Old Firm intrigue can’t mask deeply troubling broader picture in Scotland | Ewan Murray

Glasgow rivals’ meeting will be exciting, but broken system means gulf between them and other teams just keeps growing

Excitement around Saturday’s visit of Rangers to Celtic Park is appropriate. The extent to which Ange Postecoglou can further elevate Celtic after the success of last season remains unknown. So, too, whether Giovanni van Bronckhorst can prove himself capable of re-establishing Rangers as the finest team in the country. It is early enough in the campaign for levels of intrigue to be legitimately high.

That a nine-man Rangers slipped to a draw at Hibernian means Celtic could be five points clear of their oldest foes before the 3pm kick‑offs get under way. This would represent an ominous scenario for those in blue even on September’s first weekend. It is the broader picture that is so troublesome for anyone with an interest in competitive balance. Scottish football has a growing problem, one close to 40 years in the making but which on all available evidence will not be resolved, barring a revolution, in four centuries.

Liverpool’s 9-0 dismantling of Bournemouth is a useful reference point for supporters of Celtic, who have jibes about an amateur league thrown at them because of the same result against Dundee United. That United also lost 7-0, 4-1 and 3-0 in the blink of an eye – they sacked their manager, which suggests at least an element of pride – points towards an exceptional case. It is not; from the moment in 1985 when Aberdeen claimed the Premier Division, the gulf between one – or in this case, two – Scottish sides and the rest has never been so alarming. Those who ignore the chasm, largely on the basis of tribal obsession, are burying their heads in the sand. Scotland’s top flight has the unpredictability of the university boat race.

A solitary player, Ross County’s Alex Iacovitti, has scored against Celtic in domestic football this season. Twice, in fairness. Between them, Celtic and Rangers have notched 35 goals over 10 league games and conceded four. It is an increasingly grim scene which the riches of the Champions League – the Old Firm have both qualified for the group stages of Europe’s top club competition – exacerbates. Scotland’s league is unsustainable as a spectacle; privately, Celtic and Rangers must know that.

They have a duty to work harder than ever to find an alternative. Scottish football will never die – it is far too important in a societal context – and attendance numbers remain impressive, yet a league where third place is the best possible outcome for 10 of the 12 teams is fundamentally flawed. Outsiders with broader experience or ambition rarely take long to grow bored of Scotland’s formulaic chase for the title.

Carl Starfelt celebrates scoring Celtic’s ninth against Dundee United.
Carl Starfelt celebrates scoring Celtic’s ninth against Dundee United last weekend. Photograph: Steve Welsh/PA

There is a not unreasonable counterpoint. That is, major leagues all over Europe are hurtling towards monopoly or duopoly. Scotland is no different, goes this logic, to Germany, France, Spain or England. The trouble is that none of these countries are approaching four decades of the same old, same old.

Arsenal, Tottenham, Chelsea or – no laughing at the back – Manchester United most likely will not win the Premier League any time soon but it would be no epic shock if at some period over the next decade they did. Likewise, Borussia Dortmund, Bayer Leverkusen or RB Leipzig. France has had a range of champions since the mid-80s. Lille claimed Ligue 1 as recently as 2021.

It is also necessary to point out that Bayern Munich, Liverpool, Manchester City, Real Madrid and Barcelona – and even those swatted into the distance – have established themselves at various recent points as among the best in Europe. Celtic were embarrassed by Bodø/Glimt last season and, although Rangers excelled in reaching the Europa League final, mere qualification for the Champions League sends Scotland’s big two giddy with excitement. Motherwell’s conquerors in Europe this season? Sligo Rovers.

Followers of Celtic and Rangers take the pointing out of this flawed domestic picture as a slight. It’s their bald-men-and-comb fight; and how dare anybody undermine it. It is as if their beloved clubs are being blamed for this hopeless scenario. Which they clearly are not.

Strangely, celebrations from the Old Firm’s away supports at Livingston, St Johnstone or Ross County are wilder than when the league was a far more appealing contest. There are two explanations for that. Perhaps those punters are trying to convince themselves that routine strolls in the park are wonderful. Or, as is more likely, the obsession of remaining one step ahead of their city rivals is all‑consuming. Ten other Premiership teams are necessary cannon fodder until the Scottish Professional Football League cuts to the chase and lets the Old Firm play each other 38 times.

Spending power and population reach are the reasons for this unbalanced mess. The solution is much trickier to pinpoint. Celtic and Rangers will have no problem highlighting disparity around their Champions League involvement but the blunt reality of their key players regularly earning 20, 25 or 30 times the wages of domestic opposition goes unremarked upon as parties are thrown after the trouncing of Kilmarnock. The Ayrshire club’s annual income is less than Celtic spent on Jota, who scored in a 5-0 rout at Rugby Park in mid-August.

Neither Celtic nor Rangers would ever agree to the splitting of gate monies to assist those seeking to challenge them. Sky’s imminent renewal of Scotland’s main broadcast deal will retain the requirement for four Old Firm matches per season, removing the possibility of a bigger league to at least create the illusion of a challenge. Cross-border competition could save Scotland’s problems but it is difficult to foresee what English Premier League clubs have to gain from a tartan invasion.

The inevitable intensity of Saturday’s Old Firm match is to be admired and enjoyed. However, it will fail to disguise the unsatisfactory domain that is Scotland’s Premiership. Only the blinkered can deny that.


Ewan Murray

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Brendan Rodgers poised to reap benefit from Celtic’s Premiership primacy
Celtic are overwhelming favourites to win their sixth title in a row in a season when Rangers make their return to the Scottish Premiership after four years

Ewan Murray

05, Aug, 2016 @10:18 PM

Article image
Celtic chase a perfect 10 but how long can two-team competition continue? | Ewan Murray
Old Firm are the only serious rivals to each other in a Premiership where third place to the rest represents glorious success

Ewan Murray

31, Jul, 2020 @7:00 AM

Article image
Scottish football unusually buoyant after Rangers’ summer of good intent | Ewan Murray
Rangers, Hibernian and Aberdeen have all risen to the occasion this summer as Celtic prepare to set out for an eighth title in a row

Ewan Murray

03, Aug, 2018 @9:00 PM

Article image
Scott Arfield seals Rangers’ Old Firm victory over champions Celtic
James Tavernier and Scott Arfield scored in Rangers’ 2-0 win over champions Celtic at Ibrox

Ewan Murray at Ibrox

12, May, 2019 @1:01 PM

Article image
Postecoglou will need to work Celtic miracle to deny Rangers another title | Ewan Murray
Steven Gerrard has elevated his team to a point where they could sell players and still be too good for the competition

Ewan Murray

30, Jul, 2021 @12:44 PM

Article image
Europa League progress for Celtic and Rangers should not bring wild celebration
Scotland’s big two merrily portray themselves as global powerhouses so let’s leave the superlatives over reaching the last 32

Ewan Murray

13, Dec, 2019 @1:28 PM

Article image
New Lennon plays it cool before his first Old Firm renewal | Ewan Murray
Neil Lennon, back as Celtic manager, says his future will not be defined by Sunday’s game against Rangers as he looks forward to pitting his wits against Steven Gerrard

Ewan Murray

29, Mar, 2019 @10:30 PM

Article image
Rangers’ Clint Hill strikes late to deny Celtic in Old Firm game
Clint Hill was the Rangers hero in an Old Firm game watched from the stands by his new manager, Pedro Caixinha, with the defender’s late goal securing a 1-1 draw at Celtic Park

Ewan Murray at Celtic Park

12, Mar, 2017 @2:05 PM

Article image
Celtic's Neil Lennon confident of Old Firm victory despite Covid-hit buildup
Neil Lennon says Celtic will revel in any playing down of their chances in the first Old Firm match of the season

Ewan Murray

16, Oct, 2020 @9:30 PM

Article image
Odsonne Édouard seals Old Firm win for 10-man Celtic against Rangers
Odsonne Édouard secured a 3-2 win for Celtic, who lost Jozo Simunovic to a red card for violent conduct, against Rangers in a pulsating Old Firm match at Ibrox

Ewan Murray at Ibrox Park

11, Mar, 2018 @2:04 PM