To Leslie review – Andrea Riseborough is great in sad country song of a movie

Indie picture about a lottery winner who has squandered her winnings is catapulted into Oscar contention thanks to Riseborough’s remarkable, shapeshifting portrayal

To Leslie is a sad, sweet country song of a movie, with a steel-guitar twang of love and loss. Screenwriter Ryan Binaco was inspired by his own mother for this film, conjuring her memory in the spirit of Barbara Loden’s Wanda (1970) or maybe Scorsese’s Alice Doesn’t Live Here Anymore (1974). Better Call Saul producer Michael Morris makes his feature directing debut. The film is ultimately just a little contrived and its final scene is not entirely plausible, but the drama is always fiercely watchable due to an undoubtedly marvellous performance from Andrea Riseborough – who last week put this little-seen indie picture back into the conversation and made industry headlines with her sensational outsider breakthrough into the Academy Awards best actress nomination list.

Riseborough plays Leslie, a single mum who five years previously won nearly $200,000 on the Texas state lottery, a life-changing event for all the wrong reasons. Leslie squandered every dime on drink and drugs and now she is virtually homeless, a grotesque embarrassment to all the locals who celebrated with Leslie as she held the giant cheque up in front of her neighbourhood bar for the TV news cameras. She is estranged from her parents and her grownup son James (Owen Teague) – whose birthday provided the lucky numbers – and she is still entirely addicted with no intention of joining NA or AA, a subject which is never raised.

After an excruciating attempt to stay with James in the modest apartment he shares with a fellow construction worker, stealing their cash for booze, Leslie comes home to face the people for whom she now symbolises the opposite of luck. This means an ugly, painful confrontation with ex-friends Nancy (Allison Janney) and Dutch (Stephen Root) who are filled with complex rage at her and themselves: they once had to look after the son whom she neglected and abandoned, but they know in their hearts they were happy enough to party with Leslie in the good times, enabling the calamity. But she gets a cleaning job from a kindly motel owner, Sweeney (Marc Maron) and her life might still get turned around.

Andrea Riseborough received her first Academy Award nomination for her role
Andrea Riseborough received her first Academy Award nomination for her role. Photograph: Everett Collection Inc/Alamy

Riseborough brilliantly conveys a strange, almost shapeshifting figure: someone who can look almost glamorous as she drinks in bars throughout the day, but then painfully meagre and waiflike, with giant staring eyes, as if still astonished by this punchline to the bad joke of her life, awakening to another hungover collision with reality and disappointment. Most importantly, Riseborough shows that even though all the money is gone, what is left behind is the radioactivity of addiction and a strange residue of celebrity entitlement: she is now a lottery winner without the lottery winnings, a ruined queen, exiled from her rightful realm by fate, defiant in her sense that she is above all these people who now contemptuously believe themselves better than her, but probably wouldn’t have behaved any differently in her position. She didn’t get the better life she was promised. But was her life different? She had already drawn the losing ticket in the lottery of life. Maybe she was always going to be like this.

You might compare To Leslie to Spend Spend Spend (1977), Jack Rosenthal’s TV play about the unhappy British football pools winner Viv Nicholson who lost everything, but this is without the same comedy and sentimentality. Binaco and Morris find something more serious, more compassionate and also more everyday in Leslie’s story, and she is considered eligible for redemption in the classic Hollywood sense. As I say, the ending of this film does not entirely measure up to the standard of tough realism set in the rest of the drama, but what a great performance from Riseborough.


Peter Bradshaw

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Andrea Riseborough’s 10 best performances – ranked!
The British actor is up for best actress at the Oscars this Sunday for her role in To Leslie. But how does that compare with her other key turns?

Peter Bradshaw

09, Mar, 2023 @12:00 PM

Article image
Oscars to review ‘campaign procedures’ after Andrea Riseborough backlash
Film academy is implementing review after questions raised over last-minute celebrity-backed campaign in best actress category

Benjamin Lee

27, Jan, 2023 @10:04 PM

Article image
Race storm erupts after Andrea Riseborough’s best actress Oscar nomination
The To Leslie star’s unexpected nomination has led to claims of exclusion of Black performers and a revival of the #OscarsSoWhite hashtag

Andrew Pulver

30, Jan, 2023 @2:02 PM

Article image
Tom Cruise goes maverick and Riseborough goes awol at the Oscars nominees luncheon
Dominating the situation with starry generosity, Cruise took the Academy Award for best hugger – while Andrea Riseborough was nowhere to be seen

Amy Nicholson

14, Feb, 2023 @12:25 PM

Article image
‘I’d love to do a queer Titanic! Well, a queerer one!’ Director and Oscar contender Lukas Dhont
Bullied at school for his dance routine to Christina Aguilera’s Fighter, he turned to film, making zombie horrors starring his family. Now Close, his movie about a teen friendship turned sour, is up for an Oscar

Ryan Gilbey

01, Mar, 2023 @6:00 AM

Article image
Why Everything Everywhere All at Once should win the best picture Oscar
This weird, hilarious multiverse fantasy has more fresh ideas than the rest of Hollywood’s output put together, plus buckets of heart and phenomenal performances from Michelle Yeoh and Ke Huy Quan

Ann Lee

27, Feb, 2023 @8:11 AM

Article image
Last year had the slap. This year, the Oscars fight was backstage – but still on full view
After last year’s infamous slap and a build-up sullied by bad blood, Sunday’s ceremony arrives with the organisers craving calm

Catherine Shoard

10, Mar, 2023 @3:02 PM

Article image
Andrea Riseborough’s Oscar nomination upheld after academy review
British actor’s surprise inclusion in the best actress category will not be disqualified after accusations of unfair tactics although ‘responsible parties’ will be dealt with

Benjamin Lee

31, Jan, 2023 @10:04 PM

Article image
‘Masterpiece of a film’: why is every A-lister trying to get To Leslie an Oscar?
A surge of celebrity endorsements for Andrea Riseborough’s performance in a little-seen indie drama offer a strange case study in Oscar campaigning

Adrian Horton

18, Jan, 2023 @4:14 PM

Article image
Oscar nominations 2023: the full list
From The Banshees of Inisherin to Everything Everywhere All at Once, all the nominations for the 95th Academy Awards, which take place on 12 March

Guardian film

24, Jan, 2023 @5:22 PM