974 Charity Shield game against Leeds at Wembley. After the most soporific Manchester derby in history last Saturday, it would be good to see just a little sparkiness back when northern rivals meet. It is a tall order without crowds, but if anyone can rise to a non-occasion, Manchester United and Leeds have a better chance than most.


Paul Wilson

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Eric Cantona: 20 years on from the phone call that changed football
Sir Alex Ferguson's Manchester United were a mess before the arrival of a mercurial Frenchman from Leeds 20 years ago

Rob Smyth

24, Nov, 2012 @10:47 PM

Eric Cantona – a career in video

In 1992 Sir Alex Ferguson made a speculative request to Leeds about buying Eric Cantona. Twenty years later, Manchester United fans still sing his name at Old Trafford

Paul Campbell

24, Nov, 2012 @2:00 PM

Article image
Manchester United dare not lose to Feyenoord as spectre of 2005 looms | Barry Glendenning
Defeat would draw parallels with the last season United went out of Europe by Christmas, facing a backlash many thought would cost Alex Ferguson his job

Barry Glendenning

24, Nov, 2016 @10:00 AM

Article image
Bruno Fernandes hits hat-trick as Manchester United crush Leeds
Bruno Fernandes scored a hat-trick and goals from Mason Greenwood and Fred helped Manchester United thrash Leeds United 5-1 in their opening Premier League game

Jamie Jackson at Old Trafford

14, Aug, 2021 @1:38 PM

Article image
Paul Pogba cuts a liberated figure in Manchester United’s win over Leeds | Richard Jolly
The £89m midfielder showed off his remarkable passing range in racking up four assists during a 5-1 demolition at Old Trafford

Richard Jolly at Old Trafford

14, Aug, 2021 @3:09 PM

Article image
Arsenal’s ‘Wenger out’ crowd should look at Manchester United’s labours | Daniel Taylor
The struggles to replace Sir Alex Ferguson is a cautionary tale that ought to be heeded by those who want Arsène Wenger to leave Arsenal

Daniel Taylor

18, Feb, 2017 @9:02 PM

Article image
Premier League: Manchester United come back to beat Spurs handily
Paul Wilson: Ferguson looks to Europe after Manchester United overcome their latest Premier League challenge

Paul Wilson at Old Trafford

25, Apr, 2009 @7:04 PM

Article image
Golden Goal: Eric Cantona for Manchester United v Liverpool (1996)
The Frenchman completed his United redemption in firing his side to double glory with a moment of exquisite skill at the end of a turgid FA Cup final

Alan Smith

24, Jul, 2015 @9:00 AM

Article image
Manchester United must envy Arsène Wenger and his midfield 'clones' | Daniel Taylor

Daniel Taylor: Sir Alex Ferguson derided Arsenal for the type of midfielders they bought but David Moyes, his successor at Manchester United, will not find it quite so funny

Daniel Taylor

07, Dec, 2013 @9:59 PM

Article image
Manchester United keep it tight to clear hangover from City drubbing | Kevin McCarra
Kevin McCarra: Entertaining the public was off Sir Alex Ferguson's agenda as a low-key win over Everton got his side back into their routine

Kevin McCarra at Goodison Park

29, Oct, 2011 @5:05 PM