Soccer parents gone wild: behind the stunning Reyna-Berhalter family feud

Anybody familiar with the entitlement typical of American youth soccer parents probably recognizes something in the squabble that’s thrust the US men’s program into turmoil

US soccer has many forces acting against its success. The country shunned the sport after the 1930s, leaving a men’s national team withering and winless. Even after years of progress, soccer lags behind indigenous sports in a crowded marketplace.

Add one more powerful force to that list.


Also add its close cousin, snowplow parenting, a term referring to those parents who knock down any obstacle standing in front of their kids.

The obstacle du jour is Gregg Berhalter, the once and possibly future men’s national team head coach. The parents are Hall of Fame player Claudio Reyna and his wife, Danielle, a roommate and teammate of Berhalter’s wife at the University of North Carolina’s storied women’s soccer program.

And the child, though he’s 20 years old, is Gio Reyna, the Borussia Dortmund attacker who sulked for a few days after Berhalter told him he’d have a limited role at the World Cup. Reyna did come around eventually, and he played the second half when the US were eliminated from the World Cup in a 3-1 loss to the Netherlands.

On Tuesday, Berhalter released a statement admitting he had kicked his future wife’s legs in an alcohol-fueled argument in 1991, when they were both UNC student-athletes. He added these startling words: “During the World Cup, an individual contacted US Soccer, saying they had information about me that would ‘take me down.’”

To the surprise of absolutely no one, the Reyna family admitted on Wednesday that they had told the federation about the 31-year-old incident, though they denied making any sort of threat. They had opportunity, given that Claudio Reyna and Berhalter were national teammates of the USSF sporting director, Earnie Stewart, and the US men’s general manager, Brian McBride. And they had motive, given not only Gio Reyna’s scant playing time but also Berhalter’s comments at a 6 December conference on moral leadership, in which he said he nearly expelled a player during the World Cup before reconciling.

The contents of that conference were not intended to be made public. Nor did Berhalter name the player in question. And yet Gio Reyna all but confirmed the next day that he was said player, and Danielle Reyna confirmed on Wednesday that the comments motivated her to reveal the 1991 Berhalter incident, which she says was worse than Berhalter is letting on.

On Tuesday, the same day Berhalter released his statement, US Soccer alerted the public, saying they hired outside investigators as soon as they learned of the incident, on 11 December. That investigation has since morphed: “Through this process, US Soccer has learned about potential inappropriate behavior towards multiple members of our staff by individuals outside of our organization.”

Beleaguered US Soccer officials, already accustomed to being either the referee, the instigator or the instigated in controversies big and small, declined on a Wednesday conference call to give more detail.

In short: the Reynas said nothing about a physical fight between Berhalter and his future wife for more than three decades but mentioned it to US Soccer officials after learning that Berhalter had mentioned in a private conference that he had since-resolved issues with a player he didn’t identify who got scant playing time for most of the World Cup.

In other words, the Reynas acted like typical soccer parents in the US.

Claudio Reyna and Gregg Berhalter
Claudio Reyna (right) and Gregg Berhalter, second from right, train with the US men’s national team during the 2002 World Cup at the Misari Football Center in Seoul, South Korea. Photograph: Brian Bahr/Getty Images

Every youth soccer parent, coach and referee knows these parents. They’re the ones who gush about their kid’s new youth club in August and then rant against it when they leave in May. They’re the ones who intimidate coaches into substitutions at nearly every stoppage in play, lest a player be left on the sideline longer than a few minutes. They’re the ones who gossip on anonymous message boards to trash coaches and clubs.

To be sure, complaints about playing time in sports aren’t exactly breaking news. But if there was a World Cup for such griping, the US would surely have a crowded trophy case.

Woe be unto the coach who keeps the wrong player out of the lineup of any team from under-9s to the national teams, men and women.

Woe be unto the referee who crosses a women’s national team player who feels emboldened by a sycophantic fanbase not just to argue with referees but to humiliate them.

Washington Spirit defender Amber Brooks let the refs know how she felt about a particular call today.

— The Comeback (@thecomeback) September 10, 2022

Woe be unto the youth soccer coach who fails to achieve the sometimes-incompatible goals of winning trophies and developing children into prized players who can earn everything from a spot on the local high school varsity to a professional opportunity.

This is, after all, a country in which parents took advantage of preferential college admissions for athletes by fabricating their children’s exploits, part of a series of events exposed under the catch-all title Operation Varsity Blues.

It’s also a country in which players grow up and see nothing wrong with taking a staggering 90% of the prize money the men earned in the 2022 World Cup and the women will earn in the 2023 World Cup, all while grassroots organizations seethe at seeing the rich get richer. (At a media teleconference on the agreement, I asked representatives from both teams if they plan on building bridges with those who work with youth and amateurs. Silence.)

And it’s a culture that rewards players who don’t think they need to listen to coaches or critics. In women’s soccer, the fanbase has adopted the attitude that players are always right, while coaches, league officials and referees are always wrong. In men’s soccer, players are less immune to criticism but have come up through a youth system that all too often pampered them, perhaps to the detriment of their performance.

“Are you going to continue to be a bunch of soft, underperforming, tattooed millionaires?” Alexi Lalas asked in 2017 when the men were teetering on the edge of World Cup qualifying failure.

Hey #USMNT, @AlexiLalas has a message for you.

— FOX Soccer (@FOXSoccer) September 11, 2017

But ultimately, it comes back to the parents. Not every parent. Not every player. But too many.

The investigation of Berhalter and any related business may take months. In the meantime, US Soccer must decide whether to offer Berhalter a new contract or look elsewhere. The federation has already shown it can drag out such decisions for more than a year.

And so in dragging down Berhalter, the Reynas may also drag down the federation that Claudio Reyna once represented so well and Gio Reyna may yet do the same. Those who are involved with youth soccer have seen it all before. The ironic aspect of the term “snowplow parent” is that those snowplows leave behind scorched earth.

At the heart of the matter here are two families, once closely intertwined, torn apart by an argument over playing time and a player’s attitude.

Just like we see in youth soccer every day.


Beau Dure

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Berhalter denies Gio Reyna conspiracy claims as USA-Iran match approaches
The USA coach was forced to field questions on US immigration policy and inflation as well as his team’s crucial final group match

Bryan Armen Graham in Doha

29, Nov, 2022 @7:30 AM

Article image
Christian Pulisic's splashy transfer exposes gaping flaws in US Soccer
The most expensive US player ever will continue to bear the expectations of a nation, but his move to Chelsea exposes problems within the game in America

Kristan Heneage

03, Jan, 2019 @10:44 AM

Article image
Christian Pulisic has succeeded in spite of American soccer, not because of it
The rise of maybe the best American soccer player ever, who’s been linked to Liverpool and Manchester United, doesn’t square with US Soccer’s problems

Graham Ruthven

12, Jan, 2018 @3:15 PM

Article image
England transformed soccer in America. Now its players stand in USA’s way
When the US meet England on Friday night, they will effectively be facing one of the reasons for the sport’s rising profile back home

Bryan Armen Graham in Doha

24, Nov, 2022 @9:02 PM

Article image
Christian Pulisic open to Premier League move with Chelsea leading chase
Christian Pulisic has said he is open to moving to the Premier League, with Chelsea understood to be leading the race to sign the forward from Borussia Dortmund

Ed Aarons

14, Nov, 2018 @3:03 PM

Article image
Christian Pulisic realises his dream by moving to the Premier League
Chelsea’s £58m signing fell in love with the game when living in England as a child and playing for Brackley Town’s youth team

Ed Aarons

02, Jan, 2019 @5:52 PM

Article image
'Crushed' Christian Pulisic questions US development after World Cup failure
Christian Pulisic has spoken out on his dismay at USA’s failure to reach next year’s World Cup, and the level of football talent in America

Guardian sport

13, Nov, 2017 @4:34 PM

Article image
From coaches to pushy parents, US men’s soccer is married to mediocrity
A recent debacle at the top of the game in America caused uproar. But the same patterns are repeated through the sport in the US

Eric Wynalda

29, Mar, 2023 @9:00 AM

Article image
US use rainbow logo at Qatar World Cup in support of LGBTQ community
The US men’s team are showing their support for the LGBTQ community by way of a rainbow-themed logo at their training facility in Qatar


14, Nov, 2022 @5:01 PM

Article image
Bruce Arena is gone. Should US Soccer president Sunil Gulati be next?
The veteran coach could not right the systemic failure within the game in America. Maybe it’s time to look at the structure itself

Beau Dure

13, Oct, 2017 @7:22 PM