Kelleher’s shootout saves see Liverpool scrape past Derby in Carabao Cup

Caoimhín Kelleher saved three penalties to give Liverpool a 3-2 shootout win after they were held to a 0-0 draw by Derby

Caoimhín Kelleher started this season’s Carabao Cup where he left off last time out, emerging as Liverpool’s saviour in a penalty shootout as Jürgen Klopp’s much-changed team scraped past League One Derby on a tense night at Anfield.

The Republic of Ireland goalkeeper produced three fine saves in the shootout to thwart Conor Hourihane, Craig Forsyth and the on-loan Everton striker Lewis Dobbin after a goalless 90 minutes. Harvey Elliott sealed the holders’ place in round four after 18-year-old Stefan Bajcetic and Roberto Firmino had failed to convert for Liverpool, and Darwin Núñez only just managed to beat Joe Wildsmith in the Derby goal, but this was all about Kelleher’s penalty prowess once again.

The Irishman has now saved a total of six penalties in four shootouts for Liverpool, a club record that eclipses Pepe Reina’s five. Four of his eight appearances in the competition have gone to penalties and Liverpool have won every one, including last season’s final against Chelsea, when Kelleher also scored his team’s 11th and final spot-kick. “Wow,” said Klopp, when told of Kelleher’s shootout stats and place in the record books.

“They were three really good penalties as well, all going in the corner. We never hold him back, he is an exceptional goalkeeper. He has not had the best season so far because he came back from holiday with an injury. It took him time to get back up to speed but he is ready now. He barely smiles so when he does you know it means a lot. They are insane numbers.”

Kelleher’s contribution was essential after a young and inexperienced Liverpool front line, followed by more tried and trusted big names introduced from the bench, failed to break down a well-organised and resolute Derby defence in which their goalkeeper, Wildsmith, also excelled.

Derby had the backing of an impressive 5,600 away support and the defensive structure to contain their Premier League hosts throughout. Klopp made 11 changes from the team that beat Tottenham on Sunday and gave five youngsters their full Liverpool debuts – Bobby Clark, son of the former Newcastle and Fulham midfielder Lee, the 18-year-old Spanish midfielder Bajcetic, the forwards Layton Stewart and Melkamu Frauendorf, plus the summer signing Calvin Ramsay.

Technical quality was on display from all five, with Clark’s nutmegs and midfield runs catching the eye, although their understandable eagerness to impress contributed to a sloppy first-half display by the hosts.

Harvey Elliott celebrates after scoring the winning penalty.
Harvey Elliott celebrates after scoring the winning penalty. Photograph: Jon Super/AP

Paul Warne’s side looked to hit Liverpool on the counterattack but, despite several determined runs down the right by Nathaniel Mendez-Laing, they did not have an attempt on Kelleher’s goal before the interval. Liverpool, with a more experienced defence and Alex Oxlade-Chamberlain making a rare start in midfield, controlled proceedings without seriously troubling Wildsmith in the visiting goal until the second half.

The home side’s best chance of the opening period was created and missed by Stewart. A heavy first touch by Eiran Cashin allowed the 20-year-old to feed Fabio Carvalho in space on the left. Carvalho picked out Stewart with the return cross but, while well-placed in front of goal, the striker was off-balance and skied his shot over.

The second half witnessed more attacking intent and quality from both teams, mercifully, and Derby’s captain, Max Bird, had a fine chance to break the deadlock when Louie Sibley’s dangerous low cross picked out his run into the Liverpool box. Bird’s first touch struck Nat Phillips but rebounded kindly into his path, inviting a shot that was dragged across Kelleher’s goal and wide.

Angelo Ogbonna missed the crucial penalty as a youthful Blackburn dumped West Ham out of the Carabao Cup 10-9 on spot-kicks. After 19 successful penalties Ogbonna's effort crashed off the underside of the crossbar to send Championship side Rovers through to round four following a 2-2 draw at the London Stadium. 

It was a deserved win for a callow Rovers side with an average age of just 22 and a half as Jon Dahl Tomasson made 11 changes with more than one eye on Sunday's Championship derby against promotion rivals Burnley. They led through an early goal from Jack Vale before Pablo Fornals hauled West Ham level and Michail Antonio put the hosts in front. 

But the substitute Ben Brereton Díaz, Rovers' top scorer, sent the match to a shootout and Italian defender Ogbonna was the fall guy. The result means that all six top-flight London clubs have gone out in the fourth round, with third-tier Charlton the only team from the capital in Thursday's fourth-round draw.

Boubacar Traoré's late winner sent Wolves through, the substitute striking with five minutes left to down much-changed Leeds and seal a 1-0 victory for the hosts. It settled an uneventful game which looked to be heading to penalties and gave the incoming Wolves manager Julen Lopetegui and his coaches food for thought.  

Lopetegui is due at the club's Compton training base on Friday, before watching Saturday's visit of Arsenal, before officially taking charge on Monday. The former Spain manager's lieutenants were at Molineux having already briefly introduced themselves to the squad. PA Media

Wildsmith came under sustained pressure thereafter. The Derby goalkeeper reacted sharply to change direction and save a heavily deflected shot from Oxlade-Chamberlain that seemed destined for goal. He then pushed away a curling effort from Carvalho and saw Oxlade-Chamberlain slice over after Frauendorf’s back post headed was only half cleared by Haydon Roberts.

Improvement without an end product was not enough to satisfy Klopp and with 24 minutes remaining he summonsed Núñez, Firmino and Elliott from the bench in a bid to confirm Liverpool’s supremacy. The impact of the triple substitution was almost immediate. Firmino and Elliott combined to release Oxlade-Chamberlain behind the Derby defence for the first time and, though he just got his toes to the ball, Wildsmith spread himself well to save.

Wildsmith stood firm to make impressive stops from Elliott and Firmino, while Derby substitutes David McGoldrick and Dobbin also had chances to seal victory in normal time. Then it was penalties, and Kelleher’s time to shine yet again.


Andy Hunter at Anfield

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Liverpool waltz past Derby as Coutinho and Firmino show their class
Derby County were no match for Jürgen Klopp’s stylish Liverpool as the Premier League side went through 3-0

Andy Hunter at the iPro Stadium

20, Sep, 2016 @8:58 PM

Article image
Keeper Loris Karius set for Liverpool debut at Derby in EFL Cup
Jürgen Klopp claimed he did not have a No1 goalkeeper at Liverpool as Loris Karius prepares to make his competitive debut at Derby in the EFL in place of Simon Mignolet

Andy Hunter

19, Sep, 2016 @9:32 PM

Article image
Liverpool win Carabao Cup final after beating Chelsea in penalty shootout
Liverpool won the first domestic silverware of 2022, triumphing over Chelsea in the Carabao Cup final 11-10 on penalties after a pulsating match at Wembley

David Hytner at Wembley

27, Feb, 2022 @7:32 PM

Article image
Arsenal to play Manchester City after Carabao Cup shootout win at Liverpool
Arsenal beat Liverpool 5-4 on penalties to reach the Carabao Cup quarter-finals, where they will face Manchester City

Paul Wilson at Anfield

01, Oct, 2020 @9:13 PM

Article image
Mahrez and Álvarez fire Manchester City past Chelsea in Carabao Cup
Goals from Riyad Mahrez and Julián Álvarez helped Manchester City defeat Chelsea 2-0 in the third round of the Carabao Cup

Jamie Jackson at the Etihad Stadium

09, Nov, 2022 @10:03 PM

Article image
Derby knock out Manchester United after Carson saves Phil Jones penalty
Scott Carson saved Phil Jones’s penalty in the shootout, which Derby won 8-7 after they drew 2-2 with Manchester United after 90 minutes

Jamie Jackson at Old Trafford

26, Sep, 2018 @6:22 AM

Article image
Pep Lijnders calls for more respect in Liverpool and Manchester City rivalry
Liverpool’s assistant manager, Pep Lijnders, has welcomed attempts to improve relations with Manchester City before they meet in the Carabao Cup

Andy Hunter

21, Dec, 2022 @5:52 PM

Article image
Liverpool beat Leicester on penalties after Carabao Cup quarter-final thriller
Liverpool trailed 2-0 and 3-1 against Leicester but an injury-time equaliser from Takumi Minamino set up a 5-4 shootout win

Andy Hunter at Anfield

22, Dec, 2021 @10:23 PM

Article image
Liverpool fined for fielding ineligible player Pedro Chirivella in Carabao Cup
Liverpool have been fined £200,000 for fielding ineligible player in Carabao Cup match against MK Dons in September, with £100,000 of it suspended

Mark Dobson

02, Oct, 2019 @5:48 PM

Article image
Diogo Jota double sinks Arsenal and sends Liverpool into Carabao Cup final
Diogo Jota scored twice to book a Carabao Cup final clash with Chelsea, while subsitute Thomas Partey was sent off for two yellow cards

Jonathan Liew at the Emirates Stadium

20, Jan, 2022 @9:53 PM