1) Coventry and Robins deserve plaudits

Amid all the hoopla over the departing Mark Hughes, it is right to take a moment to praise Coventry City. They were deserved winners of the third-round tie at the Ricoh Arena, despite giving up the greater number of chances to the visitors. The Sky Blues played with a determination and energy you might expect of a team assuming the David role in a Goliath encounter. But they were also calm on the ball and often quite cute on it, too. Their play was all the more striking, given the starting XI had an average age of 24 (and that is including the 36‑year‑old midfield warhorse Michael Doyle). Especially eye-catching were the rangy 18‑year‑old midfielder Tom Bayliss and the full-back Jack Grimmer, whose sweetly hit 25-yard strike decided the game. With a combination of youth-team graduates and free transfer signings, Mark Robins has built a side with a sense of promise about them and some of that was translated on Saturday. Paul MacInnes

• Match report: Coventry City 2-1 Stoke City

2) Frustration continues for Iheanacho

It was Uwe Rösler who raised the matter of Kelechi Iheanacho’s price. The chances are that Claude Puel would have preferred not to mention the £25m man at all. Certainly not when Iheanacho was restricted to 10 minutes even as Puel named a second-string side against League One opponents. Islam Slimani, whose own future is shrouded in uncertainty, was preferred in attack. Both expensive additions have been unable to break up the title‑winning partnership of Jamie Vardy and Shinji Okazaki but Iheanacho has fared worse. He has been granted two league starts this season and not played a minute in Leicester’s past 10 top-flight games; a bit-part player under Craig Shakespeare has been a forgotten figure since Puel’s appointment. Yet he averaged a goal every 106 minutes in the Premier League for Manchester City and got what proved the winner in a Manchester derby. A fine finisher is looking ever more unfulfilled. Richard Jolly

• Match report: Fleetwood Town 0-0 Leicester City

3) Raised voices over Pellegrino’s negative football

Southampton manager Mauricio Pellegrino
A late decision by the Southampton manager, Mauricio Pellegrino, against Fulham resulted in booing by the Saints fans. Photograph: Tony O'Brien/Action Images via Reuters

Criticising supporters for voicing displeasure during games rarely goes down well. Followers of Newcastle United, for instance, react angrily when they are told that their treatment of Alan Pardew was impossible to justify. They are the people who pay their money to go home and away, after all, and that loyalty brings with it certain expectations. More than anything fans want to see some heart, style and excitement and can usually accept not winning trophies, so it is too basic to call them spoilt children when they rebel against what they are watching. Which brings us to Southampton fans booing Mauricio Pellegrino’s decision to replace Pierre‑Emile Hojbjerg with Mario Lemina near the end of the 1-0 win against Fulham. It was a startling response. But before piling in on the mutineers, it is worth first finding out why they are so unhappy with Pellegrino – negative football is the likely answer. Jacob Steinberg

Match report: Fulham 0-1 Southampton

4) Ipswich’s FA Cup glory days firmly in past

Forty years ago this May, an exhausted Roger Osborne was helped from the Wembley pitch after scoring an FA Cup final winner for Ipswich against Arsenal. That day will never be forgotten at Portman Road but the same cannot be said for what passes there nowadays. Ipswich’s limp third‑round defeat against a second-string Sheffield United team brought their eighth successive exit at this stage, many of them avoidable, and what a disservice this seems to a club that used to gleefully exchange punches with anyone. Those days are long gone. They have little chance of re-entering the Championship play-off pack and it is verging on open-secret status that Mick McCarthy, who has gone from local hero to figure of disproportionate vitriol, will depart in the summer. The club are dogged by a lack of money and imagination; their shocking form in a competition that brought them international renown is a handy analogue for their decline under Marcus Evans’s ownership. Nick Ames

5) Robertson emerges as bargain for Liverpool

Virgil van Dijk’s debut winner may have been the big story on the pitch, and the FA investigation into the Firmino-Holgate incident continues to dominate headlines from Friday’s Merseyside derby but the best player on the night was Andrew Robertson. Since Alberto Moreno’s injury a month ago, the Scot has been superb and kept Everton’s main attacking threat – Yannick Bolasie – deathly quiet at Anfield. Nobody had more touches than Robertson and he won 81.8% of his duels, winning the ball back eight times. It is the 23-year-old’s defensive instincts and decision-making that set him apart from most other full-backs, including Moreno, and going forward only Ashley Young is a better crosser of a ball from left-back in the Premier League. After a slow start to life at Liverpool since his summer move from Hull City, that £8m is starting to look like a bargain. Michael Butler

Match report: Liverpool 2-1 Everton

6) Guardiola displays magic touch again

The latest illustration of Pep Guardiola’s enhancement of Manchester City players came in Oleksandr Zinchenko’s accomplished display at left-back in the win against Burnley. The 21-year-old is an attacking midfielder yet Guardiola’s ability to move footballers into differing positions was evident. “Zinchenko has never played left-back before,” the manager said. “But [Benjamin] Mendy is injured, Fabian Delph is always with problems – he plays one game, has to rest for the next one and Kyle Walker was not fit. And for this you need the squad.” The Premier League leaders host Bristol City in Tuesday night’s Carabao Cup semi-final first leg and Guardiola’s men remain in contention for an unprecedented quadruple. And given his ability to alchemise performances from wherever his players operate suggests he may be able to rotate successfully in all of these. “The important thing is to be involved in all competitions. We have to be involved in everything,” he said. Jamie Jackson

Match report: Manchester City 4-1 Burnley

7) Lingard continues to show big-game mentality

Manchester United’s Jesse Lingard tries his luck with a shot in the FA Cup tie against Derby County.
Manchester United’s Jesse Lingard tries his luck with a shot in the FA Cup tie against Derby County. Photograph: Lindsey Parnaby/AFP/Getty Images

To bill Jesse Lingard as Manchester United’s new game-changer illustrates the forward’s upward trajectory. José Mourinho’s side were sleepwalking into an FA Cup third-round replay against Derby County when, with six minutes left, the 25-year-old intervened with an eighth goal in 10 games. It was a spectacular finish, a 20-yard shot that gave Scott Carson no chance. Yet as recently as three years ago the Warrington-born player was a peripheral figure, allowed by Louis van Gaal to go on loan to Derby. He had also been loaned to Leicester and Birmingham City. Lingard was sent to Derby following a serious knee injury on his United debut and to bounce back and score the winning goal in the 2016 FA Cup final, plus finishes in the EFL Cup final and Community Shield final victories, shows mental fortitude and a big-game mentality. Precisely what is required of any X-factor United footballer. Jamie Jackson

Match report: Manchester United 2-0 Derby County

8) Sunderland left to beg or borrow

Just before a post-match drink with Tony Pulis, Chris Coleman was asked if he might see if the new Middlesbrough manager has any players spare. The most telling aspect of Coleman’s response was that he did not laugh it off. Eight months after relegation from the Premier League, this is where Sunderland are: ready to borrow off neighbours, who were also relegated. “We’ve got interest in a lot of players,” Coleman said. “I can’t say it’s Middlesbrough [players] or it’s Chelsea [players]. Our market is a certain market.” Chelsea’s 20‑year‑old defender Jake Clarke-Salter is due on Wearside but Sunderland need more if they are to prevent a second consecutive relegation. Years of budget mis-management have left Sunderland scratching around for loan players. Questioning some players’ attitude, Coleman said he needs to “quickly establish who wants to be here in a relegation dogfight”, adding: “We’re not financially strong.” Michael Walker

Match report: Middlesbrough 2-0 Sunderland

9) Jones’ reputation enhanced despite defeat

Luton Town manager Nathan Jones after the match
Nathan Jones showed his Luton Town side are going in the right direction despite the FA Cup defeat by Newcastle United. Photograph: Scott Heppell/Reuters

Some shaky kicking emphasised just what a huge step going from being the goalkeeping hero of England Under-20s 2017 World Cup win to Newcastle’s first team really is. There were moments when the 20-year-old debutant Freddie Woodman showed off undeniable talent but his pathway to Premier League stardom will clearly need to first take a detour in the form of a Championship loan. Meanwhile, much commendable attacking play and intelligent organisation not only highlighted that the 3-1 scoreline reflected a little harshly on the League Two leaders Luton but underlined Nathan Jones’s immense managerial potential. Yet if Woodman’s expected route to the top is already mapped out will there ever be sufficient opportunities for British managers to enable this impressive 44-year-old Welshman to work with elite players and test himself against the best coaches? Rafael Benítez appreciates how good Jones is but will club owners? Louise Taylor

Match report: Newcastle United 3-1 Luton Town

10) Vibrant Norwich display may prove to be bittersweet

Amid Antonio Conte’s post-match combustion it was easy to forget a football match had just been played at Carrow Road. Norwich’s performance should be acknowledged and, watching them work the ball neatly around their more exalted opponents, it was tempting to wonder why they are lodged in the bottom half. Daniel Farke’s side have nine points to make up if they are to reach the play-offs and it is a long shot; that is all the more frustrating for their fans, given some of the burgeoning talents in their ranks. In James Maddison and Alex Pritchard they have two deft playmakers and the 19-year-old Jamal Lewis looks a fine prospect at left wing-back – but Norwich are paying for poor financial decisions in their Premier League days and may have to sell the family silver if promotion is not achieved. It is not hard to see where the vultures may gather; such a vibrant showing on Saturday was bittersweet because this team may not be around to provide many more of them. Nick Ames

Match report: Norwich City 0-0 Chelsea

11) Mertesacker past his expiry date

Per Mertesacker’s time is up. The German will hang up his boots at the end of the season to take over Arsenal’s academy but it appears his expiry date is at least six months too late. Time and time again in Nottingham he was at fault, orchestrating a ridiculously high offside line, ruthlessly exposed by 18-year-old forward Ben Brereton. Never fast, now Mertesacker appears to be running in treacle, particularly when he allowed Armand Traoré to gallop through and win the second of Forest’s penalties. It was in the FA Cup – last season’s final – where Mertesacker last looked like his old self, and it is sad now to see such a player corrode, although he was hardly helped by the performance of his defensive partner Rob Holding on Sunday. Mertesacker was a fine player and his experience should make him a brilliant coach, but days like these are not the way to end things.

12) Wolves are already good enough to compete in Premier League

As they showed in the FA Cup tie with Swansea, the team assembled by Wolves is already good enough to compete in the Premier League next season should they go on to seal promotion as expected. The question is what are the long-term ambitions of the club’s Chinese owners once that objective is achieved? Having already signed Real Madrid target Rafa Mir from Valencia, they are now looking at adding striker Lewis Grabban from Bournemouth this month as further proof of their commitment. And with Jorge Mendes playing an increasingly influential role in recruiting the best young talent in Spain and Portugal, there is every chance that they could become the first promoted team for several years to trouble the top 10. Ed Aarons

Match report: Wolverhampton Wanderers 0-0 Swansea City


Guardian sport

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Premier League at 25: fans from all 47 clubs on their best and worst memories
Fans from the 47 clubs to have competed in the league reminisce about legends such as Paulo Wanchope, Duncan Ferguson, Juninho and Jay-Jay Okocha

Guardian readers and Tom Stevens

03, Jul, 2017 @9:12 AM

Article image
FA Cup: talking points from the third round
Héctor Bellerín could be the best right back in England; Kelechi Iheanacho deserves his chance; Jon Walters is becoming a Cup specialist; and Oxford United provided the only upset

Guardian sport

11, Jan, 2016 @9:08 AM

Article image
FA Cup fourth-round draw – as it happened!| Alan Smith
Rolling report: Cambridge United were drawn at home to Manchester United, while Chelsea could face Millwall in a London derby if the latter can defeat Bradford in a replay

Alan Smith

05, Jan, 2015 @7:51 PM

Article image
Premier League and FA Cup: 10 talking points from the weekend's action | Guardian writers

Guardian writers: Philippe Coutinho has everything, Gus Poyet sounds lukewarm about his future and has Aaron Ramsey's return come too soon?

Guardian writers

14, Apr, 2014 @7:58 AM

Article image
Football: 10 talking points from this weekend’s action
Brendan Rodgers’ tinkering is harming Liverpool, Manchester United could have a bigger problem than David de Gea leaving and clubs form a queue for Danny Ings

Guardian sport

18, May, 2015 @7:33 AM

Article image
FA Cup: talking points from the third round matches
Plymouth’s defence was classy and defiant, Ndidi excelled on Leicester debut, Batshuayi proved little and Stourbridge showed romance is alive, even in defeat

Guardian sport

09, Jan, 2017 @9:18 AM

Article image
Premier League: 10 talking points from the weekend’s action
Chelsea are becoming great entertainers, Zinchenko provides solutions for Arsenal and Fulham need goals

Guardian sport

13, Nov, 2023 @8:00 AM

Article image
Football: 10 talking points from the weekend’s action
Manuel Pellegrini will have an eye on Bayern v Barcelona, Tom Cleverley continues his renaissance and duo do their best to avoid the Europa League

Guardian sport

11, May, 2015 @7:30 AM

Article image
FA Cup third round: 15 talking points from the weekend’s action
Louis van Gaal should stick with a back four assembled on the hoof, Sheffield United’s recent Cup success goes on and the importance of James Milner

Guardian sport

05, Jan, 2015 @9:25 AM

Article image
FA Cup third round clockwatch – as it happened | Niall McVeigh
Ole Gunnar Solskjaer steered Cardiff City to victory in his first match in charge, but there were upsets for Aston Villa and Leeds United

Niall McVeigh

04, Jan, 2014 @5:23 PM