The vegan tax: Australians pay up to double for plant-based processed products

While there’s more to choose from, research by consumer group Choice shows the vegan alternative often comes at a much higher price

Despite their growing ubiquity in Australian supermarkets, vegan products are still notably more expensive than their meat-based counterparts, according to new research by consumer advocacy group Choice.

The investigation examined products across the gamut of grocery aisles, from guacamole to fruit pies, and found that processed vegan items were marked up as much as double.

In the most egregious case, a mayonnaise marketed as vegan cost almost 40% more than its “regular” alternative despite both containing only plant-based ingredients.

“Obviously there might be some manufacturing reasons why [vegan products] might be more costly to produce,” says Choice senior food journalist Rachel Clemons. “Some of the ingredients might be a bit more expensive, or there might be different processing methods or distribution costs.

“But we do think that sometimes there’s a price premium that’s added as a result of having the claim that something is vegan.”

Opportunism from brands is a clear factor, says Clemons, especially as plant-based diets become more common.

Choice also surveyed over 1,000 Australians on their attitudes and perceptions towards plant-based foods, and found that one in 10 Australians would consider going vegan in the next five years. A study by the University of Adelaide found that one in five Australians are “making a conscious effort to reduce their consumption of meat”.

Clemons compares the price premium, known as the vegan tax, to the gluten-free boom of the early 2010s, which saw brands cash in on a popular health fad. “With products that didn’t even have gluten in them in the first place – when the gluten-free claim was made on the label, it seemed to warrant pushing the price up as well.”

A shot of a woman selecting a carton at a grocery store.
‘Having vegan and non-vegan products next to each other on the shelf is frustrating because the non-vegan one is way cheaper,’ says Sophia Lekkas, who was vegan for six years. Photograph: d3sign/Getty Images

Sophia Lekkas, who was vegan for six years before transitioning into vegetarianism at the start of this year, has experienced first-hand the cost of plant-based eating.

“Having vegan and non-vegan products next to each other on the shelf is frustrating because the non-vegan one is way cheaper,” says the 25-year-old. “Visually, you’re seeing it right in front of you that it’s more expensive to be vegan.”

“I sometimes avoid these things because I don’t want to spend $8 on a bar of chocolate that I’m going to finish in a day.”

Still, Lekkas has found the increasingly mainstream status of veganism makes plant-based shopping more accessible – despite the price.

“At the start of being vegan, plant-based alternatives weren’t as popular … it wasn’t really that known to buy vegan things at the supermarket. Whereas now you go to the shops and even at the Coles bakery section there’s vegan croissants.

“The word vegan or plant-based is put everywhere – it’s very, very obvious.”

For Raveena Grover, who has also been vegan for six years on and off, it’s about negotiating the trade-off between ease and cost – particularly when it comes to the frozen foods aisle.

“You can definitely make things like vegan sausage rolls at home with cheaper ingredients [but more work] – it just depends how much you want to treat yourself.”

Both Grover and Lekkas point to vegan cheese as a product they’re happy to fork out for, and an example of how the growing uptake of plant-based practices among all Australians has increased consumer choice.

“Whenever vegans see vegan cheese, it’s like heaven’s doors are opening,” says Grover. “After not being able to eat cheese for so many years, or just having one brand and resorting to that, being able to find more and more packets of vegan dairy … is really exciting.”

As for other common products, Grover has one piece of advice for avoiding the vegan premium: ditch the supermarket chains altogether.

“Asian cultures have a lot of food that are already vegan – if you go to the Asian grocer, you’ll have cans of mock soy meat that are just as good as what you’ll get in Coles or Woolworths.

“Just because it isn’t packaged up with a fancy label doesn’t mean they can’t be the consumed all the same.”

Contributor

Michael Sun

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
‘Barely more than a pile of sugar’: Australian consumer group finds toddlers’ snacks lacking
Choice says snacks marketed for young children often have deceptive labels and added sugars

Natasha May

11, Aug, 2021 @5:30 PM

Article image
Tesco launches own-brand vegan range amid rise in plant-based eating
Wicked Kitchen range includes 18 vegan-friendly ready meals along with wraps, sandwiches and salads

Rebecca Smithers Consumer affairs correspondent

08, Jan, 2018 @12:43 PM

Article image
Nige learned to cook in immigration detention – now he's teaching Australians his recipes
Launched in response to the pandemic, a national meal kit service shares the stories and cuisines from chefs of refugee and asylum seeker backgrounds

Oliver Pelling

23, Nov, 2020 @4:30 PM

Article image
Vegan roast roadtest: 'When I wake on Sunday my face smells like vegan ham'
A vegetarian millennial and two omnivorous boomers put three popular recipes for vegan Christmas hams to the test

Calla Wahlquist

14, Dec, 2019 @7:00 PM

Article image
Meet the parents raising vegan babies
The rapid rise in veganism in the UK has been driven by young people. Here, four parents explain how to raise a vegan child safely

Guardian readers and Sarah Marsh

19, Jul, 2016 @11:12 AM

Article image
Felicity Cloake: my week as a vegan
Can a food writer survive on dairy-free ‘mylk’, substitute sausages and tofu ‘cheese’? We asked our columnist to keep a diary of her meat-free week, from the highs (vegan pizza) to the lows (a vegan barbecue)

Felicity Cloake

18, May, 2016 @3:31 PM

Article image
The A-Z of vegan food: a beginner’s guide
From aquafaba to za’atar, this handy guide offers tips on ingredients and recipe ideas for a plant-based diet

Dale Berning Sawa

12, Jan, 2019 @7:00 AM

Article image
Spring-clean your cleaners: many surface cleaning products don't actually work
Choice finds many household surface cleaners work no better than water – and some are worse

Alyx Gorman

16, Nov, 2019 @7:00 PM

Article image
Halal meat, vegan feasts: how care caterers meet diverse dietary needs
Catering for special diets is an area of increasing concern in social care, but some charities and nutritionists are stepping up to the plate

Joanne O'Connell

23, Feb, 2017 @8:49 AM

Article image
Part-time veganism: the fewer animal products I ate, the less I wanted them | Jess Ho
As a restaurant critic, I thought adopting a plant-based diet would be hard, but what started as an experiment quickly became a lifestyle choice

Jess Ho

14, Jan, 2020 @7:00 PM