Argentina’s fall against Saudi Arabia may have set them on a shining path

If France are taking hope from their World Cup final opponents’ defeat in their first match, then they really ought to think again

It may feel as if a sporting lifetime has passed since Saudi Arabia turned Argentina over, but it was only three and a half weeks ago. A massive shock that animated the whole World Cup, it begged many questions, not least about the prospects for Lionel Messi and his team at this tournament.

It turned out that those prospects were rosy, and any footballing obituaries now seem hasty as Argentina have since won five games on the trot in Qatar to stand 90 minutes (or 120, or 145 with injury time) from history. On reflection, then, the Saudi upset seems even more extraordinary. Given Argentina’s 36-game unbeaten run going into the tournament, what was it that the Green Falcons had that dozens of other teams did not?

It was a World Cup like no other. For the last 12 years the Guardian has been reporting on the issues surrounding Qatar 2022, from corruption and human rights abuses to the treatment of migrant workers and discriminatory laws. The best of our journalism is gathered on our dedicated Qatar: Beyond the Football home page for those who want to go deeper into the issues beyond the pitch.

Guardian reporting goes far beyond what happens on the pitch. Support our investigative journalism today.

Good luck is probably the best place to start. Argentina were 1-0 up within the first 15 minutes and had three more goals disallowed for offside before half-time. The second of these, finished by Lautaro Martínez, was the kind of marginal call that only VAR could award.

Argentina had numerous opportunities across the match and by far the better chances. InfoGol’s calculation of the expected goals in the match rated Argentina at 2.29 compared with 0.16 for the Saudis.

It seems clear that Argentina’s dominance in the first half led to complacency in the second, when the Saudis mounted their comeback. The move that led to Saleh al-Shehri’s equaliser began with Messi being dispossessed after a loose touch. WhoScored says he has had seven poor touches in the entire tournament. After a quick ball forward, Shehri was able to get beyond a laggardly challenge from Cristian Romero to shoot across Emiliano Martínez to score.

The second goal was worse, Nicolás Otamendi underhitting a clearance before Ángel Di María, Nahuel Molina and Rodrigo De Paul undercooked their challenges to let Salem al-Dawsari have a free shot, which he buried with aplomb.

A valiant backs-to-the-wall defensive effort then saw Saudi Arabia over the line. It was marked less by defensive shape than by individual bravery, with defenders throwing themselves into challenge after challenge. It was as if they were playing in their final, and Saudi Arabia left themselves so drained that they could never match the same levels. Equally, Argentina, after conceding their advantage, were never able to recover a tempo sufficient to win. A period of intense aggression from the opposition – something matched perhaps only by Australia in the second half of their last-16 fixture – had been enough to unsettle the Albiceleste. Argentina have not been behind in a game since, so the question of how they might respond a second time has not been asked.

One final factor that should be taken into consideration is the nature of the support that day. Whereas the crowd appeared to be split 50-50 at the Lusail Stadium, it was the Saudi fans who created the noise, especially after their team’s first goal went in. Argentina have not played in an environment like that since, and will not on Sunday either.

The Qatar World Cup has turned out to be the equivalent to a home tournament for Argentina (and Morocco). They will be backed by a monstrous choir once again in the final against France.

So Saudi Arabia rode a special set of circumstances to beat the two-times winners. Their determination, energy and will to succeed could prove a model for others, but France play their own way, seemingly at their best when they feel affronted. But it is also true that whatever the Saudis achieved, Lionel Scaloni looked at his side and saw weaknesses, flaws that he immediately sought to correct.

Julián Álvarez, Alexis Mac Allister and Enzo Fernández did not start. Their introduction at various points later in the group stage brought elements of energy and dynamism that have transformed the team.

The old legs of Di María and Papu Gómez have been retired from the field. Any complacency, or a sense that Argentina could win a game at half pace, has also been notable by its absence. Whatever your opinion of the frenzied behaviour that marked the closing stages of the quarter-final with the Netherlands, there is no doubt that Argentina – deservedly two goals up with 10 minutes to go – refused to be dragged under after a comeback that deserves to sit alongside the Saudi victory as one of the highlights of this tournament. Their penalty shootout victory, meanwhile, was a triumph of confident focus.

Finally, the obligatory Messi paragraph. Something remarkable has happened to him this past few weeks. Against Saudi Arabia he seemed what a 35-year-old legend ought to be; a player with undimmed technique but an athlete in decline. Not only was that observation incorrect but it has been going further into reverse with each match. Starting with his match-winning performance against Mexico and until his fateful haunting of Josko Gvardiol, Messi has got sharper, faster and more clinical. He has played every minute of every game and has only one more match to achieve full, unimpeachable immortality. The Saudis must be grateful to have caught him when they did.

Contributor

Paul MacInnes

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Saudi Arabia stun Argentina as Salem al-Dawsari winner crowns comeback
Saudi Arabia came from behind to cause one of the biggest ever World Cup shocks, beating Argentina 2-1 after Lionel Messi’s penalty had put the South American side ahead

Andy Hunter at Lusail Stadium

22, Nov, 2022 @12:45 PM

Article image
‘We have made history’: Hervé Renard salutes ‘crazy’ Saudi Arabia victory
The head coach said Argentina had underestimated his team after Saudi Arabia beat the Copa América champions 2-1 in a huge World Cup shock

Andy Hunter at Lusail Stadium

22, Nov, 2022 @4:31 PM

Article image
Hidden near the dunes, Saudi Arabia plot another World Cup shock
Argentina’s conquerors are preparing to repeat the trick against Poland, at their quiet base 25 miles from their own border

Nick Ames in Mesaieed

25, Nov, 2022 @11:28 AM

Article image
Messi and Di María shine as Argentina rout UAE in final World Cup warmup
Ángel Di María scored two fine goals and Lionel Messi also got on the scoresheet as Argentina impressed in Abu Dhabi

Guardian sport and agencies

16, Nov, 2022 @10:22 PM

Article image
Mexico miss out on last 16 on goal difference despite beating Saudi Arabia
Mexico beat Saudi Arabia 2-1 – with their second a brilliant free-kick from Luis Chávez – but they still missed out on the last 16

Jamie Jackson at Lusail Stadium

30, Nov, 2022 @9:26 PM

Article image
Shock, disbelief, sadness – Argentina fans sombre after Saudi Arabia shock
Back in Argentina there was none of the vitriol normally reserved for the players after a surprising defeat on the greatest stage of all

Marcela Mora y Araujo in Buenos Aires

23, Nov, 2022 @7:30 AM

Article image
Lionel Messi’s international career has never felt closer to oblivion | Jonathan Liew
There is still time for Messi and Argentina to save their World Cup campaign, however, despite their shock defeat by Saudi Arabia

Jonathan Liew at Lusail Stadium

22, Nov, 2022 @5:23 PM

Article image
Saudi Arabia declares public holiday to mark World Cup win over Argentina
Region rejoices as Saudi team ‘writes history’ against South American powerhouse in group stage

Martin Chulov Middle East correspondent and Tom Phillips in Rio de Janeiro

22, Nov, 2022 @4:55 PM

Article image
‘We gave them a response’: Saudi Arabia claim their place in World Cup history
A national holiday has been declared in Saudi Arabia after their win against Argentina, for whom Lionel Messi is a ‘brand ambassador’ for Saudi tourism

Paul MacInnes at Lusail Stadium

22, Nov, 2022 @5:59 PM

Article image
Argentina 1-2 Saudi Arabia: World Cup 2022 – as it happened
Saudi Arabia rocked Argentina – and football – with two second-half goals to come back from 1-0 down and seal a famous World Cup victory.

Daniel Harris

22, Nov, 2022 @1:19 PM