Football still 'in the dark' about long-term risk of heading ball, says Southgate

  • England manager supports more research into dementia risk
  • ‘Everybody is more aware than ever of the impact of the illness’

Gareth Southgate believes football remains “in the dark” about the long-term risks of heading the ball and concussions sustained on the pitch.

Many former players have dementia or have died from the disease and the England manager, a former centre-half, has led calls for increased research regarding the game’s risks.

Although football’s medical protocols surrounding head injuries have been tightened appreciably in recent years, Southgate accepts there is no room for complacency. “We’re still in a position where we need more research to find out exactly the impact of concussion, of heading the ball, we’re still in the dark on a lot of those things,” he said.

In an attempt to help cast increased light on the subject the 50-year-old is joining forces with Sir Alex Ferguson and Sir Kenny Dalglish for a fundraising “Lockdown Theatre” evening on Friday 15 January. The trio will be streamed online from their homes with fans invited to join them in an anecdote-rich question and answer session in support of the Alzheimer’s Society’s Sport United Against Dementia initiative.

Gareth Southgate, pictured receiving treatment while playing for Aston Villa in 1999, says: ‘There were games where I had concussion and played on.’
Gareth Southgate, pictured receiving treatment while playing for Aston Villa in 1999, says: ‘There were games where I had concussion and played on.’ Photograph: Ian Hodgson/Reuters

“Everybody is really more aware than ever of the impact of the illness,” Southgate said. “Anybody that’s had family who have suffered know what a horrendous illness it is. So it’s a very serious situation and we want to try to support as much research as we can so that people who are playing now and in the future are as well protected as they can be.”

England’s manager is relieved to see the risks at least being taken significantly more seriously than during the days when he appeared on the pitch for his country. “The medical requirements now are way beyond [those in place] 15 years ago,” said Southgate, who swapped Middlesbrough’s defence for the manager’s office at the Riverside in 2006. “As a coach, you really have to adhere to your medical team. Protocols are much more severe than when I was playing, there were games where I had concussion and played on.

“We weren’t as aware – we just carried on, we didn’t think about it so much. That’s changed, definitely for the better. Medical care is more advanced. I think we are in a better place, but, always, we’ve got to review what we do and like all medical situations, we’re learning all the time.”

In the short term, Southgate must wait to learn what form this summer’s delayed European Championship will take but retains reason for optimism. “We’re looking forward to the summer, it’s a brilliant challenge, but a lot of uncertainty on exactly what the tournament might look like,” he said. “Will we have fans back in by then?”

The Fiver: sign up and get our daily football email.

Given current lockdown restrictions and the scale of the pandemic, scouting ranks among the myriad of tournament preparations that are no longer routine. “Like every business we’re having to be adaptable and we’re having to be sensible on how we operate in terms of meetings and attending clubs,” said England’s manager. “It isn’t so easy at the moment, but we’re very excited about the year ahead.

“And of course, with a team that are improving all the time, with lots of young players emerging, we’re, we’re very excited about the depth of young talent coming through.”


Louise Taylor

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Football should consider eliminating heading, dementia expert says
Football needs to come with a health warning and should consider eliminating heading, the leading researcher into dementia in the sport Dr Willie Stewart has said

Paul MacInnes

02, Aug, 2021 @3:00 PM

Article image
Wales defender Keith Pontin's death may be linked to heading ball
The death of the former Wales and Cardiff defender Keith Pontin may have been linked to heading the ball, an inquest has heard, while Gareth Southgate is to take part in a study

Mark Dobson

29, Jan, 2021 @5:47 PM

Article image
Gareth Southgate presses home his long-term vision for England | Daniel Taylor
It would take a shattering setback against Spain to compromise the manager-elect’s position and he set out the style of football he wants his team to play

Daniel Taylor

14, Nov, 2016 @10:30 PM

Article image
Modern footballers could be at greater risk from head injury, says academic
The Field study was commissioned by the FA and the PFA and the findings suggest modern players not at any less risk than their predecessors

Paul MacInnes

21, Jul, 2020 @11:05 PM

Article image
England’s drubbing by Hungary shows risk of over-attacking, warns Southgate
‘You’ve got to have the balance of a team right,’ the manager said as he reflected on England’s 4-0 Nations League defeat by Hungary at Molineux

David Hytner

15, Jun, 2022 @9:30 PM

Article image
England must embrace great expectations, says Gareth Southgate
Gareth Southgate wants England to build on their World Cup heroics, starting against Spain at Wembley

Martha Kelner

07, Sep, 2018 @9:47 PM

Article image
England matches create lifelong memories, says Gareth Southgate
Gareth Southgate said England matches can create lifelong memories as his side prepare to take on San Marino at Wembley

David Hytner

24, Mar, 2021 @10:30 PM

Article image
Premier League should revisit five substitutes option, says Southgate
Gareth Southgate has suggested he wants a rethink on the Premier League’s limit of three substitutions per match, and that five for this season would help reduce injuries before Euro 2020 finals

David Hytner

16, Nov, 2020 @10:30 PM

Article image
Lockdown gives England Euro 2020 planning headache, says Southgate
Gareth Southgate said all England’s preparations for Euro 2020 are currently being made on Zoom as he revealed the impact of Covid-19 on the national team

Paul MacInnes

15, Jan, 2021 @9:43 PM

Article image
European Championship delay good for England, says Gareth Southgate
Tougher opposition in the Nations League has provided a test for the squad and Gareth Southgate believes his England players have benefited from the experience

David Hytner

19, Nov, 2020 @10:30 PM