Lessons from USA's matches against Mexico and Brazil: permanent coach needed

The US tried out plenty of young talent in the recent round of friendlies but they need a concrete philosophy as they look towards the 2022 World Cup

1) However the midfield looks, make sure Tyler Adams is a six

A new cycle for the US began with a 2-0 loss to an obviously superior Brazil, a 1-0 victory over Mexico side just as youthful as the opposition, and a new set of questions regarding the midfield. Against Brazil, interim coach Dave Sarachan set up defensively, giving Wil Trapp, Weston McKennie, and Tyler Adams the start. The results were mixed and likely the product of playing a side boasting impressive depth and quality, as the US frequently conceded possession and did little with it once they got it back. Matters were not much better when Sarachan added Kellyn Acosta, another central midfielder, to the group against Mexico, as they hardly found a rhythm despite playing a more evenly-match opponent. Yet, one bright spot was Adams, who had a tough time against Brazil but still managed to do the defensive work and play smart passes to advance the ball. He excelled in the final 20 minutes against a 10-man Mexico, and also managed an intelligent 35-yard run to score his first international goal. While he can do a job on the right side, it is clear that the US may have figured out at least one part of the midfield puzzle after this pair of friendlies.

2) Miazga and Brooks emerge at top of center-back pecking order

It seems as if Sarachan has established a ranking of his available center-backs, with Miazga playing both matches during the international break. Brooks left camp early, but not before putting in a man-of-the-match display against Brazil. The two seemed to connect well despite conceding twice to the five-time world champions, doing well to limit the opponent as much as they could. Brooks, having already played in a World Cup, is one of the more experienced members of the new look USMNT, and was always expected to be a starter in this cycle. However, Miazga has established himself as the current favorite to join him in the backline, doing well in the air and positionally solid against both Brazil and Mexico. Cameron Carter-Vickers played in Brooks’s absence against Mexico and looks to be third in line, though that spot may be up for grabs considering he has yet to fully establish himself at international level.

3) Figure out what to do with too few wingers in the pool

The latest USMNT squad boasted many central midfielders, but few wingers. Julian Green was really the only midfielder able to play wide, though he has spent much of the last year in the center for Greuther Fürth and played there against Mexico. Adams and Acosta got minutes out wide, but neither are at their best in that position, while the missing Christian Pulisic might be in the same scenario despite being capable on the wing. The solution may be to give DeAndre Yedlin and Antonee Robinson attacking responsibilities while slotting in at right- and left-back, respectively. Yedlin in particular has the speed that is crucial in that role. That could lead to the US playing a back three, allowing Brooks, Miazga, and Carter-Vickers to play together.

4) Assess whether some of the more experienced players still have a role to play

Somewhat forgotten in the last ten months have been the leaders from the 2018 World Cup qualifying campaign. Since then, the team has quickly ushered in a younger generation of players that may comprise one of the better US rosters in recent history. Yet, there are some obvious holes in that pool. In addition to the lack of depth in wide positions, the US is lacking options at forward. Bobby Wood and Gyasi Zardes split starts against Brazil and Mexico, but neither truly impressed, while Andrija Novakovich got too few minutes to prove his worth one way or another. In that case, Jozy Altidore is arguably the player best suited to play up front. With spots relatively full at goalkeeper, center-back, and central midfield, those that are older, like Michael Bradley and Geoff Cameron, may miss out if the US make it to the 2022 World Cup.

5) The USMNT needs a vision, delivered by a permanent head coach

While Sarachan’s work as an interim coach has bee useful – he has expanded the player pool and given young players opportunities – but he may have overstayed his welcome. The team lacks genuine personality under him, which is fine for a short period. However, it gives his successor less time to work with the players before the team returns to competitive action in next year’s Gold Cup. Sarachan’s conservative set-up leads to matches where the US looks aimless, making it very difficult to beat teams with more concrete philosophies. Additionally, any emerging issues on the pitch can only be solved by someone with a long-term plan in mind, which is a difficult ask of an interim manager. Only then can the US take advantage of its most exciting pool in recent memory, and perhaps realize the potential many have been discussing over the last year.

Contributor

Pardeep Cattry

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Talking points from USA's matches against Colombia and Peru: who will replace Dempsey?
Sarachan has done his job; Berhalter looks like the new coach; Bradley may not be the answer but he’s the best version of the question

Graham Parker

17, Oct, 2018 @2:49 AM

Article image
What we learned from USA's qualifiers: the case for and against Pulisic
Bruce Arena will be happy after the USMNT steadied the ship with a win and a draw – and attention came back to a certain Borussia Dortmund player again

Graham Parker

29, Mar, 2017 @2:08 PM

Article image
USA's Olympic hopes left hanging in balance after 1-0 defeat to Mexico
Sebastian Soto’s giveaway cost the United States in a loss to Mexico, setting up a winner-take-all semi-final on Sunday night for a trip to the Olympics

Agencies

25, Mar, 2021 @6:02 AM

Article image
USA's new era starts with draw against European champions Portugal
Teenage midfielder Weston McKennie scored on his senior debut to help the United States to a 1-1 draw against Portugal in a friendly

Tom Dart

14, Nov, 2017 @11:09 PM

Article image
Bruce Arena's in-tray: the key issues for USA's new coach to address
The new man at the helm has his work cut out to qualify for Russia 2018 – and he must repair morale, find a new goalie, and answer the Landon Donovan question

Jamie Trecker

23, Nov, 2016 @11:00 AM

Article image
What we learned from the USA's Gold Cup triumph
Graham Parker: Tim Howard is still the first-choice goalkeeper, Darlington Nagbe shone in the midfield and Jozy Altidore remains the team’s focal point up front

Graham Parker

27, Jul, 2017 @11:57 AM

Article image
Copa América: what we learned from USA's warm-up friendlies
Gyasi Zardes is starting to become an established presence for Jürgen Klinsmann’s team, while Christian Pulisic could be the real deal

Graham Parker

29, May, 2016 @2:21 PM

Article image
USA's crucial win over Guatemala: five things we learned
Graham Parker: Klinsmann finally gets it right, Dempsey and Beckerman will do (for now), while the U-23s’ latest setback is a bad omen for the future

Graham Parker

30, Mar, 2016 @4:55 AM

Article image
What we learned from USA's friendlies with Brazil and Peru
Jozy Altidore can’t do it by himself, Jermaine Jones is a man without a position and Jürgen Klinsmann needs to make a statement as Mexico showdown looms

Graham Parker and Terrance F Ross

09, Sep, 2015 @2:28 PM

Article image
USA's Copa América squad: a look at Jürgen Klinsmann's selection
Brad Guzan has been preferred to Tim Howard, the midfield has an experienced, look and expect Darlington Nagbe and Christian Pulisic to get minutes

Gideon Nachman

03, Jun, 2016 @10:00 AM