Greggs’ arrival is no threat to Cornwall’s real pasty makers | Letters

Readers react to an article by a pasty maker on the news that Greggs will be opening a shop in Truro

Re Fergus Muller’s article (Dear Greggs, I’m a pasty maker. Here is why you are not welcome here in Cornwall, 21 November), I’d like to tell him that his pasties are indeed magnificent, as are Rowe’s, Philps, Aunty May’s and most others. There is nothing to compare with sitting, looking at the sea or some other Cornish landscape, biting into the perfectly crimped crust of a freshly bought proper Cornish pasty, in a bag, oozing with exquisitely baked peppery beef, turnip, onion and tatie. Nothing.

I seek only to reassure Fergus. I am a Cornish woman, married to a Cornish man, and I regularly make pasties from a recipe handed down to me from generations of women from Newlyn and St Just. I would even call myself a connoisseur, certainly a purist.

But we live in London now and have raised three children who frequented our local Greggs for snacks after school for many years. Not exactly haute cuisine, but tasty, and I admit that we are all partial to its sausage rolls – the vegan ones are good – the pizzas, the sandwiches, the bakes and the soups, not to mention the yum yums. But I can’t say any of us have ever noticed a pasty on sale. Pies and bakes, but not a pasty.

I was surprised when I heard of the furore in the homeland when Greggs decided to open up there. To me, it is by no means competition for a proper pasty maker, any more than a Co-op or a Marks & Spencer hot food takeaway counter is. I don’t think Fergus has anything to worry about.
Heather Strongman
Crouch End, London

• Here in Newquay, we have excellent bakers, including the Cornish chains (such as Rowe’s and Warren’s) and some splendid independents, one of which has its own bakehouse behind the shop. I see no reason to give any Cornish branch of Greggs my business. Greggs is not bad by any means, but we in the Duchy do better.
Sim Harris
Newquay, Cornwall

• Fergus Muller tells us Greggs is “never going to fly down here [in Cornwall]”. He may be right. But in the midst of a cost of living crisis, when a medium pasty from his shop costs £4 (according to its website), far more than one from Greggs, he may well be wrong, even though I’m certain that his product is far superior. Coming on top of Malcolm Bell, the head of Visit Cornwall, referring to tourists as “fucking emmets”, this sort of insularity is unlikely to see Cornwall thrive.
Ian Simpson

Have an opinion on anything you’ve read in the Guardian today? Please email us your letter and it will be considered for publication.

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Pasty wars: disquiet in Cornwall as Greggs store opens
Concerns chain, whose pasties cannot be labelled as Cornish, could threaten small bakeries

Steven Morris

07, Sep, 2018 @1:34 PM

Article image
'I won’t miss Greggs': Cornwall's pasty fans prefer the real deal
Greggs – whose pasties may not be described as Cornish – has lost its only foothold in the county

Steven Morris

17, Jan, 2020 @10:27 AM

Article image
Get ready for Greggs’ nori seaweed bake | Brief letters
Brief letters: Loneliness | Packed lunches | £50 notes | Dishwasher trays | Latin usage


02, Nov, 2018 @4:43 PM

Article image
Give us real pasties! Why Greggs is leaving Cornwall
The bakery chain has closed its only outlet in the county as people show their preference for genuine Cornish pasties

15, Jan, 2020 @5:39 PM

Article image
BBC plans to lighten up for poorer people are patronising | Letters
Letters: Content discontent | Crossword conundrum | Pasty preferences | Water companies | Tyne tributary

02, Dec, 2022 @5:09 PM

Article image
Golden opportunity or just bog-standard? | Brief letters
Brief letters: Glasses | Vegan sausage rolls | English language mix-ups | High tea | Blenheim Palace toilet theft


18, Oct, 2019 @4:56 PM

Article image
Richard Luce wasn’t so bad for the arts | Brief letters
Brief letters: Arts ministers | Jack Hobbs and Herbert Sutcliffe | Naomi Osaka | Cornish pasties | Lucy Mangan’s Toryboy


12, Sep, 2018 @4:34 PM

Article image
Pasty tax U-turn boosts Greggs shares
Greggs shares jumped 6.5% this morning to 498p after chancellor George Osborne was forced into a U-turn over the pasty tax

Josephine Moulds

29, May, 2012 @8:48 AM

Article image
Revel in Cornwall’s sublime literature | Letters
Letters: Readers Veronica Edwards, Clive Boutle and John Osborne rush to the defence of Cornish literature


04, Dec, 2018 @4:58 PM

Article image
Greggs launches vegan sausage roll
UK’s largest bakery chain acts after petition called for vegan version of bestselling product

Rebecca Smithers Consumer affairs correspondent

02, Jan, 2019 @12:15 PM