Premier League will lobby Ifab to change controversial handball laws

  • Premier League hope for review at end of season
  • PGMOL plans to roll out tweaked version this weekend

The Premier League will lobby the rule-making International Football Association Board to change the handball laws following the controversial penalty awarded against Tottenham’s Eric Dier last Sunday.

Dier was adjudged to have handled illegally, even though his back was turned, when an Andy Carroll header struck his raised arm against Newcastle. The referee, Peter Bankes, awarded a penalty, which Newcastle scored to equalise in second-half added time.

The rule that a player must be found to have handled the ball if their arm is raised above their shoulder – as was the case with Dier – will have to be followed until the end of the season but it is the Premier League’s hope that Ifab will review the law at that point.

The development comes as the referees’ body, Professional Game Match Officials Limited, plans to roll out an overhauled version of the handball law at Premier League matches this weekend.

Changes will include allowing referees greater leniency in interpreting a player’s body shape during handball incidents. In the first three match days of the season, the PGMOL instructed referees to follow the letter of Ifab’s ruling that handball should be given if a player’s arm was in an “unnatural” position. That has been changed to acknowledge that, depending on a player’s momentum or body position, an “unnatural” shape could also be “expected”. Referees will be encouraged to award a foul or penalty only if the shape is unexpected.

Other tweaks to the rules include consideration of the time a player has had to respond before handling. If a referee judges that the distance was insufficient for a player to react and move out of the way, a penalty will not be given.

The Premier League acknowledges that this is not only a change to the rules weeks after implementing them but a change in emphasis too. After Fifa took control over the use of VAR technology this summer, it placed emphasis on a consistency of decision making across different countries. These tweaks will add subjectivity to the process in England, with all the controversies and debates that will likely ensue.


Paul MacInnes

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Premier League referees to be more lenient on handball after outcry
Premier League referees are to take a lenient approach to applying the new handball law after an outcry from across the game

Paul MacInnes

29, Sep, 2020 @7:03 PM

Article image
Premier League needs to stop VAR operating like a nitpickers’ charter | Paul Wilson
The system is too often introducing travesties into games instead of clearing them up and changes are needed

Paul Wilson

31, Oct, 2019 @10:30 AM

Article image
Premier League changes offside guidance after outcry at Silva's goal
Rodri’s role in the buildup to Manchester City’s first goal against Aston Villa last week prompted the debate and Premier League officials have now been told to call for offside in similar situations

Paul MacInnes

26, Jan, 2021 @5:00 PM

Article image
No plans for Premier League technology changes despite Villa Park farce
There are no plans to reconfigure goalline technology in the Premier League, despite the system failing during the first game of the restart

Paul MacInnes

18, Jun, 2020 @2:17 PM

Article image
VAR set to end Premier League players ‘buying a penalty’ next season
Premier League referees will have to consider three criteria before giving a penalty while offside decisions will give forwards the benefit of the doubt again

Paul MacInnes

02, Aug, 2021 @9:30 PM

Article image
VAR’s Premier League bow provides cocktail of contrived and serious | Paul MacInnes
Grey areas were eliminated, celebrations compromised and dying swans killed off on the opening weekend

Paul MacInnes

12, Aug, 2019 @5:31 PM

Article image
Referees' strict rulings on unseen handball microcrimes are ruining football | Barney Ronay
Is a wonder goal really a wonder goal when skilled defenders are reduced to bouncing around with their arms behind their back?

Barney Ronay

07, Nov, 2020 @8:00 AM

Article image
Mauricio Pochettino calls for VAR in Premier League to be postponed
The Totttenham manager said he feared the new VAR system is ill-suited to the ‘dynamic’ English game

David Hytner

23, Jan, 2019 @10:30 PM

Article image
Jack Grealish ruling in FA Cup final further proves absurdity of handball | Jonathan Wilson
Jack Grealish was penalised for inadvertently touching the ball with his fingers, giving United an undeserved chance to equalise

Jonathan Wilson

04, Jun, 2023 @10:39 AM

Article image
Referees’ body to meet Manchester City over concerns about bad tackles
Manchester City have been granted a meeting with the governing body of Premier League referees to discuss Pep Guardiola’s concern regarding tackles made against his players

Jamie Jackson

21, Feb, 2018 @3:33 PM