Modeste beats buzzer to breathe life into Der Klassiker and his own career | Andy Brassell

This was a dramatic late goal the struggling striker – and fixture – desperately needed after long period of Bayern dominance

The first to approach him was Edin Terzić, and neither man attempted to look for the right words. They just saw each other, knew what it meant, and held each other, before the coach whispered a few words of vindication to his player. Teammates had submerged Anthony Modeste instants before at the denouement of this breathless Klassiker and now they followed Terzić, queuing up to congratulate the French striker on his moment of delight and relief.

Youssoufa Moukoko, the effervescent forward half Modeste’s age who had begun the comeback and whose performances in the last week had seemed to start the process of making the older man look obsolete, hugged his senior in a touching moment – pointing to Modeste as they walked towards Signal Iduna Park’s main stand, telling those in it to give it up for the man whose header delivered Borussia Dortmund from yet more disappointment in this fixture.

Further along in that same stand Oliver Kahn had shown what it meant with his reaction to Modeste’s later-than-late equaliser. The Bayern Munich chief’s reaction is destined to be the gif of choice for the rest of this year, as he slumped back in his seat then hit his forearms forward with an “Ah Mann!” summing up the twist, the shock, the exasperation and the celebration.

Dieses Ergebnis haut einen doch vom Stuhl… Ein verrücktes Fußballspiel mit einem frustrierenden Ende für uns. Dass wir mit dem Abpfiff das Tor kassieren, ist mehr als ärgerlich.

— Oliver Kahn (@OliverKahn) October 9, 2022

This was the time for emotion, not analysis. Up until the evening’s incredible climax it was following a familiar, if entertaining, script. Bayern had threatened little in the first half yet taken the lead through Leon Goretzka’s shot from outside the area, their only real effort of note in that first 45 minutes but – thanks to a few Julian Nagelsmann adjustments – had taken a typical grip of things. In spells after Leroy Sané’s second (also from outside the box, and which also you would have expected BVB’s first-choice, Gregor Kobel, rather than current stand-in, Alexander Meyer, to have done better with) it felt as if the champions were toying with their hosts who seemed to be resigned, counting the minutes to their latest loss against Bayern, having been defeated in the last seven against them.

This was the root of Kahn’s explosion. It had seemed so easy, so inevitable that Bayern would put Dortmund down again. “It’s been an amazing season,” he mused afterwards, “where we [frequently] forget to seal the deal and deprive ourselves of what we deserve. They were dead. They had already come to terms with the defeat. But we ourselves brought them back into the game.”

Kingsley Coman’s 90th-minute should-have-been-too-late-to-matter second booking was a window into how Bayern had slid from a position of imperious comfort to indignant holding on. Sané could have followed him seconds later for aiming his studs at Karim Adeyemi after the winger held him back and referee Deniz Aytekin – despite Kahn’s chiding of his lack of “empathy” towards Coman in a Sunday morning tweet – was at his most lenient through most of this, with Jude Bellingham having earlier escaped a second booking for a high foot on Alphonso Davies that compelled the Canadian to be withdrawn.

Nagelsmann was less vocal about Aytekin and more so about his team’s strange lack of intensity in those closing stages. Could Sané or Jamal Musiala have pressured Raphaël Guerreiro more when he repeatedly recycled the ball towards the Bayern goal in the final moments with Meyer up the field and no backpass on? Probably. “In the end it’s quite fair,” he suggested, “even if the 2-2 came late.”

ABSOLUTE SCENES! 🤯#DerKlassiker | #MD9 | #Bundesliga

— Bundesliga English (@Bundesliga_EN) October 8, 2022

It had been coming, even if it felt like it might elude Dortmund. Terzić – whose pointing to the sky after the equaliser had been a nod to the recent death of his father – had leaned into the emotion of the occasion, throwing on Modeste to join Moukoko in a Hail Mary move. It worked too, with the substitute tidily setting up the starter (“he didn’t score for many games,” noted the coach, “but he didn’t keep hold of his ego”) to rifle in. It also appeared as if Modeste’s own moment had come and gone, as he missed his kick in front of goal after great work by Adeyemi, with a seemingly certain equaliser beckoning.

Dortmund’s players thank supporters in the Yellow Wall after the 2-2 draw against Bayern Munich.
Dortmund’s players thank supporters in the Yellow Wall after the 2-2 draw against Bayern Munich. Photograph: Sebastian Widmann/Bundesliga/Bundesliga Collection/Getty Images

Not only did Modeste need this – how he needed this – but Der Klassiker needed this too. In the first edition post-Lewandowski and post-Haaland, it showed what it is and what it never was. Superstars are nice to have but this was never a star-led fixture, even branded and distilled for the modern audience, but a rivalry designated by necessity. It was built as a potential beacon of hope – that there can be jeopardy, engaging battle, meaningful competition. Football supporting in the modern age, in other words, in its purest form. Modeste’s last-gasp show gave it succour, little matter if it doesn’t endure.

Hoffenheim 1-2 Werder Bremen, Borussia Dortmund 2-2 Bayern Munich, Mainz 1-1 Leipzig, Augsburg 1-1 Wolfsburg, Bochum 3-0 Eintracht, Bayer Leverkusen 4-0 Schalke, Stuttgart 0-1 Union Berlin, Hertha Berlin 2-2 Freiburg, Mönchengladbach 5-2 Cologne

Talking points

• Xabi Alonso had a strong debut as Bayer Leverkusen coach, with his side brushing aside Schalke 4-0 following the midweek sacking of Gerardo Seoane. “We didn’t have much time to plan,” Alonso said afterwards, having been appointed on Wednesday, “but the players understood how we wanted to play.” And he understood how they wanted to play, with hints at the attacking power this team possess, albeit against very limited opposition. It’s the return with Porto up next in a far-from-unsalvageable Champions League campaign. Alonso’s opposite number on Saturday, Frank Kramer, might be next out of the Bundesliga door, with former Bochum coach Thomas Reis the heavy favourite to come in.

Xabi Alonso jumps for joy during Leverkusen’s 4-0 victory against Schalke.
Xabi Alonso jumps for joy during Leverkusen’s 4-0 victory against Schalke. Photograph: Kai Pfaffenbach/Reuters

• Borussia Mönchengladbach took the Rheinderby, Daniel Farke’s team beating Köln 5-2 to recover from their own five-goal hiding in Bremen last week. It all centred around a couple of first-half clashes between Jonas Hofmann and Florian Kainz – the former fouled the latter to allow Kainz to score a Köln equaliser from the penalty spot, before the roles were reversed and Kainz received a second booking for an elbow on the Germany wide man. The always reliable Ramy Bensabaini put Gladbach back in front with his spot kick – the first of the defender’s brace – and it was one-way from there. Marcus Thuram rubbed salt in the wounds, scoring the fifth and continuing his derby teasing by reprising Modeste’s glasses celebration in front of the visiting fans – he later put a photo of him doing so on social media, with the caption “only here for the comments” and a popcorn emoji.

Hier nur für die Kommentare 🍿 #derbysieger 💚

— Marcus Thuram (@MarcusThuram) October 9, 2022

• Speaking of Werder, the neutral’s (OK, this column’s) favourites are in the top five after their win at Hoffenheim on Friday, with their fantastic front two shining again – Marvin Ducksch got a stylish opener before league top scorer Niklas Füllkrug nervelessly netted a late winner from the penalty spot.

• They got there at last – Bochum finally have a win this season and a handsome one at that, turning over Tottenham’s Champions League opponents Eintracht Frankfurt 3-0 with a late salvo inspired by Philipp Förster. The former Stuttgart man set up the first two and smashed in the third with his right foot, unbelievably (“I actually only have the right one so I don’t fall over,” he noted afterwards), to seal a long-awaited and rapturously-received win.

Pos Team P GD Pts
1 Union Berlin 9 10 20
2 Freiburg 9 6 18
3 Bayern Munich 9 17 16
4 Borussia Dortmund 9 1 16
5 Werder Bremen 9 6 15
6 Borussia M'gladbach 9 4 15
7 Hoffenheim 9 4 14
8 Eintracht Frankfurt 9 0 14
9 Cologne 9 1 13
10 Augsburg 9 -4 13
11 RB Leipzig 9 1 12
12 Mainz 9 -4 12
13 Wolfsburg 9 -6 9
14 Hertha Berlin 9 -2 8
15 Bayer Leverkusen 9 -3 8
16 Schalke 04 9 -11 6
17 Stuttgart 9 -5 5
18 VfL Bochum 9 -15 4


Andy Brassell

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Sublime Klassiker suggests there's finally life in the Bundesliga again | Andy Brassell
Borussia Dortmund’s victory despite an impressive Bayern Munich performance shows how far they have come and how competitive the German league is this season

Andy Brassell

12, Nov, 2018 @12:40 PM

Article image
Bayern rediscover benchmark with Klassiker destruction of Dortmund
Bayern Munich stalked Dortmund with intent and entitlement before pinning them into premature submission as the Bundesliga champions have done so often before

Andy Brassell

08, Apr, 2019 @9:30 AM

Article image
Der Klassiker returns with Bayern and Dortmund's rivalry perfectly poised | Andy Brassell
Tuesday’s match will be played in strange circumstances but a home win would fire up title race and keep the world watching

Andy Brassell

25, May, 2020 @12:21 PM

Article image
Borussia Dortmund 0-1 Bayern Munich: Bundesliga's Klassiker – as it happened
Joshua Kimmich’s delicious chip gave Bayern a hard-fought win that moved them seven points clear at the top with only six games remaining

Rob Smyth

26, May, 2020 @6:22 PM

Article image
Bayern close on title after Kimmich chip floors Dortmund in Der Klassiker
Joshua Kimmich’s sublime chip gave Bayern Munich a 1-0 win at Borussia Dortmund in Der Klassiker and a seven-point lead at the top of the Bundesliga with six games to play

Guardian sport and agencies

26, May, 2020 @10:12 PM

Article image
Bundesliga back with a bang as Wolfsburg and Köln burst into life | Andy Brassell
There were over 40 goals across the weekend as the league returned from its winter break in brilliant but chaotic fashion

Andy Brassell

23, Jan, 2023 @2:30 PM

Article image
Ademola Lookman slips and slides from Everton into Leipzig’s affections | Andy Brassell
Ralph Hasenhüttl has belief in the match-winning debutant who ‘only brought one pair of boots with him from England’

Andy Brassell

05, Feb, 2018 @11:05 AM

Article image
Bayern cogs turn ominously but new faces breathe life into Bundesliga | Andy Brassell
Bayern Munich might win their 11th title in a row, but between now and then we can enjoy another fascinating season

Andy Brassell

08, Aug, 2022 @2:00 PM

Article image
Bayern stumble into Coutinho quandary but Dortmund set stall early | Andy Brassell
Hertha Berlin took points off the possession-hungry champions on opening night before title rivals Borussia Dortmund crushed Augsburg

Andy Brassell

19, Aug, 2019 @12:17 PM

Article image
Der Klassiker: Bayern face Dortmund amid uncertain future
The Bavarian club sacked Niko Kovac this week and need a win against their rivals to kickstart their season

Marcus Christenson

08, Nov, 2019 @12:58 PM