Gianluigi Buffon is in the wrong: referees need respect | David Conn

Juventus goalkeeper’s protest to Michael Oliver – which saw him sent off – may cause unpleasant repercussions for the embattled officials at the lowest levels of football

Heartfelt sympathy is extended to Gianluigi Buffon, of course, railing with much of Italy against the referee Michael Oliver’s last-minute penalty decision which wiped out Juventus’ marvellous three-goal Champions League second-leg comeback against Real Madrid. Oliver, remaining intently officious while the Juventus players circled him in disbelieving outrage, then met Buffon’s excessive protests with a red card, sending the great, giant goalkeeper off in the last match of his epic Champions League career.

It would take a cold heart, maybe, not to support Buffon in his passionate reaction and forgive his outbursts afterwards against the referee. Perhaps, as Buffon said so floridly of Oliver, it would take a rubbish bin for a heart. But then again, maybe not.

When Buffon and Juventus reflect, on even so enormous a sporting disappointment, perhaps he might find it in his own heart to apologise. His human response was understandable but his protest on the field was over the top, and his comments afterwards about Oliver were insulting, bordering on abusive.

This most pressured football drama was the highest of tests for the time-served football rule drilled into children when they first pull their socks up: never argue with the ref. Buffon failed it after the penalty was awarded. As wise old coaches tell their young players, he was only letting his own team down.

Arguing with the referee is necessarily an offence in the rules; Buffon, bawling and pawing at Oliver, had to go. His post-match comments to the media, about Oliver having a rubbish bin for a heart, not knowing “shit”, and having no personality, were unworthy, the Champions League equivalent of waiting for a referee in the car park after a disagreement on the public parks.

That, most importantly, is why Buffon is in the wrong. It is legitimate to question how far famed sporting giants are, or should be expected to be, role models to the millions watching them, but in their conduct towards referees, they do set standards. There are very important reasons why those standards should be decent; why, whatever the stakes, the referee’s decision has to be final and why the stars – and managers, and pundits – should maintain respect: because in the real world, abuse of referees is rife, accompanied by the visceral threat of physical violence.

Only last year in Manchester a young referee, Ryan Hampson, 18, organised a strike of amateur referees in protest at the violence and abuse infesting amateur matches. Hampson said he had been headbutted, spat at and punched during his four years as a referee, and knew many other referees who had suffered the same.

A helpline set up in response by an organisation, Ref Support UK, reported 70 calls in its first month, including two physical assaults and a referee who had been told he would be killed.

This has been happening for decades, before and after the English Football Association unrolled its “respect” plastic tape and ringed the public pitches with it. An experienced referee in Manchester told me years ago that the lack of respect shown by star players and managers on television set the tone for what happened on the parklands, where there is no spotlight or protection.

Human error is an integral feature of refereeing – which is why it does not actually matter, when discussing Buffon’s reaction, whether Oliver’s decision was technically right or not. However skilled they are, referees are necessary, a precious part of the game. On the parks just having a referee, somebody who turns up wearing black kit and wielding a whistle, establishes the authority of the rules, of the sport itself. Experience tells that without a referee, thuggery is less restrained, and it is understandably a struggle to have enough people willing to do it.

All of football feels for Juventus but Buffon was wrong, as Pep Guardiola was the night before, to confront the referee. The icons of football need to set a better example, remember what they were told as children and live by it at the galactic heights they now inhabit. Buffon, as penance, should be made by Uefa to do a season’s refereeing, on the mud baths of Manchester.


David Conn

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
‘Referee has a rubbish bin where his heart should be,’ says Gianluigi Buffon
The sent-off Juventus goalkeeper let fly at English referee Michael Oliver after Juventus’ dramatic Champions league exit at Real Madrid

Sid Lowe at the Bernabéu

11, Apr, 2018 @11:26 PM

Article image
Uefa must cut out the slapstick and play straight role in helping referees | Paul Doyle
Tuesday’s farcical goings-on at Real Madrid came a matter of weeks after Barcelona’s tainted comeback against PSG and are damaging the Champions League

Paul Doyle

19, Apr, 2017 @3:31 PM

Article image
Gianluigi Buffon and Juventus endure more regret as prize slips away again | Stuart James
The Italian legend will feel pain once more after losing in his third Champions League final, against Real Madrid, in what may well prove his last chance

Stuart James at the Millennium Stadium

04, Jun, 2017 @9:00 AM

Article image
Referees' strict rulings on unseen handball microcrimes are ruining football | Barney Ronay
Is a wonder goal really a wonder goal when skilled defenders are reduced to bouncing around with their arms behind their back?

Barney Ronay

07, Nov, 2020 @8:00 AM

Article image
VAR furore at Tottenham and Atlético a sign of what football has lost | Luke McLaughlin
In obsessing over the minutiae of refereeing, the game has sacrificed its spontaneity, narrative coherence and sense of fun

Luke McLaughlin

27, Oct, 2022 @2:32 PM

Article image
Referees are damned by their errors and ignorance of the laws is no defence | Barry Glendenning
The referee Keith Stroud’s bizarre interpretation of the penalty encroachment rules in the Newcastle-Burton game will haunt him for the rest of his career

Barry Glendenning

09, Apr, 2017 @1:44 PM

Article image
Inside the VAR bunker: a test for my irrational suspicion of referees | Max Rushden
A trip to Stockley Park gives a valuable insight into the VAR process, and also showed me that referees are actually quite pleasant, normal people

Max Rushden

24, Aug, 2019 @8:00 AM

Article image
‘Wounded’ Juventus will be spurred on against Tottenham, says Gianluigi Buffon
Gianluigi Buffon likened Juventus to a wounded animal before the Champions League last‑16 second leg against Tottenham Hotspur at Wembley

David Hytner

06, Mar, 2018 @8:41 PM

Article image
Jara’s elbow shows video referees need practice to end controversies | Simon Burnton
Officials say poor call in Confederations Cup final was part of a learning curve and the more VAR is used the fewer mistakes will be made

Simon Burnton

03, Jul, 2017 @7:32 PM

Article image
Champions League: verdict at the halfway point of group stage | Marcus Christenson
Paris St-Germain’s squad looks too unbalanced to make an impact in this season’s competition while Inter’s Marcelo Brozovic found a new way to defend a low free-kick

Marcus Christenson

25, Oct, 2018 @2:02 PM