Modern footballers could be at greater risk from head injury, says academic

  • The Field study was commissioned by the FA and PFA
  • Modern players not at any less risk than predecessors

Modern footballers could be at greater risk of neurodegenerative disease from head injuries than their predecessors, the academic leading a landmark study into the phenomenon has said.

The Field study, jointly commissioned by the Football Association and the Professional Footballers’ Association to study dementia and other neurological diseases among retired players, last year observed a risk of such conditions three and a half times greater than among the general population.

Assumptions that a lighter ball makes neurodegenerative disease less common than it used to be are misplaced, according to Dr Willie Stewart of Glasgow University, the consultant neuropathologist leading the Field study.

“I wouldn’t predict that players in 2020 are at any less risk [of neurodegenerative disease] than the players of the 50s, 60s or 70s,” Stewart said. “People suggest that because the ball is lighter or that players are training at higher intensity that the risk has gone away. There’s nothing to support that at all. Quite the opposite, maybe it’s got worse.”

The Field study has been looking at the potential damage caused to players by heading the ball during matches and training. Stewart argues that while old leather balls might have been heavier, because of the absorption of water, the ball is now hit harder and faster and this may lead to more damaging impacts.

“It’s the speed more than the weight that has the significance in this. The modern ball stays light, but if you hit it and it travels faster and lands at a higher speed it may be causing more problems.”

Examining the potential differences in damage sustained by different generations of players is one aspect the Field study intends to examine in its remaining time, with research funded until 21 February.

In evidence released on Wednesday, the study found a much lower risk of the most common mental health disorders, such as anxiety and depression, among former players. It said they were “approximately half as likely to be admitted [to hospital] for anxiety and stress-related disorders”, conditions that include depressive disorder, alcohol use disorders, drug use disorders, and bipolar and affective mood disorders.

The findings could be explained by a greater cardiovascular health among retired players, according to Stewart. “It may just be a facet of these guys living healthier lives with lower health issues in general. What it does is put into striking contrast the high levels of neurodegenerative conditions we do have.”

Stewart was critical of the delay in introducing concussion substitutes into football, with Fifa having delayed trials because of the Covid-19 pandemic. “For a sport that had done virtually nothing, we’ve seen a change to heading training and exposure in youth levels which is fantastic,” Stewart said.

“We’ve seen talk of a new approach to looking at concussion in the adult game, but we haven’t yet seen any delivery on that. We’re still seeing football players assessed on the pitch for potential brain injury for a minute or two and then sent back into the field. In no other sport at this level is that acceptable.”


Paul MacInnes

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Landmark study reveals link between football and dementia
Former professional footballers are three and a half times more likely to die of dementia than the general population, a landmark study has found

Sean Ingle

21, Oct, 2019 @11:05 PM

Article image
Footballers could be at risk of dementia from blows to the head, study suggests
Findings show potential link between repeated sub-concussive head impacts and degenerative disease, although no clear link to football established

Nicola Davis

15, Feb, 2017 @12:01 AM

Article image
Scans can detect brain injury after repeated head impacts in sport
Study of former American footballers offers hope that damage could be diagnosed more easily

Hannah Devlin Science correspondent

24, Nov, 2021 @9:57 PM

Article image
Female footballers may face greater risk of dementia, says expert
Amateurs and professionals are sought to participate in a University of East Anglia study led by Dr Michael Grey, who said: ‘We think female players are at even greater risk’

Ed Aarons

25, Nov, 2020 @12:01 AM

Article image
Football 'doesn’t want to think it can be a killer', Dawn Astle tells MPs
Campaigners for action against neuro-degenerative disease in football have delivered excoriating testimony against the game’s authorities to a parliamentary committee

Paul MacInnes

23, Mar, 2021 @3:20 PM

Article image
Football grapples slowly with brain injury, 19 years on from Jeff Astle | Andy Bull
The inquiry into concussion feels woefully small and underresourced given what we now know about the dangers

Andy Bull

11, Mar, 2021 @8:00 AM

Article image
Football still 'in the dark' about long-term risk of heading ball, says Southgate
Gareth Southgate believes football remains “in the dark” about the long-term risks of heading the ball and concussions sustained on the pitch

Louise Taylor

05, Jan, 2021 @10:56 AM

Article image
Football and rugby facing flood of claims over head injuries warning
Neuropathologist Willie Stewart says there is clear evidence between the sports and degenerative brain condition CTE

Jamie Doward

13, Dec, 2020 @9:30 AM

Article image
PFA defends its support of former footballers suffering from dementia
The Professional Footballers’ Association says the help it gives its former players is of ‘massive benefit’ to those in need but Jeff Astle’s family claim it is too little too late

David Conn

15, Feb, 2017 @8:10 PM

Article image
Why has rugby taken so long to wake up to what boxing has long known?
New research points to small, repetitive blows damaging rugby players’ brains, but boxing established this decades ago

Andy Bull

02, Sep, 2021 @7:00 AM