Cette Maison review – fragile murder tale weaves a dreamscape around grief

Miryam Charles’s beautiful and unsettling experimental film explores the unsolved killing of her cousin

Writer-director Miryam Charles’s fragile experimental film hovers on the cusp of making coherent sense throughout – and then skittishly retreats from the brink every time, like a ghost with commitment issues. It’s maddening and mesmerising in near equal measure.

There’s a profound sense of loss at the core of Cette Maison, as it weaves a dreamscape around a little nugget of biographical pain: in 2008, in Bridgeport, Connecticut, Charles’s cousin Tessa was found hanged in her room, but the autopsy discovered that she’d been raped and murdered before the hanging. The crime was never solved. The film becomes an attempt to resurrect Tessa through drama: the remarkable Schelby Jean-Baptiste plays the dead girl who offers monologues to camera about her life in Haiti before the murder, and then acts out little scenes with her mother Valeska (Florence Blain Mbaye, heartbreaking) as if she’d lived on the edges of the family.

At least, that’s one interpretation; Charles doesn’t make it easy for the viewer to work out what’s going on. Just when the narrative seems to start to come into focus, she edits away to 16mm footage shot on Haiti of beaches, mountains, ruined houses, while a mellifluous but too highfalutin by half voiceover in liquid French drones on about memory, loss, time’s passage, and so on.

Suggesting the work may have theatrical roots, the rooms where the drama unfolds are often composed of bare flats, like the partial rooms of a stage set, with a yawning blackness beyond. At one point, Valeska nurtures a lush tropical garden growing in an ordinary suburban room, like a character in a dream. The whole film is in fact beautiful and unsettling, like a visit to a stranger’s unconscious.

• Cette Maison is released on 4 November in cinemas.

Contributor

Leslie Felperin

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Menashe review – intensely emotional tale of a widower's grief
A Yiddish drama set in a Hasidic Jewish community unpicks patriarchal power politics with a powerful central turn from non-professional Menashe Lustig

Peter Bradshaw

07, Dec, 2017 @12:00 PM

Article image
Flag Day review – Sean Penn shows he’s still got it in tale of unrepentant swindler
Penn is excellent as real-life con artist John Vogel, opposite his daughter Dylan who also does well as Vogel’s journalist daughter Jennifer

Peter Bradshaw

10, Jul, 2021 @9:48 PM

Article image
Sansón and Me review – sobering account of teenager sentenced to life for murder
Director Rodrigo Reyes re-enacts his experiences with a young Mexican serving life without parole, weighing up the pressures and life choices

Peter Bradshaw

14, Nov, 2022 @7:00 AM

Article image
Mass review – impeccably acted school shooter reckoning
The parents of a teen shooter meet the parents of a boy he shot in Fran Kranz’s intelligent, sensitive drama with an unexpected ending

Peter Bradshaw

20, Jan, 2022 @7:00 AM

Article image
Ted K review – queasy inner life of the monkish, unhappy Unabomber
Sharlto Copley excels behind a straggly beard in this portrait of the serial terror-bomber, on a mission against modern technology

Peter Bradshaw

01, Mar, 2021 @8:30 PM

Article image
Too Late to Die Young review – misty tale of a changing Chile
A teenager seeks to escape from her remote commune just after the fall of Pinochet in this atmospheric but elusive drama

Phil Hoad

23, May, 2019 @6:00 AM

Article image
La Caja review – mystery box of bones ignites brooding surrogate-father tale
The final instalment in Venezuelan director Lorenzo Vigas’s trilogy about fathers and sons takes on social issues as well as emotional ones

Xan Brooks

06, Sep, 2021 @5:30 PM

Article image
The Good Nurse review – Jessica Chastain is out to catch Eddie Redmayne’s serial killer
Based on the real-life story of a nurse who apparently killed hundreds of patients, this is a creepily watchable thriller with the subtlest hint of Fatal Attraction

Peter Bradshaw

20, Oct, 2022 @8:00 AM

Article image
Prayers for the Stolen review – heart-rending tale of childhood blighted by drug cartels
Ana and her friends live in a Mexican village menaced by gangs and people traffickers in this complex and subtle story

Peter Bradshaw

06, Apr, 2022 @10:00 AM

Article image
Wasp Network review – Havana's shadow army fuels taut Cuban spy drama
Carlos director Oliver Assayas concocts an exciting and labyrinthine Miami-based thriller from a cold-war espionage story, co-starring Penélope Cruz

Xan Brooks in Venice

02, Sep, 2019 @4:19 PM