Spurs’ errors may damage hopes of breaking down Manchester City | Jonathan Wilson

Inherent sloppiness at crucial moments threatens to damage whatever tactics Mauricio Pochettino uses in Tuesday’s Champions League quarter-final first leg

How hard do Tottenham press?

There are two ways to play against Manchester City. You can press high up the pitch, as Liverpool and Lyon have with some success over the past two seasons, and try to force their defenders actually to defend, or you can sit deep, look to absorb pressure and hit them on the break. Jürgen Klopp may have dismissed the bunker mentality as being akin to looking to win the lottery, attempting to restrict the number and quality of the chances City have but essentially accepting they will have some and hoping they will miss – but it worked for Newcastle, Crystal Palace and Wolves. Pressing probably is the best way of disrupting City’s flow, but it is an approach fraught with risk: when it went wrong for Liverpool last season, they lost 5-0. Huddersfield pressed hard at the Etihad last May and were rewarded with a 0-0 draw; when they tried the same again in August they lost 6-1.

More pertinently, when Tottenham pressed high against City at the Etihad last season, hemming them in at every goal-kick, they found the ploy negated by the long passing of Ederson, who hit 19 long passes against a season average of 4.0 per game, and lost 4-1. In two games against City at Wembley since, Spurs have seemed unsure in their approach and on both occasions have been a little tepid, losing 3-1 and 1-0.

Occupying Fernandinho

Shaking City out of their rhythm is difficult, but when opponents have managed to do it, it’s often been by sitting a creator on Fernandinho and preventing him being the metronome at the back of midfield. Leicester, perhaps, were most successful with the ploy, James Maddison moving off the flank into the centre and imposing himself on the Brazilian. City are a too-gifted and flexible team for that to be a surefire way of upsetting them but it does seem a role to which Dele Alli is ideally suited.

City and the early goals

Whereas Liverpool’s pursuit of the league title has been characterised by anxiety, drama and late winners, since the turn of the year City have been gracefully efficient at tearing into opponents, getting an early goal and so being able to control a game. Gabriel Jesus’s header against Brighton in the FA Cup semi-final on Saturday was the sixth goal City have scored this season inside five minutes, the 12th before the 10th minute and the 26th before the 20th. That is clearly part of a policy: rip into opponents, prevent them settling and have the game won before any doubts can begin to creep in. It may be that in a two-leg tie there’s less impetus to do that – but then an away goal can make a huge difference.

Pressing Tottenham

City, particularly in the opening stages, if they are chasing that foothold of an early goal, will surely press Tottenham hard. Although Spurs have the fourth-best pass completion rate in the league, they are clearly vulnerable under pressure, something that was clear in that league meeting at Wembley. That plays into another trait: Tottenham’s inherent capacity for sloppiness at key moments. Call it a witch’s curse, call it Spursiness, call it a lack of experience at the very highest level, it afflicts them again and again at key moments: against Juventus in the Champions League last season, in the FA Cup semi-final against Manchester United last season, in the league defeat at Anfield this season. Spurs always give a sense that under real pressure, they will make mistakes.

Attacking City wide

Louis van Gaal said last year that the difference between his teams and Guardiola’s was that Guardiola was happy to send both full-backs forward at once whereas he would always keep one back as cover. Guardiola has compromised on that this season, notably at Anfield where Kyle Walker at times played almost as a third central defender, but full-back is an area where Tottenham may be able to get at City, particularly if Walker is kept out by his hamstring injury. That said, if Alli (or Christian Eriksen) is deployed to handle Fernandinho, it would be a very bold move for Spurs to play the 4-2-3-1 necessary also to attack City wide.


Jonathan Wilson

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Spurs prevail as mind-bending match sees Guardiola's City lose control | Barney Ronay
Pep Guardiola suffered another Champions League exit with Manchester City on a night where all hope of controlling the game was lost early on

Barney Ronay at the Etihad Stadium

18, Apr, 2019 @6:40 AM

Article image
Three former Premier League managers all expect Manchester City to break into the top four this season| David Hytner

David Hytner: Three former Premier League managers all expect Manchester City to break into the top four this season

David Hytner

12, Aug, 2009 @11:10 PM

Article image
Champions League semi-final draw: hopes and fears for Manchester City
One of Atlético Madrid, Bayern Munich and Real Madrid lie in wait for Manuel Pellegrini’s team in Friday’s draw. We assess the reasons for City to be fearful or cheerful about their potential opponents

Sid Lowe and Raphael Honigstein

14, Apr, 2016 @3:32 PM

Article image
Son’s solo effort secures win for Spurs after Lloris saves Man City penalty
Son Heung-min’s solo effort secures a Champions League quarter-final first-leg win for Tottenham after Sergio Agüero’s controversial early penalty is saved

Daniel Taylor at Tottenham Hotspur Stadium

09, Apr, 2019 @8:58 PM

Article image
Manchester City 4-3 Tottenham: Champions League player ratings | Richard Jolly
Kevin De Bruyne was outstanding for Manchester City but Son Heung-min ensured Harry Kane was not missed by Spurs

Richard Jolly at the Etihad Stadium

17, Apr, 2019 @10:59 PM

Article image
Tottenham 1-0 Manchester City: Champions League player ratings
Harry Winks was hugely impressive for Spurs, while it was a disappointing night for Kyle Walker and Sergio Agüero

David Hytner at the Tottenham Hotspur Stadium

09, Apr, 2019 @9:34 PM

Article image
Supercharged Son jolts City to show Spurs can prosper without Kane
Son Heung-min is quicker and more likely to dribble or power on behind the last defender and it may suit Tottenham to have him as their main striker in Manchester

Barney Ronay at the Tottenham Hotspur Stadium

09, Apr, 2019 @11:26 PM

Article image
Ilkay Gündogan says Manchester City are too nervous in Champions League
Ilkay Gündogan offered a scathing assessment of Manchester City’s mentality in the Champions League, describing them as too nervous, error-prone and vulnerable to setbacks

David Hytner

10, Apr, 2019 @1:11 PM

Article image
Tottenham win Champions League epic as Llorente stuns Manchester City
Tottenham lost 4-3 but beat Manchester City on away goals to book their place in the Champions League semi-finals

Daniel Taylor at the Etihad Stadium

17, Apr, 2019 @9:05 PM

Article image
Manchester City penalty against Shakhtar highlights need for VAR | Paul Wilson
Whatever the objections, introducing video technology in the Champions League cannot be worse than getting things as hideously wrong as at the Etihad

Paul Wilson

08, Nov, 2018 @12:06 PM