BBC v ITV: how broadcasters did in battle to voice England’s emotions

Both sides’ coverage offered insight and tear-jerking moments but, like the game itself, the result came down to tiny details

While much of the past month has been about falling in love with an England team that represents the best of our modern country, Gary Lineker introduced England v Italy with a line straight from the 1950s. “Shouldn’t you be in church?” Lineker asked the audience. You could almost feel the befuddlement in the nation’s living rooms, alongside a quick check to make sure: it is Sundays when church happens, isn’t it?

“Shouldn’t you be at work?” was, of course, Des Lynam’s intro when England played Tunisia at lunchtime during the 1998 World Cup. It was this sense of a communal experience that Lineker was trying to tap into. Yet for all his expertise and personal charm, there’s always been a sense that the ghost of Lynam’s eloquence still haunts Gary’s dressing room, and it manifested itself on England’s big night.

BBC or ITV, ITV or BBC? It’s the question you’re supposed to deliberate over in the manner you would the removal of a portrait of the Queen from a university common room. But in the end, the truth is both channels offer insight and entertainment and have the ability to make tear-jerking montages. Just as England found in the decisive shootout, it’s the small details that matter now.

The Beeb had pulled their start forward 10 minutes to give Gary his Des moment and hand the national broadcaster an edge in a battle over what was anticipated to be the biggest live broadcast in British TV history.

ITV didn’t seem particularly bothered. They just stuck Mark Pougatch front and centre at 6.30pm and he Ronsealed 1966 right in there. “It’s a very, very long time since Bobby Moore and the boys won the World Cup,” ran his opener, before he dropped an entirely new formulation for the time since passed: “Twenty thousand days of hurt”.

From there ITV cut to a cutely edited montage, contrasting that the World Cup was closer to the Titanic sinking than we are to it now, with Harry and Raheem’s relatively serene passage to this year’s final. It was a spine-tingler, and had a lot more woosh about it than the BBC’s first effort, a recap of the Denmark semi with Raleigh Ritchie’s plodding self-actualisation anthem Stronger than Ever as the soundtrack.

Having dealt with the whole history thing straight off, ITV were free to go into the actual football, first discussing the breaking news of ticketless fans breaching the stadium, before Emma Hayes and Gary Neville chewed into the tactical details of the match ahead. The Beeb, meanwhile, just plodded around in nostalgia and recaps, the exception being a fascinating and frank encounter with the great managers who were chewed up by the Impossible Job. From Big Sam – “This country should be embarrassed about how it goes about trying to destroy people” – to Fabio Capello (who has not aged in a decade) and his “white tentacles” of 66, it was a revealing two minutes.

On commentary, we had Guy Mowbray and Jermaine Jenas for the BBC and Sam Matterface and Lee Dixon for ITV. Dixon still sounds like the old BBC man he is, a bit stiff around the collar. But Matterface, who pleaded with viewers to choose ITV midweek, has a populist twang that echoes the times. He met Luke Shaw’s opener with simply a scream of his name, and introduced the final period of extra time with a call for backbone and grit. Mowbray observed that Shaw’s strike was the earliest goal in the history of the Euro finals and gave the wry introduction to penalties: “It had to come to this, didn’t it?” And indeed, it did.

Contributor

Paul MacInnes

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
England’s dreaming: Euro 2020 final offers chance to scratch 55-year itch | Jonathan Liew
After a close, tense tussle with Denmark, England are into their first major men’s tournament final since 1966

Jonathan Liew at Wembley

07, Jul, 2021 @10:47 PM

Article image
England suffer cruel defeat but Gareth Southgate and his players lit up the summer | Barney Ronay
Italy are deserved champions at the end of a tournament where football offered hope and warmth after 18 months of isolation

Barney Ronay

11, Jul, 2021 @11:41 PM

Article image
England fans force way into Wembley without tickets for Euro 2020 final
Groups of England fans without tickets forced their way through the Wembley turnstiles before England’s Euro 2020 final against Italy, multiple witnesses have told the Guardian

Nick Ames

11, Jul, 2021 @6:17 PM

Article image
England expects? Facing Germany again sets nerves jangling
Gareth Southgate’s team have looked strong but any game with Tuesday’s Euro 2020 opponents brings up past heartaches

Sachin Nakrani

29, Jun, 2021 @7:00 AM

Article image
Keir Starmer accuses Boris Johnson of failure of leadership in anti-racism row
Keir Starmer has accused Boris Johnson of a lack of courage over his reluctance to condemn fans who boo England’s players for taking the knee

Exclusive by Jacob Steinberg

11, Jun, 2021 @2:06 PM

Article image
From New Order to Chris Kamara: England’s best and worst tournament songs
England football songs have run the gamut of emotions from misty-eyed hope to the musical expression of deep psychological malaise

Ben Beaumont-Thomas

09, Jun, 2021 @5:00 AM

Article image
England step into strange new light as fear turns to joy in win over Germany | Barney Ronay
Fans celebrated wildly and ghosts were laid to rest as England advanced to the Euro 2020 quarter-finals in style

Barney Ronay at Wembley

29, Jun, 2021 @8:53 PM

Article image
Revealed: shocking scale of Twitter abuse targeting England at Euro 2020
Exclusive: over 2,000 abusive posts directed towards footballers during games, including scores of racist messages

Caelainn Barr, Paul MacInnes, Niamh McIntyre and Pamela Duncan

27, Jun, 2021 @3:00 PM

Article image
Raheem Sterling supplies catharsis in England’s sun-kissed re-emergence | Barney Ronay
Returning crowds supplied a boisterous human touch to an encouraging Euro 2020 opener for Gareth Southgate’s team

Barney Ronay at Wembley

13, Jun, 2021 @6:24 PM

Article image
Why online abuse of England’s footballers is a problem for us all
Analysis: enabled by multibillion dollar platforms, hatred and racism have an impact across wider society

Paul MacInnes

27, Jun, 2021 @3:00 PM