Gareth Southgate faces Harry Kane dilemma as Belgium match approaches

• Manager hints he may rest captain to give others playing time
• ‘Harry knows the team is the most important thing’

As England’s footballers continue to rewrite the way they are perceived around the world, from the Spanish sports daily Marca dubbing Harry Kane “the Hurricane” to La Gazzetta dello Sport in Italy noting “a security and spectacularity that historically they never usually have”, Gareth Southgate has been encouraging his players to soak it in and enjoy the moment. It was time, according to the manager, to “get the music on and have a couple of beers”.

Only a couple, mind. Zaliv, the one nightclub in Repino, is open late only on Fridays and Saturdays and not, perhaps, a typical haunt for England’s players, given Frankie Boyle’s description of it on his BBC documentary before the tournament as “last orders at your cousin’s wedding”.

The team chose instead to stay at their hotel, toasting their early qualification for the last 16. And why not when they are even getting praise, of sorts, from an old enemy? “It is time for all of Scotland to be afraid,” according to the Daily Record, which noted England would regret it for ever if Southgate – “a bit of a dry lunch, but so what?” – did not get his hands on the “big lump of glorious gold almost winking in their direction, beckoning them to step forward and claim it for their own”.

At which point it is probably worth reiterating that England’s victories so far have come against moderate sides and, to be picky, that Southgate’s men have not managed a clean sheet in either match, with some legitimate misgivings about how they might cope at the back against more efficient opponents.

All the same, it does not feel outlandish to report a new wave of optimism inside the camp. Southgate has never gone as far as saying England are here to bring the trophy home. But he has never said it cannot happen, either. “I’ve said all along I don’t want to limit what they [the players] feel is possible,” he said. “That’s still how I feel.” And it is safe to assume Kyle Walker, for one, might have revised his position that it would need “a miracle”. Plenty of luck, perhaps, and a spirit of togetherness and durability that has been conspicuous by its absence during the undistinguished sequence of only six knockout victories in major tournaments since 1966. But not necessarily a miracle.

Harry Kane

England can certainly be emboldened by the fact they have won their opening two fixtures for only the third time since 1950, that the team are playing with energy and effervescence and that Kane, in particular, seems absolutely determined to leave his mark on this tournament.

Kane’s five-goal haul against Tunisia and Panama would already have been enough to win the Golden Boot outright in 1962 and jointly with Miroslav Klose in 2006 and Thomas Müller in 2010. He is one short of Mario Kempes’s winning total in 1978, Paolo Rossi in 1982, Gary Lineker in 1986, Totò Schillaci in 1990, Hristo Stoichkov and Oleg Salenko in 1994 and Davor Suker in 1998. Kane gives the impression he is as driven by these awards as Cristiano Ronaldo, so much so that Southgate wondered whether his captain might “have the hump” for being substituted against Panama. For Kane, it is almost an obsession to see his name at the top of the scoring charts.

The Fiver: sign up and get our daily football email.

All of which might warrant a delicate conversation if Southgate, as he appears to be leaning, has any plans to leave Kane out of the match against Belgium on Thursday that will determine which of the two teams, both already qualified, goes through as Group G winners.

Southgate, choosing his words carefully, seemed to recognise that might not go down well with his captain when he said: “Obviously it will be very important for Harry [to go for the Golden Boot]. He’s sitting proudly at the top. He’s gone ahead of some major names in English football history in terms of World Cup goals and that should make him incredibly proud. But he also knows the team is the most important thing and we have to make decisions that are right for the team. I always have to balance what’s right for the squad.”

That suggests Southgate is contemplating keeping him back for England’s first knockout tie, either in Rostov on Monday or Moscow the following day. Kane, of course, has let it be known he does not want a rest. Yet Southgate has also said that his priority is to look after some of the players who have not featured so far and, more than once, he has mentioned “the harmony” of the group. Steven Gerrard once referred to the England camp as a “five-star prison” and, behind the gates of the team hotel, Southgate is aware of the potential for the non-playing members of his squad to start feeling down and that, in turn, to create problems.

Gareth Southgate looks on during an England training session on Monday.
Gareth Southgate looks on during an England training session on Monday. Photograph: Alex Morton/Getty Images

“We have to consider everything,” Southgate said, noting his use of substitutes in the 6-1 defeat of Panama. “I felt it was important for [Jamie] Vardy, [Fabian] Delph and [Danny] Rose, who have trained so well and been such an important part of the group. There were four or five others I’d have liked to get on the pitch. I have to think through all those things – the competition for places, the players who need match minutes and keeping the unity of the squad.”

Belgium will definitely make widespread changes, with Eden Hazard and Romelu Lukaku among the players expected to be rested, and in Southgate’s case there are four outfield players – Danny Welbeck, Phil Jones, Gary Cahill and Trent Alexander-Arnold – who have not played a single minute. Dele Alli hopes to be fit again and Kieran Trippier will be closely monitored after being substituted, as a precaution, against Panama.

By the time the game kicks off, England will also have a much better idea of the pros and cons of finishing first or second and the best route to avoid a potential quarter-final showdown with Germany or Brazil. It may work out better in the long run to go through as runners-up in a group where England and Belgium are currently separated only by their bookings count. Nobody, however, should believe England, currently top, will go to Kaliningrad with the specific intention of surrendering that position.

“For our country, that would be a very difficult mindset to have,” Southgate said. “We want to win every game of football we go into. I don’t know how we would go into a game not wanting to win and play well, so I think that’s dangerous territory if we start trying to plot and predict where we might end up.”

Besides, if there is one lesson from Euro 2016 it is that England should not be so cocky to look any further than their first knockout tie, against Japan, Senegal or Colombia. “We had a really favourable draw, we all thought, in the last tournament [against Iceland] and it didn’t work out that way,” Southgate said. “We just have to keep playing as well as we can, keep preparing the team the right way, keep the momentum and I have to keep the squad involved. That’s the one thing I think is really important.”


Daniel Taylor in Repino

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Harry Kane set to start for England in group decider against Belgium
Harry Kane is likely to start for England in the Group G decider against Belgium as he resumes his quest for the World Cup golden boot

Dominic Fifield in Repino

26, Jun, 2018 @9:30 PM

Article image
Gareth Southgate: England players fully behind my Belgium decisions
Gareth Southgate says the England squad is behind his decision to rest eight players against Belgium for the Group G decider

Dominic Fifield Kaliningrad

29, Jun, 2018 @7:00 AM

Article image
England’s Harry Kane declares himself fit for third-place play-off with Belgium
Gareth Southgate will assess Harry Kane in training before determining whether his captain, pursuing the World Cup’s golden boot, will start in the third-place play-off against Belgium in St Petersburg on Saturday

Dominic Fifield in Repino

12, Jul, 2018 @9:29 PM

Article image
Gareth Southgate keeps Harry Kane waiting on England captaincy
Gareth Southgate said he was impressed with Harry Kane’s goals in the past two England games but is in no hurry to appoint his permanent captain, saying: ‘Everyone wants me to get a shift on, but I want to give myself time’

Jamie Jackson in Vilnius

08, Oct, 2017 @7:52 PM

Article image
Gareth Southgate: ‘We wouldn’t swap Harry Kane for anyone’
England manager Gareth Southgate has praised Harry Kane as ‘irreplaceable’ after his hat-trick against Panama took him top of the World Cup scoring charts with five in two games

Dominic Fifield at the Nizhny Novgorod Stadium

24, Jun, 2018 @6:18 PM

Article image
Gareth Southgate: ‘Let Germany defeat be a warning for England’
England manager Gareth Southgate has expressed surprise at Germany’s elimination from the World Cup but said it showed that ‘any team can be vulnerable’

Daniel Taylor in Kaliningrad

27, Jun, 2018 @10:13 PM

Article image
Gareth Southgate stands by Harry Kane after night to forget against Hungary
Harry Kane, who had scored in 15 consecutive qualifiers, was taken off after 76 minutes against Hungary and Gareth Southgate said: ‘I don’t think singling out players is fair’

Jacob Steinberg at Wembley

12, Oct, 2021 @10:17 PM

Article image
England’s late winner was ‘justice’ after Tunisia’s tactics, says Harry Kane
England’s captain, Harry Kane, said England, despite leaving it late, deserved their 2-1 World Cup victory over Tunisia as they should have been awarded a couple of penalties

Dominic Fifield at the Volgograd Arena

18, Jun, 2018 @9:15 PM

Article image
Gareth Southgate feared he had missed his chance to manage England
The England manager has admitted he feels ‘hugely fortunate’ to be leading his side into the knockout phase of a World Cup after fearing he had passed up his chance two years ago

Dominic Fifield in Kaliningrad

27, Jun, 2018 @9:29 PM

Article image
Gareth Southgate tells his players to change perception of England team
Gareth Southgate has said before the World Cup opener against Tunisia in Volgrograd on Monday night that his attack-minded side can change perceptions of English football

Dominic Fifield in Volgograd

17, Jun, 2018 @10:19 PM