Mahrez penalty saved as Manchester City held by Borussia Dortmund

Riyad Mahrez had his second-half penalty well saved as Borussia Dortmund joined Manchester City in the last 16 after the 0-0 draw

The final whistle was celebrated with a rasp of relief, hugs and handshakes, an exhausted but elated Jude Bellingham sinking to the turf, a stirring curtain call in front of the Yellow Wall. It meant something to Borussia Dortmund, at least. They qualified for the last 16 with a performance of maturity and ambition, one that might even – with a little more poise and penetration in the final third – have ended with all three points.

That their opponents were largely going through the motions was of only the barest relevance. Of course Manchester City came to win. It’s just that if they had really needed to, you sensed they would probably have found a way.

A draw here suited both teams fine, with City already qualified for the last 16 and Dortmund needing just a point. And for all the brief flurries of drama, including a missed penalty by Riyad Mahrez, this was ultimately a match of narrowed ambitions and thwarted plans: a learning experience rather than a red-hot contest.

So what did Pep Guardiola learn? Probably a lot that he already knew. That City at anything less than their usual feverish intensity remain vulnerable in transition. That the goalkeeper Stefan Ortega is a fine and reliable deputy to Ederson. That Julian Álvarez can be a viable Plan B when Erling Haaland is injured or rested.

Álvarez moved into the centre‑forward role when Haaland was withdrawn at half-time, and even if he enjoyed few sights of goal himself, his sharp movement and smart link play helped City exert increasing control as the game went on.

And even if the stakes were not at their highest, the atmosphere was as rabidly, raucously good as ever. The Südkurve heaved and howled and hammered out all the old tunes, a hurricane of song and aggression. They roared every block and clearance, screeched the long spells of City possession and even gave their returning star Haaland a warm welcome.

Naturally, Haaland’s lack of potency improved their mood no end. It was a quiet performance from City’s No 9, playing through a slight bout of flu and enjoying just 13 touches in comparison to the 1,006 made by his teammates. His substitution was as much a precaution as anything else, having picked up a slight knock to his foot – not serious, by the looks of things, but certainly a small crumb of optimism for Brendan Rogers, whose Leicester side face City on Saturday.

The curiosity was that City seemed to improve after Haaland went off. It had been a pale first half from them, with Dortmund enjoying several threatening moments in transition, the two best chances falling to Youssoufa Moukoko. In many ways this has been Dortmund’s Achilles heel this season under Edin Terzic: promising approach play marred by poor execution, and a consequent failure to capitalise on their dominant periods.

And as Mahrez stepped up to take a penalty he had won himself, after dropping the shoulder and drawing a clear foul from Emre Can, it felt like a familiar script was about to play out. But then Mahrez from 12 yards is its own unique kind of psychodrama, and sure enough a poor penalty was beaten away by the much-maligned Dortmund goalkeeper Gregor Kobel.

“Since I got here I don’t know how many millions of penalties we have missed,” Guardiola grumbled. “It’s a big problem. Riyad will reflect, he will practise. And for now, he will take a break.” Ominous.

But no sooner had a reprieved Dortmund begun to sense that it might be their night, the quiet waves of blue began to wash over them. In a way, this sterile domination was an impressive feat of visualisation by City, simply shrugging off the missed penalty by pretending they had actually scored it. John Stones stepped up into midfield and started directing play.

Ilkay Gündogan started to loiter further forward and shift the point of attack. Rodri made 138 passes, not that anybody – perhaps even Rodri himself – would remember a single one of them. And ultimately the yellow wall held firm; that City were not hell-bent on cracking it would prove to be Dortmund’s greatest fortune of all.


Jonathan Liew at Signal Iduna Park

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Phil Foden saves Manchester City with late winner against Borussia Dortmund
Late effort in first leg of Champions League quarter-final to give Manchester City a 2-1 victory has kept Pep Guardiola’s men in the hunt

David Hytner at the Etihad Stadium

06, Apr, 2021 @9:04 PM

Article image
Foden thunderbolt puts Manchester City in semis after Dortmund scare
Phil Foden sealed the Champions League tie from 18 yards out as Manchester City won 2-1 in Germany and 4-2 on aggregate against Borussia Dortmund

Jamie Jackson

14, Apr, 2021 @9:13 PM

Article image
Erling Haaland magic denies Dortmund as Manchester City make late comeback
Jude Bellingham gave Borussia Dortmund the lead with a header but John Stones and Erling Haaland turned the game around late on

Andy Hunter at the Etihad Stadium

14, Sep, 2022 @9:08 PM

Article image
Kai Havertz penalty drama helps Chelsea edge past Borussia Dortmund
Kai Havertz’s retaken penalty helps send Chelsea into the Champions League quarter-finals with a 2-1 aggregate win against Borussia Dortmund

Jacob Steinberg at Stamford Bridge

07, Mar, 2023 @10:17 PM

Article image
Manchester United in talks over Jadon Sancho loan to Borussia Dortmund
Manchester United and Borussia Dortmund are in negotiations over a deal for Jadon Sancho to return to the Bundesliga club on loan

Fabrizio Romano

02, Jan, 2024 @8:48 PM

Article image
‘I trust them’: Guardiola backs City to pass Dortmund test and reach last four
As he prepared for Wednesday’s Champions League quarter-final second leg against Borussia Dortmund, Pep Guardiola said he would be ‘crazy’ not to trust his Manchester City players

Jamie Jackson

13, Apr, 2021 @3:44 PM

Article image
Chelsea’s Graham Potter hails ‘special night’ after victory over Dortmund
Graham Potter said: ‘The players have been suffering; today was important,’ while Borussia Dortmund’s Jude Bellingham was unhappy at the retaken penalty

Nick Ames at Stamford Bridge

07, Mar, 2023 @11:52 PM

Article image
Guardiola delights in Manchester City ‘building history’ in Champions League
Pep Guardiola praised Phil Foden after Manchester City knocked out Borussia Dortmund to reach the Champions League semi‑finals for only the second time

Jamie Jackson

14, Apr, 2021 @10:50 PM

Article image
Nmecha winner for Borussia Dortmund dampens Newcastle’s knockout hopes
Felix Nmecha’s strike fired Borussia Dortmund to a 1-0 win over Newcastle to dent the hosts’ hopes of reaching the Champions League knockout stage

Louise Taylor at St James' Park

25, Oct, 2023 @9:01 PM

Article image
Pep Guardiola relieved with win but says Manchester City were ‘not clever’
Pep Guardiola was a mixture of relief and cautious optimism after Phil Foden’s 90th-minute goal secured Manchester City a 2-1 first-leg win in their Champions League quarter final against Borussia Dortmund

Louise Taylor

06, Apr, 2021 @11:05 PM