USA’s Gio Reyna never had the leverage to step out of line at the World Cup

The 20-year-old is an avatar of US hopes as fans look forward to 2026. In the present he’s a useful tool for Gregg Berhalter’s many critics

Gio Reyna admitted on Monday that he sulked after being told he would have a limited role at the World Cup.

I know, I know. This is what passes for scandal in Gregg Berhalter’s America. Come back to me if your players butt or bite an opponent, get kicked out of the tournament for drugs, arrested for theft or indulge in a naked pool party.

As player-coach spats go, it’s not in the same league as the feu d’artifice that saw France’s Nicolas Anelka sent home during the 2010 tournament amid internal fissures so deep that the 2006 finalists finished bottom of their group.

It’s not even as significant as the incident that led to Weston McKennie being sent home for violating squad protocols in Nashville last year, given the midfielder’s value to the team and the negative effects that would have dogged the rest of the qualifying campaign if the incident had bred lingering rancor.

But now we have an explanation for why Jordan Morris rather than Reyna came off the bench in the 1-1 draw with Wales, and support for Guardian columnist and former US forward Eric Wynalda’s claim ahead of the Iran match that there was a “rift” between coach and player.

For why Berhalter talked about being cautious with Reyna because of “a little bit of tightness” in training, only for the player to assert that he felt “great”. For the slightly weird vibes, the vague sense of the uncanny around the Berhalter-Reyna dynamic in Qatar in what otherwise appeared to be a harmonious and happy camp.

Berhalter’s collection of T-shirts and limited-edition sneakers were more eye-catching than the 20-year-old Borussia Dortmund playmaker. But it’s strange that Reyna was so shocked and offended to be a member of the supporting cast. It would have been irrational to make him a foundation of the team given his frequent muscle injuries, including the tightness that saw him exit the US’s final pre-tournament friendly against Saudi Arabia after 30 minutes.

He featured only four times during Concacaf World Cup qualifying, starting just once, in the opener against El Salvador in September last year. (He got injured.) It would have been extraordinary for Berhalter to reshape his tactics and lineup in Qatar to integrate Reyna as a key player.

Maybe the team’s tepid performances and lack of attacking threat in the run-up to the tournament might have convinced some coaches to deal their wild card. But Berhalter opted against picking his maverick and went with the more conservative choices, the surer things, perspiration above inspiration. And that was understandable given what figured to be a hard grind against more experienced opponents. Starting Reyna would have felt like hiring a ballet dancer for a factory shift.

No one doubts his potential, but at this point in his international career he’s a nice bonus, an optional extra. If the US team were a car, Tyler Adams would be the engine, Christian Pulisic would be the accelerator and Reyna would be a fancy touchscreen. He didn’t, and doesn’t, have the leverage to step out of line and expect to get away with it.

Besides, the midfield trio of McKennie, Adams and Yunus Musah and the wingers Christian Pulisic and Tim Weah fully justified their places in the starting XI, weakening Reyna’s case even more. And the industrious and in-form Brenden Aaronson, who made four substitute appearances, deserved to be ahead of Reyna in the queue. Perhaps Berhalter could have moved Weah to a central position to make room for Reyna on the right wing, which may have helped solve the lack of production at striker. But given Weah’s effectiveness on the flank, it’s not necessarily fair to second-guess the coach in this respect.

The 2026 World Cup is too distant and Reyna’s simply not enough of a star – yet – to justify hyperbolic columns attempting to set up a showdown scenario in which this team ain’t big enough for the both of them and it’s Berhalter who’s chased out. Especially when Reyna was so obviously in the wrong. A player’s unprofessionalism – a lack of effort at the World Cup, of all places – is somehow the coach’s fault? Who does Reyna think he is? Cristiano Ronaldo?

There is, admittedly, an irony to savor in Berhalter’s leadership skills being questioned as a result of comments he made as a guest expert at a summit on leadership skills. It was naive to expect that newsworthy remarks in front of an audience would not become public. (Unless Berhalter has made up his mind to resign and so feels relaxed about speaking freely.) There’s a different level of scrutiny and interest in this US team, in a much-altered media environment compared to 1998, when Steve Sampson dropped John Harkes from the squad two months before the tournament in France for “conduct issues” but it took 12 years for the full story to emerge.

However, from Berhalter’s point of view the episode was a successful piece of man-management: he mentioned it as an example of tackling a difficult decision head-on. He, his staff and squad members addressed a conduct problem, resolved it and moved forward. Clearly it was serious, since Reyna was at risk of being sent home. Yet it did not become public until after the tournament, averting potentially destabilising scrutiny from media and fans when it really might have mattered.

Notably, despite the irritation at the leaks that Reyna conveys in his statement, Berhalter did not publicly call out the winger in Qatar despite having ample opportunities to do so, nor did he name him during the summit interview; and The Athletic broke the news.

Reyna made two appearances in Qatar: as an 83rd-minute substitute in the goalless draw with England and then coming on at half-time in the 3-1 round of sixteen loss to the Netherlands. He made scant impact during his sole extended opportunity in a match that saw the Americans knocked out because they committed individual defensive errors against clinical opponents. The idea that Reyna’s presence from the first whistle might have made all the difference as the US sought a quarter-final berth is highly dubious.

Evidence-based arguments, though, are not the point. Reyna isn’t yet an integral part of the team but he’s one of its most potent symbols: an avatar of the US’s young talent and bright future, and a useful tool here and now for Berhalter’s legion of critics.


Tom Dart

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
USA’s Gio Reyna hits back after reports of attitude problem at World Cup
The midfielder was almost sent home from Qatar for a perceived lack of effort before the team’s World Cup opener against Wales, according to multiple reports

Tom Lutz

12, Dec, 2022 @7:38 PM

Article image
No light touches: USA’s World Cup 2022 opponents profiled
Gregg Berhalter’s side will face England, Iran and one of Wales or Scotland or Ukraine in their return to the World Cup after an eight-year absence

Tom Dart

01, Apr, 2022 @7:53 PM

Article image
USA’s familiar shortcomings exposed against clinical Dutch at World Cup
The Americans are a talented young team with a bright future, but attacking profligacy and a lack of a knockout power cost them against the Netherlands

Bryan Armen Graham at the Khalifa International Stadium

03, Dec, 2022 @8:31 PM

Article image
The Netherlands: USA’s World Cup opponents – and how to beat them
The Dutch boast youth and experience along with a few exceptional individual talents. The Americans will need to be at their best to make the quarter-finals

Tom Dart

02, Dec, 2022 @4:04 AM

Article image
Age before beauty: Berhalter tweaks USA’s World Cup squad around edges
Gregg Berhalter suppressed his preference for youthful dynamism by picking old-timer Tim Ream. Given the overall youth of the roster, adding a veteran can’t hurt

Tom Dart

10, Nov, 2022 @8:00 AM

Article image
USA’s European elite sparkle then fizzle on World Cup return against Wales
Gregg Berhalter displayed a preference for players who ply their trade overseas. For large parts of Monday’s game it was clear why

Bryan Armen Graham at the Ahmed bin Ali Stadium

21, Nov, 2022 @11:32 PM

Article image
USA’s Antonee Robinson wins praise for comforting Iran players at World Cup
Much was made of the geopolitics surrounding USA’s World Cup match with Iran, but any animosity between the two countries was not reflected on the pitch

Guardian sport

30, Nov, 2022 @1:23 PM

Article image
USA’s World Cup report card: best and worst players, plus predictions for 2026
Did the US reach their potential in Qatar? Should Gregg Berhalter stay on as coach? And who will lift the trophy? Our writers have their say

Bryan Armen Graham, Beau Dure, Tom Dart and Aaron Timms

05, Dec, 2022 @11:00 AM

Article image
Berhalter denies Gio Reyna conspiracy claims as USA-Iran match approaches
The USA coach was forced to field questions on US immigration policy and inflation as well as his team’s crucial final group match

Bryan Armen Graham in Doha

29, Nov, 2022 @7:30 AM

Article image
England saved in postcolonial grudge match by USA’s invisible striker
A battling, courageous effort confirmed what many have long suspected: this US side remain a team in search of a goalscorer

Aaron Timms

26, Nov, 2022 @2:09 PM