Switzerland 0-2 England: Five talking points

Hodgson should be allowed to get on with it, Wilshere can learn from Inler and this is as exciting as qualifying will get

1 Hodgson has earned supporters’ patience for the campaign ahead

There were few fireworks in Basel and it is also worth pondering that Switzerland, only sporadically threatening, were perhaps not the behemoth presented by Fifa’s world rankings. Their World Cup showings did not suggest a side with exceptional strength beyond two or three outstanding individuals, after all, but Roy Hodgson can be justified in believing that he and England got it right. There was no need to play like Norway, whatever one’s interpretation of that might be, against a home side that was strangely tentative at the outset. England were not over-ambitious themselves but were intelligent in seeking to expose the Swiss back line and, in general, painstaking in their attention to the hosts’ danger men. It always felt that Hodgson was on a hiding to nothing in last week’s Norway friendly, which was met with scant enthusiasm at the outset. It is now best to give him some breathing space.

2 England’s pace can defeat the best when harnessed

There was evidence of it in what now seem the more innocent days of that World Cup defeat by Italy; there had been glimpses, too, in the first half in Basel. England’s attack has pace to burn and, if it can be matched regularly with cohesion, few will be able to live with it. That is still an “if” – Welbeck and Sterling both made poor decisions before the break after their speed had taken them clear – but the Arsenal forward’s goal showed exactly what is possible when all three attackers are in sync. The transition from Wayne Rooney to Raheem Sterling to Danny Welbeck was clean, clinical and never going to be halted by a labouring Swiss defence whose obvious sluggishness was targeted instantly. When Daniel Sturridge is fit, and if Welbeck can keep his form up, England’s options will have afterburners to spare. It may be worth remembering the optimism that sprouted after that Italy fixture, and that it was a mere four games ago.

3 Inler showed Wilshere the way to police a midfield at the highest level

There would be little to gain in singling Jack Wilshere out for criticism; his performance was not poor and moments such as his 10th-minute ball to Rooney – which one could not help feeling the captain would have taken first-time when feeling his best – spoke of his passing range. A burst early in the second half, when a shot deflected only just wide, was a welcome assertive touch and could usefully have been added to. Wilshere’s counterpart at the base of Switzerland’s midfield, the captain Gökhan Inler, cannot always match the 22-year-old’s technical gifts but gave a lesson in proactive, head-up patrolling of what was often a congested central area. Notable about Inler, who makes himself available and sets the tempo from deep in the way Wilshere has done in the past with Arsenal, is the way in which he uses his frame to screen the ball from opponents before setting off; physical tact is something Wilshere needs to add if he is to dominate games.

4 Fabian Delph recovered his cool to contribute valuably

The Aston Villa man was a horse for a course: he has operated in a 4-3-3 domestically under Paul Lambert, covers an exceptional amount of ground and looks after the ball carefully. A promising opening, in which he made a strong run down the left and popped a couple of decent balls to his front men, threatened to unravel when consecutive lunges on Valon Behrami and Stephan Lichtsteiner earned him a yellow card and a subsequent slide – after he had ill-advisedly let the ball run – caused concern. But Delph knuckled down on his first start and looked more positive after the break, causing problems with bursts down the left and perhaps being unlucky not to win a penalty. He also played a part in subduing Xherdan Shaqiri and can be happy with his night’s work.

5 This was as tense as things will get for the next 21 months

If the watered-down qualifying competition spawned by the European Championships’ expansion has one benefit, it should be that many coaches have the freedom to iterate their way to a desirable formula without having to compromise on their ideals in tense, tight ties. That is, of course, a generous reading of the situation: England and Switzerland go their separate ways now in the knowledge that, when they meet again at Wembley next September, it ought to be all over bar the shouting – with Slovenia, Lithuania, Estonia and San Marino unlikely to offer much more than fleeting curiosity. It is a shame that it has come to this and it was noticeable that the atmosphere inside a usually boisterous St Jakob Park never really hit the heights that it can. England’s only test of real import is out of the way and was, with a few obvious caveats, passed; no one would presume to suggest that 10 wins are already in the bag but this may well be as interesting as the campaign will get.


Nick Ames

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
England 2-0 Switzerland: five talking points from Wembley
As Wayne Rooney makes history, Harry Kane also reminds us of his qualities and Luke Shaw deserves praise in the Euro 2016 qualifier

Dominic Fifield at Wembley

08, Sep, 2015 @9:03 PM

Article image
England’s Roy Hodgson says win over Switzerland ‘points way forward’
Roy Hodgson urged his young England to ‘go again’ after his decision to play a diamond formation against Switzerland paid off with a 2-0 victory

Dominic Fifield at St Jakob Park

08, Sep, 2014 @11:11 PM

Article image
Switzerland have Roy Hodgson to thank for high place in world football
England’s current manager enjoyed a three-year spell in charge of the Swiss national team during which time he laid foundations that are now bearing fruit on the global stage

James Riach

07, Sep, 2014 @5:38 PM

Article image
Roy Hodgson must solve Jack Wilshere conundrum for new-look England | Barney Ronay
Barney Ronay A more innovative England are trying to get the best out of the skilful Arsenal midfielder – but should his role be at the base of a midfield diamond?

Barney Ronay

09, Sep, 2014 @1:31 PM

Article image
Roy Hodgson goes hunting for Euro 2016 base but keeps England grounded | Daniel Taylor
Daniel Taylor: The England manager will tour Côte d’Azur hotels having learned from World Cup mistakes, while there is more to come from Raheem Sterling and Jack Wilshere

Daniel Taylor

09, Sep, 2014 @9:29 PM

Article image
Roy Hodgson has shown angry side but can England prove their passion? | Daniel Taylor
Daniel Taylor: England’s manager has endured a trying week and knows only a brighter performance against Switzerland will silence the critics

Daniel Taylor in Basel

07, Sep, 2014 @9:30 PM

Article image
Talking points: Roy Hodgson’s chance to experiment with England | Dominic Fifield
England’s Euro 2016 qualifier against Lithuania and the friendly in Italy are ideal opportunities for Roy Hodgson to try out a few things

Dominic Fifield

23, Mar, 2015 @3:45 PM

Article image
England 2-0 Estonia: five talking points from Wembley
Theo Walcott dazzled, Harry Kane deserved more for his industry and another injury absence for Michael Carrick may mean a Euro 2016 finals question mark

Dominic Fifield at Wembley

09, Oct, 2015 @9:12 PM

Article image
Roy Hodgson tells England they can pull off Euro 2016 success
The midfielder Jonjo Shelvey offered an upbeat message from the manager, Roy Hodgson, with England set to take on San Marino and Switzerland in a qualifying double-header

Dominic Fifield

02, Sep, 2015 @9:30 PM

Article image
Jack Wilshere reveals England players given ‘homework’ by Roy Hodgson
Jack Wilshere has said that England’s players have been given videos to study and analysis of their performances

Dominic Fifield

09, Sep, 2014 @9:30 PM