Premier League referees to be more lenient on handball after outcry

  • Officials allowed more leeway when making decisions
  • Eric Dier incident would still have led to a spot-kick

Premier League referees are to take a lenient approach to applying the new handball law after an outcry from across the game.

This season there have been five penalties awarded for handball in three matchdays, compared with 19 across the whole of the last top-flight season. The change has been blamed on a new interpretation of handball which punishes a defender if the ball strikes their arm in an “unnatural” position.

After criticism from managers and players, Premier League club executives on Tuesday endorsed a change which would give referees more leeway in interpreting the law. The change has been endorsed by Ifab, the body which sets the laws of the game.

The strategy will be implemented from this weekend and it is expected to flip the approach applied in preceding weeks. Instead of looking for “unnatural” body shapes a referee will be invited to consider whether a player could be expected to have their arms in such a position given the way they were standing, or how they were interacting with opponents.

A separate clause in the handball rule which calls a foul if a player has the hand above their shoulder when struck will not be changed.

Under the new interpretation the majority of penalties given for handball this season would not have been awarded. They include the controversial spot-kicks awarded against Crystal Palace’s Joel Ward and Manchester United’s Victor Lindelöf. The penalty given late on against Eric Dier in Tottenham’s match against Newcastle would stand, though.

Dier called for a change in the laws following the decision, which gave Newcastle a late point. “Everyone’s on the same page,” he told the BBC. “Something has to change.”

Dier’s hand was above his shoulder, however, meaning the penalty would stand. The fact that he was caught from behind by a hard-driven ball from an opponent at close quarters would not be taken into consideration.

The change in approach comes early in a congested season and the Premier League insists it is consistent with the spirit of the new handball rules. But after Fifa took control of VAR in an attempt to standardise refereeing across the globe, three weeks in the Premier League is beginning to diverge.


Paul MacInnes

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Premier League changes offside guidance after outcry at Silva's goal
Rodri’s role in the buildup to Manchester City’s first goal against Aston Villa last week prompted the debate and Premier League officials have now been told to call for offside in similar situations

Paul MacInnes

26, Jan, 2021 @5:00 PM

Article image
Referees' strict rulings on unseen handball microcrimes are ruining football | Barney Ronay
Is a wonder goal really a wonder goal when skilled defenders are reduced to bouncing around with their arms behind their back?

Barney Ronay

07, Nov, 2020 @8:00 AM

Article image
Premier League needs to stop VAR operating like a nitpickers’ charter | Paul Wilson
The system is too often introducing travesties into games instead of clearing them up and changes are needed

Paul Wilson

31, Oct, 2019 @10:30 AM

Article image
VAR set to end Premier League players ‘buying a penalty’ next season
Premier League referees will have to consider three criteria before giving a penalty while offside decisions will give forwards the benefit of the doubt again

Paul MacInnes

02, Aug, 2021 @9:30 PM

Article image
VAR VAR voom! The Premier League gets set for video referees | Paul MacInnes
Video Assistant Referees finally arrive in the Premier League this season, ready to correct ‘clear and obvious’ errors. At least, that’s the plan …

Paul MacInnes

09, Aug, 2019 @4:00 PM

Article image
No more blunders? Video assistant referees 'could change football forever'
The introduction of video assistant referees on a trial basis in next season’s FA Cup could help bring an end to simulation and match-fixing as well as sort out red-card matters

Ed Aarons

09, Mar, 2017 @11:00 PM

Article image
Premier League will lobby Ifab to change controversial handball laws
The Premier League will lobby the rule-making body Ifab to change the handball laws following the controversial penalty awarded against Tottenham’s Eric Dier on Sunday

Paul MacInnes

30, Sep, 2020 @9:30 PM

Article image
VAR’s Premier League bow provides cocktail of contrived and serious | Paul MacInnes
Grey areas were eliminated, celebrations compromised and dying swans killed off on the opening weekend

Paul MacInnes

12, Aug, 2019 @5:31 PM

Article image
'They have to do their jobs': Guardiola slams VAR after Foden penalty call
Pep Guardiola was scathing about VAR’s decision not to award a penalty after Southampton’s Alex McCarthy clearly brought down Phil Foden

Jamie Jackson

10, Mar, 2021 @9:41 PM

Article image
Bielsa-esque Pierluigi Collina defends referees and Fifa’s new rules | Suzanne Wrack
The chair of Fifa’s refereeing committee gave an energetic presentation in Paris following controversial incidents in the Women’s World Cup

Suzanne Wrack in Paris

26, Jun, 2019 @7:31 PM