Jürgen Klopp eases Liverpool’s pressing game in the search for solidity | Jonathan Wilson

It wasn’t just José Mourinho who was cautious – by keeping Henderson, Wijnaldum and Can on, Liverpool’s manager shunned the hyperactive approach

It is not something you often have to consider but what if José Mourinho was right? What if, on Saturday, there was for once no bluff or manipulation, no attempt to provoke or deflect attention: what if the analysis he gave of Manchester United’s 0-0 draw at Liverpool was straightforward and correct?

There was, of course, a passive aggressive jibe dividing the world into those who watch football for entertainment (the monsters!) and those who actually understand the game but beyond that his words seemed fairly straightforward. There was a – grudging – respect towards Jürgen Klopp for the way he had held his nerve, and perhaps that is evidence of a change in the Liverpool manager. The game never broke, Mourinho said, and so “for me the second half was a bit of chess”; this is not chess the actual game, of course, which can be played in as many ways as football, but “chess” the metaphor for something cagey.

“We came for three points but in the second half we felt it was difficult to do that with the dynamic of the match. I was waiting for Jürgen Klopp to change, waiting for him to go more attacking but he kept three strong midfielders all the time.” Klopp substituted all of his forward line but kept the three of Jordan Henderson, Georginio Wijnaldum and Emre Can in midfield; had he chosen to chase the game, he could have perhaps withdrawn one of them for a forward and pushed Philippe Coutinho deeper or into a central role in a 4-2-3-1.

That restricted United’s capacity to break, something about which Klopp was clearly delighted: he kept stressing after the game how United are “one of the best counterattacking sides in the world”, yet they threatened only once, on the one occasion when Henrikh Mkhitaryan had an impact, opening up the game for Romelu Lukaku’s one-two with Anthony Martial that led to United’s only shot on target. The Armenian’s anonymity was indicative of how well Liverpool countered United’s counters.

Whether Klopp was right, given Mourinho’s set-up, to remain so cautious is a matter of interpretation – as is the issue of whether Mourinho was right to sit so deep, given Liverpool’s recent form – but it was further evidence of a general shift in Liverpool’s play this season.

The sense is that Jürgen Klopp has asked his Liverpool players to ease off as part of a plan.
The sense is that Jürgen Klopp has asked his Liverpool players to ease off as part of a plan. Photograph: Tom Jenkins/The Guardian

The question for Klopp at Liverpool was always going to be whether his hyperactive approach could be as effective in the Premier League in which everybody plays at a high tempo. Even towards the end in Germany, there was a suspicion that with other teams also pressing hard and high, Dortmund were diminished. It was no longer sufficient to run further or faster than other sides in the league. In addition, as teams become more used to counteracting gegenpressing, as their players become more inclined to hit long balls over the press, the tactic loses its power to shock. Klopp’s approach is no longer unique; it’s not even unusual.

Familiarity is one issue; fatigue, or rather efforts to stave it off, is another. Last season Liverpool’s form collapsed in January. This season, with the Champions League to worry about as well, the sense is that Liverpool have eased back. They are no longer pressing with the same ferocity. In Klopp’s first two seasons at Anfield, the average length of each spell of possession enjoyed by an opponent was 5.9 seconds. This season that is up to 6.5, which is lower than the league average but far from exceptional. Distance run and high-intensity sprint stats have dropped.

That, presumably, is part of a conscious plan – the fear for Liverpool is that it is a result of players losing faith in Klopp and not pushing themselves to their physical limits as a result – and given what happened in the second half of last season it makes sense. The problem is that by not engaging opponents high up the pitch, Liverpool are having to do more traditional defending in their own final third – and they are not very good at that. It would be misleading to say that the high pressing of the past two seasons masked defensive flaws, for pressing is itself a means of defence. But what is true is that by pressing less hard, Liverpool are inviting a form of pressure they are ill-equipped to resist, which is why going into the weekend they had the third-worst defensive record in the league.

On Saturday, though, that vulnerability was barely tested; United had only six touches in the Liverpool box. The nature of the game and the identity of the opponent perhaps legitimised a more cautious approach but it is hard then to avoid the conclusion that Mourinho might have tried to expose that weakness a little more rigorously. Just because his analysis was right doesn’t necessarily mean his approach was. In a game of chicken, neither manager blinked.


Jonathan Wilson

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Liverpool’s Jürgen Klopp says pressure on ‘human’ managers causes outbursts
Jürgen Klopp believes managers should be punished for disrespecting match officials but cannot be expected to give guarantees about their behaviour because of the extreme pressure of the Premier League

Andy Hunter

02, Feb, 2017 @10:33 PM

Article image
Jürgen Klopp, José Mourinho and the cultivation of liderazgo | Jonathan Wilson
With Manchester United and Liverpool set to meet at Anfield on Monday, José Mourinho’s approach seems stale while Jürgen Klopp sounds the voice of modernity

Jonathan Wilson

13, Oct, 2016 @9:59 AM

Article image
José Mourinho says Jürgen Klopp must win trophy after Liverpool’s spending
Manchester United manager José Mourinho believes Liverpool’s significant investment in new players means Jürgen Klopp is under pressure to win silverware this season

Jamie Jackson at the StubHub Center

26, Jul, 2018 @8:06 AM

Article image
José Mourinho v Jürgen Klopp and the question of football aesthetics | Jonathan Wilson
There are several reasons why there is gloom at Manchester United while Liverpool, two points behind, are borne on a swirl of positivity – but entertainment is a fundamental one

Jonathan Wilson

08, Mar, 2018 @11:45 AM

Article image
Jürgen Klopp two years on – how much progress has been made? | Barney Ronay
Liverpool are a better side than they were at the end of Brendan Rodgers’ reign but a rampant Manchester United visit Anfield on Saturday and will be 10 points ahead of their rivals if they win

Barney Ronay

12, Oct, 2017 @6:00 PM

Article image
Everton’s momentum gives Liverpool’s Jürgen Klopp his most testing derby yet | Andy Hunter
Liverpool manager insists he feels no pressure as he looks to extend winning run against Everton in a match for which both sides’ preparations have been jolted

Andy Hunter

31, Mar, 2017 @9:30 PM

Article image
Liverpool’s Jürgen Klopp confirms Coutinho will miss Manchester City game
Jürgen Klopp has confirmed Philippe Coutinho and Joël Matip have been ruled out of the showdown with Manchester City on New Year’s Eve

Guardian sport and agencies

29, Dec, 2016 @3:14 PM

Article image
Up for the cups: Jürgen Klopp ends Liverpool’s wait for Wembley final | Andy Hunter
Liverpool manager’s commitment to domestic cups has been questioned but his delight at semi-final win was clear

Andy Hunter

20, Jan, 2022 @11:54 PM

Article image
Jürgen Klopp concerned by Liverpool losing their defensive solidity
The Liverpool manager admitted his team have conceded too many goals in recent games after Chelsea beat them 2-0 in the fifth round of the FA Cup

David Hytner at Stamford Bridge

04, Mar, 2020 @12:26 AM

Article image
Jürgen Klopp: Manchester United game was good practice for Pulis’ West Brom
Jürgen Klopp said Manchester United were stronger than Liverpool in their goalless draw ‘but you can use a few things from that’ as he prepares for Tony Pulis’s West Brom

Andy Hunter

20, Oct, 2016 @9:30 PM