Form, formation and Foden: big issues facing Southgate before World Cup

As England prepare for final pre-tournament games we address five key topics, also including the need to shed reliance on Kane

Players struggling at club level

Gareth Southgate risks running into problems if he picks players on reputation rather than form. England’s manager has argued that he is right to consider international performances when he selects a squad, yet with several key individuals struggling at club level it will be how interesting to see how far Southgate’s loyal streak goes before the World Cup.

There are problems across the board. At left-back there is concern over Chelsea’s Ben Chilwell, who has recently returned from a serious knee injury, and Luke Shaw, who has lost his place at Manchester United. In midfield Kalvin Phillips, missing from this camp with a shoulder problem, has barely played since joining Manchester City. Further forward Mason Mount is going through a dip at Chelsea and Jarrod Bowen has been underwhelming for West Ham this season. Is Bowen really a better bet than Jadon Sancho?

Then there’s Harry Maguire. The United centre-back presents Southgate with his biggest conundrum. Will he follow Erik ten Hag’s lead and drop him? United have been far more solid without Maguire and there is no justification for Southgate starting him if he is not playing for his club. Fikayo Tomori is playing every week for Milan, who won Serie A last season, and Eric Dier has excelled for Tottenham.

Three or four at the back?

England’s disastrous start to their Nations League campaign could spook Southgate into becoming even more pragmatic. The memory of Hungary running riot at Molineux remains raw and it would not be a surprise if England line up in a 3-4-3 when they play Italy on Friday and Germany on Monday.

Yet much would depend on how Southgate sets up the team. Reece James and Chilwell would be progressive options as the wing-backs. A fluid front three could be exciting. An attacking partner for Declan Rice in midfield could be a game-changer.

The concern, though, is that Southgate veers towards negativity. Perhaps England lack the centre-backs to play a 4-3-3, but the argument against caution is that they are hardly short of creative players. Is it time they played to their strengths?

Ben Chilwell (left) and Reece James at an England training session last year. They would be progressive choices at wing-back.
Ben Chilwell (left) and Reece James at an England training session last year. They would be progressive choices at wing-back. Photograph: Nick Potts/PA

Make a decision on Alexander-Arnold

Trent Alexander-Arnold is a brilliant footballer. His crossing is astonishing, his passing range is superb and he is regularly one of Liverpool’s best creators. None of that means he is guaranteed to go to the World Cup. It is hard to ignore Alexander-Arnold’s defensive struggles for Liverpool. He is not the same player for England. He has not flourished for Southgate, who has often preferred the less exciting but more reliable Kieran Trippier, and the sense is that Alexander-Arnold needs this camp to go well. Otherwise it is hard to see any point in Southgate cramming four right-backs into his squad.

Get the best out of Foden

There was plenty of excitement about Phil Foden before Euro 2020. The City youngster turned up with dyed blond hair, which inevitably drew comparisons to Paul Gascoigne’s Euro 96 look, but he ended up having a disappointing tournament for reasons largely beyond his control.

It has been frustrating for Foden, whose international career is yet to get going. Yet England need to work out how to use him. This is a player trusted by Pep Guardiola, who has used Foden as a winger, a false 9, a No 10 and a No 8. England, who have not scored from open play in their last four games, need to tap into Foden’s inventiveness.

Phil Foden (left) in action for England against Scotland at Euro 2020.
Phil Foden (left) in action for England against Scotland at Euro 2020. Photograph: Facundo Arrizabalaga/EPA

The reliance on Kane and Sterling

Southgate needs more from his attackers. England are too reliant on Harry Kane and Raheem Sterling for their goals. Mount needs to take more responsibility on the ball, and Southgate wants Bowen, Bukayo Saka and Jack Grealish to emulate Sterling by chipping in with goals from the flanks.

England are stale in attack. The threat comes from Kane, but what happens if the captain has no service, has a bad game or picks up an injury? Southgate needs depth. As it stands, though, Tammy Abraham is yet to prove he is a suitable deputy. Ivan Toney, called up for the first time, will hope to prove he can be England’s Plan B. It is a worry for Southgate, who could do with Marcus Rashford recovering from the injury that has forced the United forward to miss these fixtures. Rashford, who has shown signs of getting back to his best, has lifted the burden on Kane and Sterling in the past.


Jacob Steinberg in Milan

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Manchester United players have ‘lot to do’ to make World Cup, warns Southgate
Gareth Southgate has made it clear that players such as Marcus Rashford and Jadon Sancho are at risk of missing out on Qatar

David Hytner

12, Jun, 2022 @9:30 PM

Article image
Gareth Southgate warns against piling pressure on England’s Phil Foden
Gareth Southgate may start with Phil Foden against Wales but has warned against putting pressure on the Manchester City youngster

Jacob Steinberg in Doha

28, Nov, 2022 @10:30 PM

Article image
Marcus Rashford ‘different player’ after return to form, says Gareth Southgate
‘We’ve got a different version completely of the Euro 2020 player,’ the England manager said of his two-goal forward

Jacob Steinberg at the Ahmad bin Ali Stadium

29, Nov, 2022 @11:33 PM

Article image
Southgate regrets ‘missed opportunity’ before England host Ivory Coast
Gareth Southgate said it is unfortunate that the pandemic means England will face only one non-European opponent in the year leading up to the 2022 World Cup

Nick Ames

28, Mar, 2022 @9:30 PM

Article image
Gareth Southgate will wait before making decision on England future
Gareth Southgate said he would take time before making a decision on his England future after his side were beaten by France in the World Cup quarter-final

Jacob Steinberg at Al Bayt Stadium

10, Dec, 2022 @11:36 PM

Article image
Gareth Southgate says World Cup can be England’s best moment ever
Gareth Southgate will blast away the negativity surrounding England by telling his players they can make this the best period in the team’s history by winning the World Cup

Jacob Steinberg

12, Nov, 2022 @10:30 PM

Article image
Southgate voices England concerns about human rights at Qatar World Cup
The England manager said it was vital that female and LGBTQ+ fans, among others, were given stronger assurances about their safety in Qatar

Nick Ames

19, Mar, 2022 @10:30 PM

Article image
Trent Alexander-Arnold is yet to find club form with England, says Southgate
Gareth Southgate admitted ‘I’ve to look at myself’ over Trent Alexander-Arnold’s drop-off in form when playing for England

David Hytner

18, Mar, 2021 @10:30 PM

Article image
Southgate defends Maddison World Cup call-up and dismisses ‘misconceptions’
The England manager said he had ‘no concerns’ about how the Leicester playmaker James Maddison will fit in with the squad

David Hytner

10, Nov, 2022 @10:30 PM

Article image
Gareth Southgate decides to carry on in England job despite World Cup agony
Gareth Southgate has decided to continue as England’s head coach after considering his future in the wake of the World Cup quarter-final defeat by France

David Hytner in Doha

17, Dec, 2022 @9:42 PM