SAOT ain’t slow: how does the World Cup’s AI-assisted offside system work?

Technology to assist VAR is designed to ensure offside calls in Qatar are quicker and more accurate – but it is not without flaws

What is SAOT?

It may have an acronym akin to a reality show but Semi-Automated Offside Technology, or SAOT, was designed to quell drama rather than cause it. An extension to VAR, it was introduced to help reduce problems with one of the most contentious aspects of video-assisted refereeing: how to decide if a player is offside in the buildup to a goal. It will be in use at the World Cup in Qatar.

How does it work?

In a nutshell: artificial intelligence crunches location data to map the positions of players when a ball is kicked. If the AI adjudges that a player is offside, an alert is sent to the VAR showing the “kick point” of the ball and the line of offside. After manually checking that alert, the VAR official informs the referee and any on-field decision is amended accordingly.

A SAOT decision at the World Cup will be made using data sent from a sensor inside the ball, the Adidas Al Rihla, transmitting its location 500 times a second, alongside that of 12 tracking cameras around the stadium that follow both the ball and 29 different points on a player’s body (the cameras relay their information 50 times a second). The AI will also create a 3D graphic showing the line of offside and the position of players relative to it. That graphic will be generated after the decision is taken and shown to fans inside the stadium and on TV.

It was a World Cup like no other. For the last 12 years the Guardian has been reporting on the issues surrounding Qatar 2022, from corruption and human rights abuses to the treatment of migrant workers and discriminatory laws. The best of our journalism is gathered on our dedicated Qatar: Beyond the Football home page for those who want to go deeper into the issues beyond the pitch.

Guardian reporting goes far beyond what happens on the pitch. Support our investigative journalism today.

Why has it been introduced?

Law 11 of the football rulebook starts out clearly enough: a player is offside, it says, if “any part of the head, body or feet is nearer to the opponents’ goal line than both the ball and the second-last opponent”. But there are qualifications that must be applied to that rule. For example: a player can be offside only in the opponent’s half of the field and cannot be offside if an opponent had deliberately touched the ball last. These qualifications are subject to further revisions, too. This season the rule-making body, Ifab, was forced to clarify what “deliberate” meant, an explanation that ran to 400 words.

Given its complexity it is not surprising the offside law has provided the greatest challenges for VAR. The basic setup has an official remotely assessing an incident by replaying video footage. Such limitations did not take long to manifest themselves after VAR’s introduction to the Premier League. Video footage often cannot capture the precise moment a ball is kicked, while offside lines were also determined manually. In the case of a high-stakes decision, where the difference between a goal or not is a matter of millimetres, such an approach instantly created the possibility for frustration. Perhaps more crucially, these decisions could take several minutes to be made.

SAOT came with the promise that it would be both more precise and quicker, cutting decision times from an average of 70 seconds to 25. Fifa’s head of refereeing, Pierluigi Collina, described SAOT as “faster and more accurate” and “offering better communication to fans”.

A video assistant referee in action during the last World Cup in Russia
A video assistant referee in action during the last World Cup in Russia. Broadly, VAR worked well during the tournament. Photograph: Mladen Antonov/AFP/Getty Images

Where has it been tested?

SAOT made its debut at the Arab Cup in Qatar last year. It has also been taken up by Uefa for this season’s Champions League.

Has it passed the test?

While there is little controversy over the accuracy of decisions under SAOT, calls that judge a player offside by margins not visible in the stadium, or on the video screen, remain controversial with managers and supporters. The main issue with SAOT, however, remains the reason it was brought in in the first place: timing.

The Arab Cup passed smoothly but examples unearthed by the ESPN journalist Dale Johnson found delays of well over a minute and, in one instance, over two minutes in making calls on goals with potential offside incidents. This pattern has spilled over into the Champions League this season. Harry Kane had a winning goal ruled out against Sporting Lisbon because of the interpretation of a subclause of the offside law that took four minutes to make. There was also a lengthy delay in Liverpool v Napoli and controversy following an overturned Patrik Schick goal for Bayer Leverkusen against Club Brugge.

In the Kane example it is hard not to imagine that the delay was generated not so much by the technology than by the subsequent intervention of human beings whose job it was to apply the offside law in full. Human fallibility and/or subjectivity, alongside the complexity of rules that have been written by humans (handball being not far behind offside in this regard), remain the biggest hurdle to VAR working efficiently. Uefa notes, however, that offside decisions are taking on average 30 seconds less to complete in the Champions League than in this season’s Europa League, where basic VAR is still in operation.

In previous Fifa tournaments, namely the men’s World Cup of 2018 and the women’s of 2019, VAR managed to avoid taking centre stage, perhaps due to greater discretion being allowed to the officials on the pitch – something a lot of fans would like to see more consistently. If that is the case again in Qatar, the hope might yet be for the upside of correct decisions without the pain of soul-sapping delays.


Paul MacInnes

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
VAR still a work in progress so expect more controversy and occasional fury | Barry Glendenning
The Premier League season’s early weeks were relatively quiet but subsequent mishaps show VAR controversy is not going away yet

Barry Glendenning

10, Oct, 2021 @11:00 AM

Article image
VAR technology to be used at Russia World Cup after lawmakers’ vote
Video assistant referees will be used at the World Cup this summer after a meeting of football’s lawmakers approved change to the rules at top level

Martha Kelner in Zurich

03, Mar, 2018 @12:44 PM

Article image
Why Japan’s second goal against Spain was allowed to stand
The whole of the ball must cross the line for it to be out of play and VAR decided that at least some of it was still overhanging

Martin Belam

02, Dec, 2022 @10:42 AM

Article image
VAR is another slap in the face for the long-suffering paying spectator | Paul Wilson
The VAR experiment, which has left fans without a clue as to what is going on, has shown that control of a game is best left to the referee and linesmen

Paul Wilson

04, Mar, 2018 @9:59 AM

Article image
Liverpool ask Premier League to review VAR decisions in draw at Everton
Liverpool have asked the Premier League to review the use of VAR in their controversial 2-2 draw at Everton in the Merseyside derby

Andy Hunter at Goodison Park

17, Oct, 2020 @5:10 PM

Article image
Korean calamities of Ghandour and Moreno are antidote to anti-VAR clamour | Andrew Anthony
The officiating scandals of the 2002 World Cup must remind us why the advent of the video referee is a good thing

Andrew Anthony

24, Aug, 2019 @7:00 PM

Article image
Julen Lopetegui says ‘tactical camera’ showed Wolves goal should have stood
The Wolves manager has said he saw a ‘tactical camera’ angle that showed his side’s late goal in the 2-2 FA Cup draw with Liverpool should have stood

Jamie Jackson at Anfield

07, Jan, 2023 @11:48 PM

Article image
AI-powered technology will be used to speed up VAR offside calls at World Cup
New AI-powered technology will be used at the Qatar World Cup, Fifa has confirmed, claiming it will halve the time taken to make VAR offside decisions

Paul MacInnes

01, Jul, 2022 @8:00 AM

Article image
The heart of the World Cup: Doha Metro brings fans together
The Qatari capital’s $36bn underground rail network is a hive of activity – but its construction has carried a human cost

Paul MacInnes | Photographs by Tom Jenkins

04, Dec, 2022 @7:30 AM

Article image
England out of World Cup after Harry Kane penalty miss against France
Harry Kane had already levelled once with a penalty but missed a second to give France a 2-1 victory in the World Cup quarter-final

David Hytner at Al Bayt Stadium

10, Dec, 2022 @9:25 PM