The Good Nurse review – Jessica Chastain and Eddie Redmayne impress in killer thriller

The true story of a nurse who became a prolific serial killer is brought to Netflix in a solid crime drama that loses steam by the end

Given our collective, at times morally dubious, bloodlust for all things true crime, one would safely assume that the story of the man considered to be the most prolific serial killer in recorded history would have already been given the podcast, documentary and miniseries treatment. But the name Charles Cullen has mostly been absent from the genre, the hows and whys of which might be somewhat explained by the intermittently effective Netflix drama The Good Nurse, a mixed bag of shock, horror and frustration.

Because telling the story of Cullen is far from easy: his crimes are scattered, his victim count unknown and his motives mysterious. The beats of his story don’t fit into the slick structure we know too well, and in this cold and surprisingly cynical film, we see the struggle of trying to make them. Between the 1990s and the 2000s, Cullen, as a nurse, killed at least 29 people but authorities believe the number to be closer to 400 – he was a silent killer who used intravenous tubes to poison patients. He’s played by Eddie Redmayne at the tail end of his killings, a new hire at a New Jersey hospital in the early 2000s. He is paired up with Amy (Jessica Chastain), a wearied single mother working night shifts while trying to hide her cardiomyopathy.

It’s in the film’s grim and granular sketching of Amy’s illness and the grind it takes to get and afford help that we start to see that this is all part of a bigger picture, the film a rather angry assault on a callous and convoluted healthcare system. To get health insurance through her job, Amy must work there for a year first. She’s a few months shy of that mark, so while the doctor (who charges Amy $980 for a test and consultation) might caution her that working in her condition could lead to death, she is left without a choice. When Charles enters the ward, it’s with a heavenly glow, someone to help her through the nights and cover for her increasingly frequent attacks. The two become close in and out of work, Charles ingratiating himself with Amy and her two daughters until an investigation into an unusual death starts to make Amy wonder who she’s friends with.

Director Tobias Lindholm and 1917 co-writer Krysty Wilson-Cairns, thankfully rebounding after the maddening mess that was Last Night in Soho, initially nail the balance of micro and macro, focusing a bit less on Charles himself and a bit more on the system that has been protecting him. After a patient dies and the hospital reluctantly calls in detectives (played by Nnamdi Asomugha and Noah Emmerich), seven weeks after, to investigate, the gradual pan back shows that even if those higher up have been aware, or at least suspicious, of wrongdoing at this or previous institutions, admitting so would mean they would have to accept culpability, everything going back to the dollar. A standout Kim Dickens embodies the chilly, corporate face of Cullen’s latest hospital, playing an evasive “risk manager”, and there’s a fun crackle to her talky scenes with Asomugha and Emmerich, both baffled by what they’re faced with.

But when the focus tightens and Chastain and Redmayne dominate, the balance starts feeling a little less interestingly modulated. While Chastain’s beleaguered and increasingly unwell single mother is nicely drawn (every moment of life-threatening over-exertion is a horribly well-ratcheted scene of tension), her friend turned antagonist is kept at a distance, one that ultimately becomes too removed for his character to register as more than a collection of statistics. In trying to maintain the mystery and to avoid overdosing on uneasy trauma, the harrowing details of Cullen’s childhood are kept to his Wikipedia page, admirable if a little frustrating. While Redmayne’s unusual looks and energy are well-suited for maximum oddness here (with an accent that’s more believable than the one he, and we, struggled with in The Trial of the Chicago 7) he’s a little too restricted by the writing to be much more than a creepy presence and so takes a backseat to Chastain.

She’s an actor who often underplays to her detriment for characters who need something a bit more pronounced, a little more involved, but it’s a minimalism that’s smartly deployed here for someone whose life is less focused on her own emotions and wellbeing and more on those around her. When her emotions do come, when circumstances force her to grapple with horror in a way she doesn’t usually give herself time for, they still come with subtlety – but of a shattering kind. A late stage scene of her having to mask tears is particularly poignant. She knows exactly when to gently push forward and also quickly pull back and while it’s unlikely to get her the same level of awards attention, it’s one of her more finely suited roles. Even when some of the dialogue goes from crackle to clunk, she still convinces.

If the final confrontation between the pair doesn’t quite satisfy then perhaps it was never going to. The nature of the story and the makers’ unusual unwillingness not to coerce the facts into something more dramatically palatable yet also more false means that we’re left wanting. I’d argue we could have been given slightly more, especially in the telling of Cullen’s crimes and past, but The Good Nurse remains a good, if not ultimately great, attempt to tell the story of a very bad person.

  • The Good Nurse is screening at the Toronto film festival and will be available on Netflix from 26 October


Benjamin Lee in Toronto

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
‘Did I notice a dark side?’: the true story behind serial killer drama The Good Nurse
The real nurse who helped capture a colleague, estimated to be America’s most prolific killer, talks about the facts behind the Netflix thriller

David Smith in Washington

03, Nov, 2022 @6:16 AM

Article image
The Good Nurse review – Eddie Redmayne and Jessica Chastain excel in gripping medical drama
Understated performances are deployed to devastating effect in Danish director Tobias Lindholm’s English-language debut

Wendy Ide

16, Oct, 2022 @10:00 AM

Article image
The Good Nurse review – Jessica Chastain is out to catch Eddie Redmayne’s serial killer
Based on the real-life story of a nurse who apparently killed hundreds of patients, this is a creepily watchable thriller with the subtlest hint of Fatal Attraction

Peter Bradshaw

20, Oct, 2022 @8:00 AM

Article image
The Forgiven review – Chastain and Fiennes light up darkly comic thriller
John Michael McDonagh’s mostly entertaining adaptation of Laurence Osborne’s novel offers an unusual mix of provocation and penance

Benjamin Lee

11, Sep, 2021 @11:45 PM

Article image
The Eyes of Tammy Faye review – Jessica Chastain nails gaudy TV evangelist
A compelling performance from the often miscast actor carries an otherwise by-the-numbers look at a Christian couple who spectacularly fell from grace

Benjamin Lee

13, Sep, 2021 @3:15 AM

Article image
The 355 review – Jessica Chastain-led action thriller is a disappointing dud
The Oscar nominee leads an impressive cast in a frustratingly rote caper that ends up being as forgettable as its title

Benjamin Lee

06, Jan, 2022 @5:00 PM

Article image
The Menu review – darkly comic foodie thriller is tasty but undercooked
Toronto film festival: Ralph Fiennes is a sinister chef with a deviously designed menu in a fun, if throwaway, stew of class satire and torture porn

Benjamin Lee in Toronto

11, Sep, 2022 @6:43 PM

Article image
After Love to The Good Nurse: the seven best films to watch on TV this week
Joanna Scanlan is superb as a widow who uncovers the secret life led by her late husband, while Eddie Redmayne and Jessica Chastain star in a chilling true-crime about a serial killer nurse

Simon Wardell

21, Oct, 2022 @8:00 AM

Article image
The Good Nurse: real-life medics cast in Eddie Redmayne film to add realism
Exclusive: Tobias Lindholm had sought to make the lead actors’ performances more ‘naturalistic’

Dalya Alberge

27, Sep, 2022 @5:00 AM

Article image
The Zookeeper's Wife review – Jessica Chastain drama is wildly inconsistent
The true story of a couple helping Jews at the Warsaw Zoo during the second world war has moments of power but also suffers from an uneven script

Jordan Hoffman

20, Mar, 2017 @3:00 PM