Phil Foden's freedom to flick depends on Southgate's England staying organised | Jonathan Liew

As showcased against Iceland, thrilling moments of individual expression can pay off in a clearly defined, well-honed system

The best moment of England’s marathon international week came right at its very end. In the 90th minute against Iceland, with England 4-0 ahead, Harry Maguire cleared the ball high and long towards the right touchline, where Phil Foden – already two goals to the good – gamely chased down an inevitable lost cause.

Instead, as the ball dropped from an astronomical height, Foden cheekily heel-flicked it along the touchline to himself, sending Olafur Skulason spinning through spacetime: a perfectly scandalous piece of skill whereupon, had it emanated from your own two feet, you would have been well within your rights to pick up the ball and never play again.

Iceland were agreeably pliant opponents at Wembley on Wednesday, already relegated in the Nations League and probably exhausted. However Foden’s individual performance, capped by his breathtaking devilry on the right touchline, felt like its own self-contained puzzle: a moment of individual flourish that pointed the way to any number of possible conclusions. The question, as ever, is whether Gareth Southgate will draw the right ones.

For example, you could see in Foden’s exuberant, expressive confidence the importance of having a system that plays to his strengths. You could conclude that England are best served employing the sort of attacking tactics that give their flair players the biggest possible stage. You could posit that on this form Foden must start and that on this form Jack Grealish must start. And that in order to accommodate both alongside Harry Kane and Raheem Sterling, plus at least one of Jadon Sancho or Marcus Rashford or Mason Mount, Southgate must ditch his widely despised 3-4-3 and return to the 4-3-3 that served England so well in late 2019.

This would be to draw the wrong conclusions.

The increasingly tiresome debate over 4-3-3 and 3-4-3 may have been relevant a few months ago but now feels like a red herring: a pointless wrangle over imaginary numbers. It is also largely based on a number of false dichotomies: between attack and defence, reactivity and proactivity, ambition and the lack of it. This should scarcely require pointing out but you can blitz teams with a 3-4-3 (like Marcelo Bielsa’s Chile), and you can set up a 4-3-3 to defend (like Neil Warnock’s QPR).

Gareth Southgate
Gareth Southgate (right) is in the enviable position of having a defined system and a firm grasp of the players he wants to play in it. Photograph: Tom Jenkins/NMC Pool/The Guardian

What matters far more is the inclination of the players you select, the outlook and the positional freedom with which you send them out, the conviction of your approach and the collective commitment to it. And yet a cursory glance through Thursday’s newspapers, along with the overwhelming weight of opinion online, would suggest the majority of pundits and England fans would be perfectly happy for Southgate to rip up a system he has spent the whole year working on, with maybe four games left before a major tournament.

The irony is we know exactly what would happen in this scenario, because it did happen. Four years ago, a tired and unmoored Roy Hodgson decided to cast aside his reputation for order and circumspection and discard his trusted diamond midfield on the eve of Euro 2016. It was a resounding victory for popular sentiment, neatly sidestepping the question of how to accommodate England’s wealth of attacking talent by playing it all at once. The 2-1 defeat to Iceland ended with Rashford, Kane, Jamie Vardy, Daniel Sturridge, Dele Alli and Jack Wilshere all on the pitch at once.

The irony is England are in the enviable position of having a defined system and a firm grasp of the players they want to play it. Kane as striker, with Dominic Calvert-Lewin deputising. Sterling, Sancho, Grealish, Foden and Rashford to compete for the two wide berths. Jordan Henderson, Declan Rice, Mason Mount and Harry Winks (or Kalvin Phillips) in the centre. Bukayo Saka and Ben Chilwell on one flank; Trent Alexander-Arnold and Kieran Trippier (or Reece James) on the other.

Maguire, Kyle Walker, Eric Dier, Tyrone Mings and Michael Keane (or Conor Coady) at centre-half, assuming Joe Gomez is out for the season. Three goalkeepers. That’s your squad.

If this autumn’s Nations League has taught Southgate anything it is that the gulf to the top nations will be bridged by organisation, not by talent.

France, Spain and Belgium – who all won their respective leagues – are the three to beat on depth and current form. The Netherlands, Portugal and Germany (their 6-0 drubbing by Spain notwithstanding) are just a rung below. But Roberto Mancini’s Italy, who also qualified for next year’s finals, show what is possible when a more limited group of players collectively buy in to a defined style of play.

The Fiver: sign up and get our daily football email.

All of which brings us back to Foden and his little bit of skill on the touchline. The lesson from Wednesday was that the individual outrages, the Foden flicks, the Grealish shimmies, the long-range screamers that turn big tournament games, exist largely independently of systems and formations. What inhibits them is not tactics but uncertainty, a lack of conviction, an absence of cohesion, a fear of judgment.

And so, as England and Southgate approach the home stretch, what matters is not so much the system they play but that they know and commit to it thoroughly. This, perhaps, has been the real value of the autumn internationals: a chance to drill and hone a style of play that may not yet be producing exemplary results but may well do with time. Or, put more tritely: one plan may be better than none but it’s certainly better than two.


Jonathan Liew

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Gareth Southgate's constantly evolving England begin new journey | Barney Ronay
With fewer games behind them and more in quick succession ahead, this is no time for a young squad to pause

Barney Ronay

04, Sep, 2020 @7:00 AM

Article image
Phil Foden will be 'fabulous for England for years', says Gareth Southgate
Gareth Southgate said Phil Foden had a long and fabulous England career ahead of him after the midfielder scored twice in the 4-0 Nations League win over Iceland

Andy Hunter

18, Nov, 2020 @11:50 PM

Article image
Gareth Southgate to 'hammer home' discipline message to England players
Gareth Southgate said he would ‘hammer home’ the importance of discipline to the England players in the wake of Kyle Walker’s dismissal in Iceland

David Hytner

06, Sep, 2020 @9:30 PM

Article image
Foden's sparkling double sinks Iceland and completes return from England cold
Phil Foden scored his first two goals for England to round off a 4-0 Nations League win against Iceland

David Hytner at Wembley

18, Nov, 2020 @10:01 PM

Article image
Gareth Southgate relishes England's blend of youthful joy and senior nous
Manager is delighted to be with his players for the first time since November and looking forward to the double-header with Iceland and Denmark

David Hytner

04, Sep, 2020 @10:28 PM

Article image
Summer must be the start and not an end for Gareth Southgate's England
Manager said the run to the semi-finals in Russia should be the start, not the pinnacle, of this generation’s achievements as they prepare to host Spain in the Nations League at Wembley

Dominic Fifield

07, Sep, 2018 @9:29 PM

Article image
Rice key to Southgate's new England: a team hard to beat and hard to love | Jonathan Liew
The West Ham midfielder Declan Rice has quietly become the linchpin of Gareth Southgate’s increasingly conservative England side

Jonathan Liew

18, Nov, 2020 @8:00 AM

Article image
Southgate's faith in England's class of 2018 is showing diminishing returns | Jonathan Liew
Most of the young stars who shone in Russia have stagnated, so is the manager’s faith in them based on stability or nostalgia?

Jonathan Liew

15, Oct, 2020 @6:00 PM

Article image
Gareth Southgate admits England 'got out of jail' against Iceland
Gareth Southgate said England players needed to learn from their mistakes after admitting they ‘got out of jail’ in their 1-0 Nations League win in Iceland

David Hytner

05, Sep, 2020 @9:07 PM

Article image
England’s Harry Maguire intent on staying ‘normal’ after World Cup
Excellent performances in Russia by Harry Maguire led to interest from Manchester United and plenty of autograph requests for the Leicester centre-half

Daniel Taylor

04, Sep, 2018 @9:30 PM