Wayne Rooney: thanks for the goals but not for the waning influence | Michael Cox

England looked more lively after the captain was substituted and when Danny Welbeck and Daniel Sturridge played upfront with Raheem Sterling in the No10 role

A month into a campaign where Wayne Rooney has been named captain of club and country, questions remain about his precise role in both sides. Manchester United’s signings of Ángel di María and Radamel Falcao provide Louis van Gaal with other top-class attacking options, while it increasingly seems Rooney is crowbarred into the England side at the expense of overall cohesion.

In fairness, while Rooney was not in spectacular form at the World Cup, he was not one of England’s worst performers either. He created Daniel Sturridge’s equaliser against Italy with a fine run and cross, before scoring England’s only other goal of the tournament against Uruguay.

In terms of goalscoring, Rooney remains consistent: he has reached double figures in 10 consecutivePremier League seasons, a truly outstanding record. Nevertheless, it is fascinating thatwhile United have won the title in half of those seasons, Rooney’s best four goalscoringcampaigns have come when others have triumphed – Manchester City twice and Chelsea twice. Perhaps that tells the story: what is best for Rooney is not always best for his side.

At international level, there is a similar feeling. Rooney is now on 41 England goals, but Wednesday’s 1-0 victory over Norway was a microcosm of the situation – Rooney scored the only goal from the penalty spot and therefore found his name in the headlines yet again, but England looked most lively after he was substituted, with 20 minutes remaining.

That allowed Roy Hodgson to change system, playing Daniel Sturridge and Danny Welbeck upfront together, with Raheem Sterling at the head of a midfield diamond, where he had excelled for Liverpool in their 3-0 thrashing of Tottenham last weekend. There was greater pace in England’s attack, neater combinations between the lines and more players in advance of the ball, giving the midfielders options.

Even when Rooney was on the pitch, he was not involved in England’s best moves. Club combinations came to the fore: Sterling and Sturridge twice interchanged passes excellently, then Jack Wilshere and Alex Oxlade-Chamberlain played a neat one-two. England’s best passingmoves were played around Rooney, rather than through him, and for a No10, that is a damning indictment of his minimal influence.

In truth, Rooney’s best position for England might be as the primary striker, the role he developed into during the 2009-10 campaign for United, but has seldom played since. However, the fine club form of Sturridge means that position is not available, and shoving Sturridge out wide is an unhappy compromise.

Rooney can be fielded wide, but in England’s opening World Cup fixture, he was put on the left and failed to track Italy’s right-back Matteo Darmian, leaving Leighton Baines exposed. Worryingly, Rooney was only playing there to free him from the defensive responsibility of tracking Andrea Pirlo, something he was not capable of during Euro 2012. Not only has Rooney’s creative potential declined, his tactical discipline has vanished too.

Strangely, the Rooney problem will not be critical over the next 18 months – in such a weak qualification group England should defeat minnows with a minimum of fuss, the central midfielders should be able to command matches as a duo, and Rooney can concentrate on goalscoring.

Against stronger opposition, however, England will continue to look fragmented. By Euro 2016, Rooney will probably be England’s all-time record goalscorer, but Hodgson will be faced with the same old dilemma about how to use him.


Michael Cox

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Wayne Rooney promises England will ‘start new chapter’ under captaincy
England must ‘put the summer behind us’, Wayne Rooney said, as England return to action after the World Cup disappointment with a friendly against Norway

Guardian staff

02, Sep, 2014 @2:12 PM

Article image
Wayne Rooney ready to reboot Roy Hodgson’s England against Norway
The England captain says he is excited about his new responsibility and hopes England’s World Cup disappointment will stand the youthful squad in good stead for the future

Dominic Fifield

02, Sep, 2014 @9:30 PM

Article image
England dropping Wayne Rooney is not courageous – it is long overdue
English football loved the assassin‑faced baby, Wayne Rooney, but what we are left with now is a fading pro, approaching his 31st birthday

Daniel Taylor in Ljubljana

10, Oct, 2016 @7:16 PM

Article image
Wayne Rooney setback will hit Louis van Gaal harder than Roy Hodgson | Daniel Taylor
Time was when an injury to Rooney would have been a national emergency but England look equipped to cope – while a thin Manchester United attack may toil

Daniel Taylor

17, Feb, 2016 @8:10 PM

Article image
Roy Hodgson backs wasteful Wayne Rooney to reach England landmark
Roy Hodgson said Wayne Rooney had not been distracted by the England goal-scoring record on a night when the striker scored but missed chances during the 5-0 home win over San Marino

David Hytner at Wembley

09, Oct, 2014 @11:36 PM

Article image
Wayne Rooney chases England records but Harry Kane is kept waiting
Roy Hodgson said he was delighted to see Wayne Rooney back in a forward role for Manchester United and is unlikely to start with Harry Kane against Lithuania

David Hytner

26, Mar, 2015 @10:57 PM

Article image
England’s Wayne Rooney knows it is time to make World Cup mark at last
Daniel Taylor: Forward once described as England’s Pelé admits he has not performed on the biggest stage but is fit, fresh and ready for Brazil

Daniel Taylor

22, May, 2014 @9:29 PM

Article image
Wayne Rooney: spirit in England dressing room the best I’ve experienced
The England captain is the elder statesman in Roy Hodgson’s squad and says it is the best he has been in since earning his first cap 12 years ago

Dominic Fifield

15, Jun, 2015 @9:30 PM

Article image
Wayne Rooney boxes clever to stay ahead of England forward game
Before the Euro 2016 qualifier against Lithuania and the friendly in Italy, the England captain said he was delighted with ‘the strongest group of strikers’ being available

Dominic Fifield

26, Mar, 2015 @10:57 PM

Article image
Wayne Rooney warns England youngsters over intimidating Glasgow crowd
Wayne Rooney has talked to younger members of the England squad to warn them about the atmosphere at Celtic Park

Dominic Fifield in Glasgow

17, Nov, 2014 @11:00 PM