‘Safe’ standing barriers are anything but, says former Wembley Stadium manager

  • Expert warns new crash barrier height limits are too low
  • Concerns also raised about rail seating configurations

The introduction of safe standing areas could create new safety problems in football grounds, according to Noel Jeffs, an expert in stadium operations and a former general manager of Wembley Stadium.

This month the Sports Ground Safety Authority (SGSA) confirmed that six clubs will trial safe standing areas in the Premier League and Championship from the new year. The decision follows lengthy campaigning by fan groups and years observing behaviour at a select number of grounds across the UK and Europe.

However, Jeffs has called the new rules into question, in particular over a decision to set safety standards lower than those required by regular building standards. Under building regulations, crush barriers must be a minimum height of 1.1m to prevent people falling over them, but under the guidance for safe standing trials established by the SGSA, they can go as low as 80cm, even though some of the SGSA’s own documentation states that this may not be high enough.

“What the SGSA has done is reduce the height of the barriers, which is not a risk-based solution but a performance-based one,” says Jeffs. “How have we gone from high barriers being unsafe to low barriers being safe?”

Jeffs cites the fall of a spectator during England’s Euro 2020 fixture against Croatia at Wembley (which has no safe standing) as an example of something that could go wrong. “The fan at Wembley fell from the upper tier over an 80cm barrier,” Jeffs said. “Low barriers just don’t work. The steeper the terracing the more likelihood that you will fall forward, particularly when you’re jumping up and down through excitement or you can’t see or you’ve been pushed out of the way. That’s where a lot of the risks are.”

Bradford City players at Wembley Stadium in 2013
Bradford players at Wembley in 2013; Noel Jeffs says a spectator who fell over an 80cm barrier on to a lower tier there at Euro 2020 shows 1.1m is a much safer height. Photograph: Tom Jenkins/The Guardian

Jeffs also argues that the nature of most rail seating, which allows seating areas to be used as standing sections when desired, is potentially dangerous because each row is lined up directly behind the next. This means fans have their sightlines restricted and makes them more likely to move along rows and cause further risks of falling or creating blockages on exits and gangways. “It’s a fact that if you go and stand one behind another in normal terracing you cannot see the near side touchline, so your view is obstructed,” he said. “They’ll be standing one behind each other and won’t be able to see.”

The SGSA has defended its choice of barrier heights and the type of seating installed as part of safe standing trials. It says the regulations will be an improvement on the current situation, where fans are ignoring the rules to stand in seated areas.

The head of inspectorate at the SGSA, Ken Scott, who wrote the guidance for licensed standing, argued that rather than new risks being created, “a key and major risk will be averted as soon as these rails go in”, adding: “The risk of what we call progressive crowd collapse [where one fan falling would cause another to fall and so on] is stopped because of the intervening barrier on every single row of seats and it’s for that reason that we’re comfortable with the barrier height.”

Under the guidance, clubs will be expected to convey to fans – perhaps via a code of conduct – that they should stay in their place, even if they cannot see the play. “A lot of fans have been requesting this change for a number of years now, so we’re reflecting a social norm,” Scott said. “We’re giving people choice on the basis that they will be watched, they will be monitored and that they will need to treat the latitudes they’ve been given with respect. If fans don’t behave, the local authorities have the ability to reduce capacities. I’m confident that fans will treat this really well.”

The Fiver: sign up and get our daily football email.

Jeffs is more sceptical. “Can a person fall over a low height barrier, for example during goal celebrations, on to the person standing in the row in front, causing them to fall forwards or sideways? The answer is yes,” he says. “Fans will be standing one behind each other and won’t be able to see, but it’s their responsibility to stay where they are. Of course they’re not going to do that, because [stewards] can’t make them sit now. It’s never going to work.”

Jeffs has created a form of rail seat, the 2020 stadium seat, compliant with the more stringent regulations set out in the SGSA’s central rulebook, the Green Guide, which is being trialled at Wycombe in League One. “The important thing for me was that if you put the existing recommendations from the Green Guide in there, anyone can make a seat,” he says. “It’s the perception that’s been created around this. You call something safe and people think it’s safe. But it’s not safe and that’s wrong.”

Contributor

Paul MacInnes

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
‘First step’ taken towards introducing safe standing in Premier League
Premier League clubs have agreed to hold further talks over the possibility of introducing safe standing

Owen Gibson

17, Nov, 2016 @7:40 PM

Article image
Safe-standing initiative given a lift by Premier League mood swing
Top-flight clubs are more open to rail seating and its future is an agenda item at a Premier League meeting on Thursday

Owen Gibson

16, Nov, 2016 @8:39 PM

Article image
Standing at grounds is safe, says leading stadium architect

The designer behind the new Wembley has said he would be happy to incorporate standing areas in grounds if the law was changed

David Conn in Zurich

08, Nov, 2011 @5:07 PM

Article image
Safe standing a step closer after Football League’s green light for rail seats
The government body responsible for ground safety has granted a request from the Football League to permit rail seating in 21 grounds not subject to all-seater requirements

Exclusive by Ed Aarons

10, Mar, 2017 @5:00 PM

Article image
‘It’s groundbreaking, pioneering’: Shrewsbury bring in safe standing
The League One club, who face Rotherham in Sunday’s play-off final, are the first in England to install rail seating. Will it catch on?

Paul MacInnes

24, May, 2018 @10:00 AM

Article image
Safe standing across English football moves a crucial step closer
Safe standing across English football has come a step closer after a report found it had ‘a positive impact on spectator safety’

Paul MacInnes

07, Feb, 2020 @11:37 AM

Article image
Labour calls on government to back safe standing at English football stadiums
The Premier League has come out in favour of allowing its clubs a ‘local choice’ as to whether to introduce safe standing.

Simon Burnton and Paul MacInnes

08, Jun, 2018 @9:30 PM

Article image
Safe standing at football: government to review all-seat policy
The government has commissioned a review of the all-seat policy in a significant shift towards permitting safe standing in the Premier League and Championship

Martha Kelner

05, Jun, 2018 @1:05 PM

Article image
Arsène Wenger urges Premier League clubs to embrace safe standing
Arsène Wenger has labelled the Premier League ‘conservative’ in its approach to safe standing, and called on clubs to move more quickly to implement it

Paul MacInnes

19, Apr, 2018 @9:56 PM

Article image
Safe-standing under spotlight as the government looks for answers
The government’s review of the legal ban on standing at Premier League and Championship grounds will consider new research

David Conn

05, Sep, 2018 @5:54 PM