Premier League changes offside guidance after outcry at Silva's goal

  • Rodri’s role in buildup to Manchester City goal prompted debate
  • Officials now told to call for offside in similar situations

Premier League referees have been given another round of guidance on how to interpret one of football’s most controversial laws, following an outcry over a player winning the ball while apparently offside.

Changes are to be made following the buildup to Bernardo Silva’s opening goal for Manchester City against Aston Villa last week. The alterations again bring into focus the disparity between the laws of the game, the spirit in which people want the game to be played, and how VAR interprets them both.

The move that led to the Silva goal began with Manchester City’s Rodri winning possession from Villa’s Tyrone Mings after running back from an offside position. Rodri was not adjudged to be offside however, because Mings had intercepted a City pass and controlled it on his chest – in official language “deliberately playing the ball”. The referee Jon Moss awarded a goal and VAR agreed.

Under the letter of the law Moss’s decision was correct but it provoked a strong reaction from fans and viewers who felt Rodri’s challenge had not been fair on the blindsided Mings.

Now the Professional Game Match Officials Board has instructed its officials to call for offside should similar situations arise.

According to the new guidance: “Where a player in an offside position immediately impacts on an opponent who has deliberately played the ball, the match officials should prioritise challenging an opponent for the ball, and thus the offside offence of ‘interfering with an opponent by impacting on the opponent’s ability to play the ball’ should be penalised.”

In a further complication, this ruling would not apply if Rodri had not challenged Mings but the ball had bounced off the Villa player and into the Spaniard’s path. A similar situation led to Villa scoring their first goal against Newcastle on Saturday, after Fabian Schär inadvertently played the ball to an offside Ollie Watkins.

The Fiver: sign up and get our daily football email.

The guidance follows an update to referees earlier in the season when officials were instructed to be more lenient in handball decisions. They were encouraged to take into account not only whether a player’s hand position was “unnatural” but whether it could have been “expected” in context of the player’s general movement.

The offside and handball laws were updated for this season by the rule-making International Football Association Board. Although the changes were officially justified as an attempt to “foster the spirit of attacking play”, many observers felt more detailed rules were a response to more minute scrutiny of contentious decisions allowed by video technology.


Paul MacInnes

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Premier League referees to be more lenient on handball after outcry
Premier League referees are to take a lenient approach to applying the new handball law after an outcry from across the game

Paul MacInnes

29, Sep, 2020 @7:03 PM

Article image
VAR set to end Premier League players ‘buying a penalty’ next season
Premier League referees will have to consider three criteria before giving a penalty while offside decisions will give forwards the benefit of the doubt again

Paul MacInnes

02, Aug, 2021 @9:30 PM

Article image
Premier League needs to stop VAR operating like a nitpickers’ charter | Paul Wilson
The system is too often introducing travesties into games instead of clearing them up and changes are needed

Paul Wilson

31, Oct, 2019 @10:30 AM

Article image
'They have to do their jobs': Guardiola slams VAR after Foden penalty call
Pep Guardiola was scathing about VAR’s decision not to award a penalty after Southampton’s Alex McCarthy clearly brought down Phil Foden

Jamie Jackson

10, Mar, 2021 @9:41 PM

Article image
Mauricio Pochettino calls for VAR in Premier League to be postponed
The Totttenham manager said he feared the new VAR system is ill-suited to the ‘dynamic’ English game

David Hytner

23, Jan, 2019 @10:30 PM

Article image
VAR’s Premier League bow provides cocktail of contrived and serious | Paul MacInnes
Grey areas were eliminated, celebrations compromised and dying swans killed off on the opening weekend

Paul MacInnes

12, Aug, 2019 @5:31 PM

Article image
VAR’s failings threaten to plunge Premier League into mire of dark conspiracies | John Brewin
What happened at Tottenham on Saturday only further erodes trust in referees in this country, which could badly damage the game

John Brewin

01, Oct, 2023 @7:00 PM

Article image
No plans for Premier League technology changes despite Villa Park farce
There are no plans to reconfigure goalline technology in the Premier League, despite the system failing during the first game of the restart

Paul MacInnes

18, Jun, 2020 @2:17 PM

Article image
VAR is getting it right despite football's wider mood of suspicion and distrust | Sean Ingle
New studies have revealed that the accuracy of ‘match-changing decisions’ has increased significantly with VAR and it has had hardly any effect on the way games are played

Sean Ingle

21, Sep, 2020 @7:00 AM

Article image
Why Japan’s second goal against Spain was allowed to stand
The whole of the ball must cross the line for it to be out of play and VAR decided that at least some of it was still overhanging

Martin Belam

02, Dec, 2022 @10:42 AM