Solskjær’s approach shows players are not sets of data, but humans | Jonathan Wilson

The Norwegian’s man-management at Manchester United has been top class – but the game against Tottenham will show whether he has the tactical nous to beat the best

Nobody realistically doubts that Manchester United’s game against Tottenham on Sunday represents a new level of challenge for Ole Gunnar Solskjær but equally it would take a particularly cussed soul – or Nemanja Matic – not to acknowledge the change of mood he has already enacted.

Perhaps his role is simply to be a palate-cleanser but Solskjær has United playing with a sense of enjoyment that arguably has not been there since Sir Alex Ferguson retired.

Should players be so influenced by the nature of the management? There have been plenty in the weeks since José Mourinho’s departure who have blamed the squad, suggesting they owed it to the club, the fans and their contracts to give their all, no matter how much they disliked the bloke who was constantly calling them out in interviews and shouting at them to hold cautious positions. But that, perhaps, is to misunderstand the nature of endeavour: it’s all very well to want to will yourself to try harder but where does that will come from? Can it be willed into existence?

At some point, a player’s psyche is subject to factors beyond his control – and part of a manager’s job is to be one of those factors, shaping or guiding a player’s responses, whether by making him feel happy or angry or as though he has a point to prove or has a duty to defend his club’s colours or whatever. In fact, for a long time, certainly in the British conception of the role, harnessing the collective psyche of the squad was a manager’s main function. Matt Busby, Bill Shankly, Don Revie and Brian Clough all had other virtues but their main strength, in differing ways, was man-management.

Paradoxically, as more and more clubs have begun to use sports psychologists, man-management has come to seem less and less significant for the manager himself. Those who prioritised man-management – Martin O’Neill, Harry Redknapp, Kevin Keegan – tend now to be regarded as embarrassingly old-fashioned.

Mourinho is a more complex case. Speak to those who played for him at Porto and the impression is almost of a cult, such was the devotion he inspired. Yet recently, he has come to seem outmoded both tactically and in his handling of players – a useful reminder, perhaps, that psychology and tactics are not readily disentangled.

The Shankly model remains powerful enough that there endure vestiges of a desire for a manager-messiah but as the role is redefined as head coach, so the manager inevitably becomes more technocratic – and that is symptomatic of a much wider trend.

In an essay in The Point, Justin EH Smith, author of Irrationality, discusses the baleful effects of the modern urge to quantify everything. Algorithms and systems, he notes, make life safer and more efficient but there is a cost. Once somebody becomes a set of data, they become a commodity. “This financialisation is complete…” he says, “when the algorithms make the leap from machines originally meant only to assist human subjects, into the way these human subjects constitute themselves and think about themselves, their tastes and values, and their relations with others.”

This is as true of footballers as it is of anybody; in a sense, football pre-empted the wider shift: “The tech companies’ transformation of individuals into data sets,” Smith says, “has effectively moneyballed the entirety of human social reality.” That is a trend that extends beyond managers, to scouts, agents, journalists and fans, many of whose interactions with football will have been conditioned by Football Manager or Fifa, in which players are literally bundles of statistics.

This is not a dismissal of data in football. Clearly it is of use, in highlighting trends or anomalies, confirming or challenging what we think we have seen, alerting clubs to the likely strengths and weakness of potential signings. But Smith does highlight a limitation and perhaps a danger.

An alarming number of the blithe purveyors of xG stats and the like seem to regard their algorithmic reality as somehow more real than the actual flesh and blood game on the pitch with its players who have minds and personalities and emotions that fail frustratingly often to conform to the equation.

English football – and as Raphael Honigstein’s book Das Reboot makes clear, this was the case in Germany too – for a long time prioritised motivation at the expense of everything else. Perhaps modern football, though, has gone too far in the other direction. There has been a suspicion that, on the rare times Manchester City find themselves under pressure, they can lack leadership, in part because of the way their players are denied agency by an approach that demands players be subordinate to the tactical genius of their manager.

And there is, of course, an irony. As Mourinho unravelled towards the end at Old Trafford, one of his more bizarre rants was against the use of stats to prove footballing points.

That this came just two months after he had read from a sheet of stats to explain his use of Marcus Rashford means it can be probably disregarded as self-serving, obfuscatory hypocrisy – and yet equally his successor has perhaps proved his point.

The Fiver: sign up and get our daily football email.

For Mourinho, mental preparation was always a key aspect of tactical preparation and just because he has struggled recently to do that effectively does not invalidate the principle. Solskjær has made strides by dispelling much of the negativity around Old Trafford; Sunday should give some indication of whether there is tactical substance to go along with that.


Jonathan Wilson

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
‘Conned by Son’: Solskjær’s cheat claim sparks Mourinho fury
The Manchester United manager criticised the player after his team had a goal disallowed in the first half while Tottenham revealed Son received racist abuse on social media

Louise Taylor

11, Apr, 2021 @8:29 PM

Article image
Ole Gunnar Solskjær fails to solve Manchester United's prickly problem | Jonathan Wilson
Defeat by Arsenal offered further evidence United excel only when playing on the break

Jonathan Wilson

01, Nov, 2020 @7:37 PM

Article image
Martial and Rashford reward Solskjær’s Manchester United rejig | Jamie Jackson
Manchester United struggled to hold on to their lead until telling interventions by Anthony Martial and Marcus Rashford that bode well for their campaign

Jamie Jackson at Old Trafford

11, Aug, 2019 @6:21 PM

Article image
Safety-first plan for big games is defining Solskjær’s roundhead Reds | Jonathan Liew
First face second in the Manchester derby on Sunday – and yet has a game between the Premier League’s top two sides ever felt so essentially inessential?

Jonathan Liew

06, Mar, 2021 @8:00 PM

Article image
Solskjær’s lack of a cohesive attacking structure has been brutally exposed | Jonathan Wilson
Faced with a Villarreal-style low block Manchester United rely on individual brilliance and that is not enough at elite level

Jonathan Wilson

27, May, 2021 @10:30 AM

Article image
Manchester United hope Solskjær can convince star players to stay
Manchester United believe their change of manager could help convince David de Gea, Anthony Martial and Paul Pogba that their long-term futures are with the club

Jamie Jackson

19, Dec, 2018 @6:40 PM

Article image
Rooney-Ibrahimovic axis needs to be complemented by a dynamic runner | Michael Cox
Manchester United need a quick, energetic forward to capitalise on the work done in deeper areas by Wayne Rooney and Zlatan Ibrahimovic

Michael Cox

07, Aug, 2016 @7:12 PM

Article image
Solskjær’s game of patience at Manchester United is running out of time | Jonathan Wilson
Planning for the future is laudable but at some point there must be evidence of a plan being enacted in the here and now

Jonathan Wilson

02, Jan, 2020 @12:22 PM

Article image
Solskjær’s Easter woes show Manchester United must live up to their past | Richard Williams
Time will tell whether Manchester United really have hit upon their saviour and, either way, the club must rediscover their boldness of old

Richard Williams

22, Apr, 2019 @4:39 PM

Article image
United’s season risks chastening end after Solskjær’s promise of fresh start
Defeat to Barcelona is no disgrace but its manner highlighted glaring weaknesses and a Champions League return will require a swift upturn in fortunes

Paul Wilson

17, Apr, 2019 @11:48 AM